Software
Houzz Logo Print
meeshl3

Pickled Oak Cabinets!

4 years ago

So we purchased our dream home that comes with pickled oak cabinetry. Not my choice but we loved the house. Don’t want to do a full Reno so trying to figure out what
the options are.
I thought to paint but also love the look of the white oak kitchens.
Can we save the black granite?
Floors were refinished before we purchased and I do like them.
We like the mid century coastal vibe … suggestions?

Comments (22)

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    I like your cabinets but they do lean gray and the floor finish leans warm. I might consider adjusting the cabinets to be more the color of your fireplace surround.


    Perhaps an overglaze or dark wax can be applied to the cabinets that will warm the finish. I have to admit that all the black in the room is offputting to me. I would at least change the appliances.





    Not nearly as bad as some pickled oak I've seen with red oak that has that terrible pink undertone.





  • 4 years ago

    Looks like you have nice sized rooms, great windows and a nice green backyard.

    I would be inclined to do nothing to this kitchen for 6-12 months. Get to know the kitchen and the feel of the space through a few seasons.

    Your kitchen has things I would want to change, so I would start saving for a full remodel and not waste funds on temporary fixes. These are the things I would want to change: straighten out those angles if possible, more drawers so that means new cabinets, upper cabinets to the ceiling, change the counter to something much lighter.

    In my previous house I waited about 6 years to gut the kitchen. The layout was mostly good, but the cabinets were not great quality and it had really dark counters and backsplash. There were 5 bathrooms that needed to be remodeled first!

  • 4 years ago

    @BeverlyFLADeziner I do like the gray. Would be more inclined to find some form of glaze or stain but wasn't sure on the coloring. Is it hard to do? We were looking to change the appliances to the Bespoke stainless line as I don't like the black appliances. Another thought I had was to sand the granite so it had a matte finish instead of a shine. We wanted to infuse in other rooms the mid century cream and conac coloring with black accents to tie it all together. Not sure how this will play out and look. @chispa We may eventually do something more extensive, but furnishings are first on our list ;). The views are of the marsh to deeper water in the distance, so its a beautiful natural environment in SC.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    IMO no to any glae in a MCM style kitchen ever. I think you need to live there for at least 3-6 months to see how the space functions for you The cabinets look okay the lattica abovet the fridge could go and IO stainless appliances and better lighting is where i would start I think you need 3x the number of pot lights and they should all be LEDs 4000K that will help with all the black for sure . This is never going to be a MCM kitchen without a big redo but live there and see how it works I think your ideas for decor are good please do not sand the granite it will then show every grease spot. I do know about the appliances you mention but never buy all appliance from one maker for sure there is no maker that makes everything well . The good thing with plain old stainless is it does not matter who makes the piece they all go together . If the appliances are working then wait for them too until you know how the space functions What I see right now that would make me crazy is the island making me go around to get from fridge to sink and the fact there is no proper hood above the range

  • 4 years ago

    Fantastic LR, windows, and view! I can see why you love the house. Looking through your 5 ideabooks, I am seeing mostly Glam and European Traditional, but very little coastal or MCM. I am having trouble understanding your vision of MCM Coastal for this house. Would you mind creating another ideabook for your MCM Coastal kitchen?

  • 4 years ago

    It would also help in your reno planning and spending reno money wisely if you described what long term changes to kitchen layout will make it more efficient for you to work in - and that may take at least 6 months to realize.

  • 4 years ago

    There are always so many things to do when you move, even to a house that is not that old, to make it your own. I moved to my third house 2+ years ago and am still working on those things in a 25 year old house. I am going to remodel the kitchen last, but one of things I found that really helps me is to make a list of everything I want to change, group the things together that should be done at the same time and then prioritize the list. Then I work my way through the list. Slowly is not bad as it allows you to think and plan what you're going to do. It really helps to have an overall vision of where you are going. I think some of the previous posters brought up good points about refining your style. Start compiling Ideabooks for each room. If you're changing your style from what you had before this is a good time to do it, but it helps if you have thought it through before you change anything. Also, you may have experienced this before - anytime you change one thing it makes something else look bad. :-)


    Your kitchen cabinets aren't bad. As Flo said, they could be that pinky pickled oak that was so popular once upon a time. If you are thinking about refinishing your floors you should do that first before changing your cabinets. It looks like a beautiful lot and home, so congratulations!

  • 4 years ago

    Those cabinets are really not bad for pickled oak. I think it is smart that you are starting with new stainless appliances. Yes, I'm curious about why no hood over the stove and if you can change it so you have exterior venting access.


