Software
Houzz Logo Print
36vintage

powder vs liquid amount?

4 years ago

I finally decided to check the amount of liquid detergent at the "line 1" indicated on the Tide liquid cap. Dados is correct in the use of 2 table spoons for the liquid detergent for the front loader; the Tide instructions say to use line 1 for "medium" loads which is also 2 table spoons. I just filled a 30 ml (2 table spoons) on a 30 ml glass with water & poured it in the Tide cap; saw amount is at the cap line 1.


So should the amount of powder be at the same 2 table spoons? I am using around 3+ table spoons for powder with the 50 ml scoop that came with the Sears powder. The thing is the Tide powder scoop looks to be around the 1/4 cup as the 2 table spoons came to around at th 1/2 to the scoop line 1.


Is more powder needed for the HE powder detergent for the front loader? On the surface, I don't see how using powder is less expensive than liquid as I've read.


Not really going to change my habits but curious. Are other detergent companies using the same lines on there liquid detergent caps; same with the powder scoops?

Comments (7)

  • 4 years ago

    I use 2 table spoons for both liquid and powder.

    I have found if I use more than 2 table spoons, on really long cycles I'll get more suds.

    2 table spoons cleans and rinses better with less sudsing (which you want, otherwise it's hard for the machine to rinse out).

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I use the same amout of detergent, whether it is powder or liquid, with no problems.


    Line 1 in my liquids (All & Tide) = 2 Tbsp

    Line 1 in my Tide and All powder scoops = 4 Tbsp, which is too much for our needs.


    Our loads of laundry are small compared to a large family with a large capacity washer. One Tablespoon is usually the average dose for us.


    IDK about Sears detergent dosing; I haven't used it in years.

  • 4 years ago

    With powders I use 1 Tbsp for average loads and 2-3 Tbsp for max loads. I have soft water and anything more is impossible to rinse especially for normal/permanent press cycles even if extra rinses are added. The whites/sanitize/towel cycles rinse better. Some times I run clothes through those cycles to get them rinsed well. For liquids I use 1Tbsp, rarely 2 because I find it even more sudsy. Our clothes are not very dirty (no farm or garage work) and I pretreat oily stains with Dawn soap. In general I think this amount is fine alhtough once a while I am wondering if I use too little detergent. Never had issues with musty towels. The only issue I run once a while is with exersice clothes from one family member and the only think that works there is soaking, then wash.

  • 4 years ago

    I use 2 TBSP for both liquid and Powder. I mostly use powder. I found that in my old Bosch which I no longer have that it was much easier to get too many suds with liquid than powder. I haven't so far notice that on my new machine.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Cheer powder, I use 2 to 3 tablespoons for very small loads, up to 7 tablespoons for max-capacity high-soil loads. Persil liquid, 1.5 to 2 tbps for very small loads. 4 to 4.5 tbsp for max-capacity high-soil loads. Always spiked with 1 to 2+ tbsp of STPP, and (recently) 2 (or up to 4) tbsp of borax. Unsoftened well-water.

  • 4 years ago

    Thanks everyone. I should have added that I have hard water and the water report says that around 40% is from well water & the rest is soft.


    Haven't seen any suds with my WashTower as all the laundry seem to be at the back on the tilted drum hiding the suds? Also don't see any suds at the 'dark' window nor at the gasket after washer finished. My loads are definitely small; biggest load may be the sheets & duvet cover or with 2 sets of towels. The washtower is an overkill for 1 person but it was the only available during the pandemic & fitted inside the laundry closet, sortof.

  • 4 years ago

    36vintage - sounds like your dosing is just right..