Software
Houzz Logo Print
carrieann_wood

HELP WITH FLOORING STAIN

4 years ago

I'm rebuilding and have redoak in im thinking of doing ' coffee brown " ? The lady came back and put dowm " Dark walnut " & she said it would close up my home and not good for pets and scratches easily? I'm just wondering if anyone else has or have that stain color or any advice about it ? 'Thank you ! #1 Dark walnut, #2 Special walnut #3coffee brown #4 Provincial ( second pic) coffee brown. Also need help with how to find a lvp that complements the stain ?

Comments (8)

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Lighter floors show less scratching, etc. Darker floors show ever piece of lint, and every scratch. All up to you. Dark walnut is a pretty floor. I dont know about the others. I wouldnt put lvp next to the wood flooring. It wont match, no matter what, and will always look like you tried to match and didnt.

  • 4 years ago

    Instead of lvp go to Lowes and look at Smartcore Naturals. 100% waterproof with real wood wear layer instead of fake wood picture. They have free samples to bring back to your space.

  • 4 years ago

    For what it's worth, our last house had dark brown hickory in the LV/DR. It was beautiful and I never felt like it darkened the room, but every speck of dust, pet hair, lint, etc., showed as well as shoe prints and foot prints when people walked through the rooms. I was constantly sweeping that floor.


    Our new house has oak floors and the lighter color doesn't show any of the above. The floors always look clean even if they are not. Something to consider when you make your decision.

  • 4 years ago

    I don't have the option of going with natural wood upstairs we had a house fire so they are replacing like for like ? So upstairs has to be a LVP or carpet which with 3 pets one who's a pisser so I think im in trouble anyways if I go w darker hardwood's!  I know its going to be tough to care for but I don't want any orange or red floors. I wish they were white oak I'd be done w this project! Thank you all for the help !

  • 4 years ago

    LVp is going upstairs & im not too crazy about the idea either to " try " & match up buy I have no option but to see if I can " compliment '" it to the hardwood's! It's upstairs but still I know

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Replacing like for like really means spending a specific figure on replacing the floors. They'll change to carpet. Not like for like. Find out what the figure is. Then decide if you can use something currently available at the same total price you prefer. Or, decide how much you'll add to that segment to get what you want. Lowes has a hardwood product called Smartcore Naturals. Real hardwood veneer with a SPC core like lvp. Go in and bring home some free samples to match to your other flooring.

  • 4 years ago

    They dont really care what you put on the upper level, as long as it is in their budget range. However, there is some good lvp, and I would prefer that over carpet, with pets. As to color range, you dont have to try and match colors. You seem to want to go very dark on the lower level, use a light natural color upstairs. That way, you get the flooring you need, but, you dont get the look, of trying to match, the lower level and failed. Upper levels, can be different from lower levels.

  • 4 years ago

    None of those colors are "dark" to the point that I'd warn the customer about scratches and dust being an issue. The bigger issue with darker stains is the contrast between the harder and softer grain, which is especially evident on boards with flat grain. The harder grain gets a little darker where the valleys in the softer grain hold more stain.

    I might suggest a different strategy. Find a vinyl you like for upstairs and see if the wood floor finisher can match it.

    If you like the sample in your third picture I'd suggest using Jacobean with a little bit of white mixed in, maybe 20: 1 or 10:1, applied over water popped wood then coated with three coats of a good waterborne urethane. The white gives the stain a little opacity and water popping makes the floor darker and more uniform. Three finish coats are needed to counter how the water makes the wood fuzzy. If you like the resulting color but it's too dark, Natural can be added to lighten it up.