    What bothers me the most about this space are the countertops - the color and sheen are jarring. But, perhaps with enough black in the rest of your space they will make more sense. For now I would get new tops for the island and the far corner piece. Live with the black for now. Get new drawer hardware. Get a nice MCM breakfast area table, chairs, and light fixture and see what you think. Can you post a few MCM kitchens that you like so we can see what you are going for?

  • 4 years ago

    In your case, I would live in the home before deciding on what do. The kitchen looks well cared for.

    If a complete renovation will not be in the cards within 5 years, I would look into having them professionally painted.

    White cabinets with the black granite is classic.


  • 4 years ago

    I would replace the island with an island that was all drawers...and paint it. (soft muted turquoise?) Perhaps a butcher block top on the island? And replace the sink with a single bowl sink. A proper exhaust hood over the range if possible. If there is living space above the kitchen, routing ductwork through the roof could be tricky/ next to impossible.

    I don't care for the wine rack over the refrigerator. Cabinets would be better if you can find matching cabs.

    Stainless appliances but I would replace on an as needed basis.

    Would want to replace the counters--but that is going to get spendy. If you have the budget, then yes, replace them.

    As other have said--for pickled oak, yours actually look quite good. I could live with them and they do fit in with Coastal, IMO.

  • 4 years ago

    I will build a new MCM book to give more thoughts/ideas about the kitchen. I truly appreciate the information. I do not like the wine rack above the fridge lol. I already thought it has to go. The kitchen wall where the microwave is not on an exterior wall, so my thought is that the microwave has a recirculating fan as opposed to venting to the exterior. I had thought about replacing the microwave with an updated hood and finding another home for the microwave. I think that would help with a general update. In a perfect world I would get rid of the bar height wall and make that a counter height extension to the current countertop. That would be a bigger undertaking. I do like the idea of the island, painting a different color, We plan to accent with navy if it looks good. I also thought to paint the cabinetry where the beverage fridge was and possibly take down the cabinets and put some stained wood open shelving there. Let me see if I can find another photo to give a better idea of the wall to the family room. One thought is that underneath the kitchen is the garage. Don't know the logistics of venting out that way??


  • 4 years ago

    Here is a picture showing the wall space on the other side of the microwave wall.

  • 4 years ago

    Never a good idea to vent cooking exhaust into garage - and worse yet, your pipe would need to run down a wall instead of across. the reason is the hole could allow toxic car fumes and any other chemical fumes stored in garage to get into your living spaces…and your local building code could even ban it. You can buy high CFM vent (with quiet decibel fan motor to reduce fan noise in open floor plan) and it should be OK unless you cook with lots of spices. If you need the range to vent directly outside, can it go in corner where the beverage fridge is, and add counter depth pantry cabs where door is, and move beverage fridge next to the sink, and leave eat-in area at bay window empty since dining table is a few steps away? Can the range go where the door is (how will you hide the exhaust pipe)? Both these latter 2 options reorient the kitchen to the bay window and make the island less obtrusive in the work triangle.

  • 4 years ago

    Option 2

  • 4 years ago

    Option 3

  • 4 years ago

    Option 3 continued

  • 4 years ago

    Thanks, Michelle for posting more inspo photos!

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    It is possible that a range duct could go thru the second floor, attic and then thru the roof. Depends on what is directly above. Perhaps thru a closet or, if there is a wall directly above, thru a rectangular duct buried in the wall or even an enclosed drywall chase outside of but against a wall. So long as the path is clear and there isn't HVAC ducting in the way.

    I would explore the vertical option before considering the downdraft one.

  • 4 years ago

    You say you are thinking navy accents? Be sure you like the way the color makes the pickled oak look and the orange floors look and the black counters look. Consider whether you are looking for a calm low-color- contrast coastal look or an energetic high-color-contrast nautical look. And whether you plan to use only navy or a lot of different shades of blue through the first floor.

    You say you need furniture. When buying a dining table, consider the orange floors and the oval shape of the room with low windows suggesting an oval shaped dining table (or round with with leaves) with low-back chairs on a rectangle rug.

  • 4 years ago

    Here is island painted Dress Blues from SW. I also did fridge is steel gray

  • 4 years ago

    You can DYI hone the black counters and should try it if the black fits your coastal vision (I usually think of Coastal as light and airy, but black works with MCM)

  • 4 years ago

    hi @marylut thank you for all the ideas. I thought about honing the granite to take off the shine. I would ultimately love white granite with veining (I had them before and loved them) but we are trying to work with what we have, if we can. @ci_lantro I think there could be a possiblity to vent out, otherwise we would have to keep with the internally vented hood. @eld6161 by doing some visual moderations we were hoping to love it and not have to do a renovation. I painted my last kitchen myself, but don't know if I want to tackle that again. I may paint the bar area (where the bevereage fridge is) that gray color to see how I like it and if I do, have someone come in and paint the rest.