Not a monstrosity at all! The current color scheme seems to pull out the yellow in the brick. You Could go with any number of shades of gray to pull out the grays. Can you post a picture of the roof? Can't quite tell what color it is.

For more comments, add Design Dilemma to your post's topics.

Muted green would work with your brick.

@Celery. Visualization, Rendering images that's beautiful! Unless the siding is vinyl, I like the idea of going darker.

Crystal, what is the siding material made of?

It’s aluminum siding in the factory finish so no problem painting it.

I really like the dark green! I thought we’d match the garage to the shutters but I like it all green too

tozmo1, the roof is a mixture of charcoal and tan

Thank you for taking the time to do that Celery! I’m sorry I can’t seem to figure out how to tag people.😅