Software
Houzz Logo Print
1simplechic

Should I redo bathroom shower tile?

4 years ago

Hi everyone,
First time home renovators here! We are redoing our bathroom but aren't really loving the way our shower is coming out - we're thinking it's too busy and matches too much. While we like the shower wall tile we aren't 100% on the niche and shower floor tile. We are thinking of asking the contractor to remove the hex from the niche and use the shower wall tile there instead and to remove the hex from the shower floor and put a white herringbone tile. I've included pictures of the options. Would love to hear your input - keep the existing tiles or replace the hex with the white herringbone? Thank you!

Comments (16)

  • 4 years ago

    Before discussing style choices, let's discuss the installation. I see no waterproofing anywhere. What system is being used?

  • 4 years ago

    Waterproof a must. Love the hex for the floor. Almost looks like penny rounds. Would use wall tile for niche. Note: I am not a pro.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    The wall tiles and the hex work well together, but you need to resolve the bigger issues first.

  • 4 years ago

    There’s Kerdi everywhere, so the waterproofing is taken care of, if it’s done correctly.


    Too many tile shapes and designs and everything. Its a visual caconophy. You need a single shower tile, and a single mosaic shower floor tile. Preferably ones much less busy than the ones you chose.


    Be prepared for a BIG change order, as removing any of what was done is likely to damage the Kerdi, and impact your tiler’s schedule committments to other customers, which also translates into $$$$. This is why using a designer on the front end saves you money.

  • 4 years ago

    Thank you all for your feedback so far. Correct, Schluter Kerdi system was used for waterproofing.

  • 4 years ago

    The wall tile, while it's a pretty simple pattern layout, is a little busy. That being said, maybe a simple white penny round tile would work best on the shower floor. The white herringbone pattern may be a bit too busy. Have you thought about putting something totally different in the niche. Something with a pop of color that could tie in the vanity color, or the wall paint color. Using the same color grout throughout will tie everything together nicely. Btw, what does the bathroom floor tile look like?

  • 4 years ago

    I love what you have chosen! Looks really pretty!

  • 4 years ago


    Forget the herringbone.

    Without totally starting over, I would replace the hex tile in the niche with wall tile and be done with it.

    It is still going to be busy but grouting will tame it down some.

  • 4 years ago


    This is a bathroom I am redoing. The niche will have just a little color. Trying to complement each tile is key when you have multiple tile selections.

  • 4 years ago

    I persoanlly think it looks nice . i like how the niche marches the floor.

    i like it better than herringbone idea.


    i think it will look breat once done and would be a huge waste of money to change .

  • 4 years ago

    I remodeled my master bath last year. I have hex tile on the floor of the shower very similar to what you're showing. I really like it and it's a lot easier to install than penny tile. I did white walls instead of the marble look you are doing, but I don't see anything wrong with what you chose. If you really don't think you can live with, change the niche tile, but honestly, I like that as well. It's like anything - some people will like it and some people won't. If it were me, I wouldn't change it if it ruins the waterproofing and costs a lot of money. Chalk it up to experience. You didn't say what the bathroom floor is. As long as it isn't something busy the overall effect won't be too busy. I think a marble look is classic.

  • 4 years ago

    Thanks again for all the comments and suggestions! Here is a pic of our bathroom floor tile.

  • 4 years ago

    I think you have chosen all goes lovely together. i think the floor tile will look good with the shower tile.

    its nerve wracking seeing everything installed, but really dont second guess yourself on this. you did a good job selecring your materials and i think it wil turn out great .


  • 4 years ago

    Another vote to keep it as is. The herringbone is nice too, but I don't think it's better--just different. Maybe worth considering if you were still pre-install as an alternative, but definitely not worth ripping out already-installed tile to start again.

  • 4 years ago

    What you have is lovely. Don't second guess your choices!


Sponsored
The Creative Kitchen Company
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars52 Reviews
Columbus Area Kitchen Remodeling and Refacing Professional