How close is the coppery red you're painting the window trim with the natural brick color?

This is one of my favorite exterior paint combinations, as a possible inspiration.

Not sure where you live but I would paint it cream to match the trim. Around here everything is green already and white or cream is a relief.

I would go with color matching wood door.

Are you considering painting the foundations stones as well? I think I prefer white or black like the front door, unless you're changing that.

I would paint them all cream like the trim. The best would have been the natural brick, but, since that is already painted, thats not an option anymore.

here are some visuals. which one do you like?

I, too, would like to know what the original color of the brick is - maybe it will look great with your trim...

Think I would go with green...

My I ask what color your green paint color is?

Your house is really charming, and either the cream or the green will look great. I think I like the cream, since there is already a lot of green and the cream brightens the shady area. On the other hand, the green grounds the home a little better...I am no help at all! The inspiration pictures that Beth H. posted are all so beautiful; I am beginning the think that these Craftsman homes are becoming my favorites! Yours is so cute!

I vote cream.

Green gets my vote.

Cream

I vote painting the brick green. its not a trim its part of the house for me and will make the trim pop.

Green!

@eld6161 the green is "Hemlock" by PPG and Pittsburgh.

It’s an adorable house, whatever you decide. Looking forwarded to the “after” pics!