The older one is lovely. You could add lighting if you like it.

I can't vote for the one on the right, the choice I would make because you have painting it as a choice--no way should you paint it.

I like them both.

My preference would be the one on the left. It’s gorgeous, a classic.

But it really depends on the room it’ll be in, surrounding decor, the style you’re planning.

Only you can decide. :)

Love that wallpaper!

Neither. The room would look so much more elegant with a blue painted sideboard IMO with the mirror turned vertical and framed prints added to the wall..

Beverly, she’s downsizing to another place.

Yikes, sorry!

Neither of them. I might change my mind if you post a photo of the dining room in the new house. I generally don't care for corner cupboards, though, because they seem like clutter to me.

If you keep the either one on them, I vote No on painting them.

Unfortunately my new dining room is too small for a side board. It’s funny how when you can’t make-up your mind about something asking others helps so much even if you don’t agree. I probably shouldn’t keep either of them, but I think I’ll keep the antique one. I like the idea of turning the mirror and having art work on either side. The corner cupboard will go on the opposite wall. Thanks all! And thanks you for loving the wallpaper.

Best of luck in your new place!

We downsized a few years ago, it can definitely be challenging. Choosing what to take, etc. I am kind of liking having less stuff, though. :)

Take the antique one with you. It might work in another place I. Y

Oops. It might work in another place in a different room.