Software
Houzz Logo Print
oursteelers

Black Caviar from Palatine

I really wanted Ascot because of Diane but it wasn’t offered this year so I went with Black Caviar AND was shocked to get it after the crazy ordering (by far the worst since I’ve been ordering from them)

Do we think I still need Ascot? I don’t have a lot of room for ”red” roses and I also ordered Rouge Royale from Roses Unlimited.

Gotta say, as much as trying to capture the true color is driving me bonkers, I love this rose! Vigorous, fragrant amd the color is exquisite.





Comments (29)

  • 4 years ago

    Wow..I like it. Look at all those buds! I grow Ascot and think you might still need it because of the shape...I think it might be more cup shaped. The shape of Black Caviar is lovely but different. Ascot is just a great plant, though I only grow the grafted one from Palatine.

  • 4 years ago

    Oursteelers, you really captured the unique color

    What a fabulous rose. It is just one more temptation that I probably cant resist.

    Now to hide it from the deer.

  • 4 years ago

    I’ve had Black Caviar on my wish list for a while now. I’m kicking myself for not grabbing it up from Palatine two years ago when I had the chance. I’ve heard great things about it.


    I still recommend getting Ascot too. It’s such an incredible rose….it’s made it to my must-have list. The blooms are beautifully cupped and the color is stunning. Beyond that, it also has a truly wonderful bush also. Thick, strong canes with dense foliage. No nodding blooms and a perfect vase shape. I love this rose!








  • 4 years ago

    I agree, you still need Ascot!

    Its truly outstanding. I dont have a lot of room for reds left either - but Black Caviar is on my list, as is Quadra.


    Ascot is completely disease free for me, blooms almost continuously, and is the perfect shape (as Laura & Erasmus mentioned!).


  • 4 years ago

    That's beautiful. The colors remind me of a fuschia.

  • 4 years ago

    Ok, fingers crossed Palatine has Ascot again next year.

    Kristine, I don’t know if there is anywhere in my yard that is deer safe. They keep coming back but they are only grazing now vs the absolute chomping they did in spring

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Freedom gardens also carry's ascot from time to time. That is from whom I bought mine and it's been a very Vigorous plant. I need to lookn into BC as i can't seem to get enough of these deep purple reds.

  • 4 years ago

    Oops, that was Ascot. Diane



  • 4 years ago

    To me the dark, burgundy reds go well with most other colors. Bright red doesn't bother me but for those that don't like it I'd think burgundy would be a whole different color. .

  • 4 years ago

    I love burgundy and also a true red. I'm not so fond of orange red, though I like some pure orange roses. I agree with erasmus that burgundy does fit in well, at least here, amongst my other roses. Diane

  • 4 years ago

    Ben did you grow this is Texas?? I am making a list for a garden of the future when I do actually own dirt again. Color reminds me of Dark Lady but even better.

  • 4 years ago

    This is another 1 that freedom gardens carries from time to time or will custom propagate as he will add Ascot.

  • 4 years ago

    @Austin I never did grow Astrid , but after looking at Oursteelers’ pic it’s on my list for the Palatine rose race this fall. The violet / crimson / black interplay is gorgeous.


    I tried Ascot, unfortunately it did not fare well in my Texas garden. Blooms were identical in color to Knock Out (who wants that!?) and she tended to throw long blind shoots. Two wrongs make for a shovel prune. I only kept her one season, so perhaps the plant would improve with age.

  • 4 years ago

    Ben did you see my post on Rosemantic Pink? Is a a great shrub rose…. Could be one of the best I have grown.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Ben, here Ascot did take a couple of years before coming into her own and she just keeps getting bigger and better.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Hi Austin

    I didn’t grow Rosemantic Pink, but all the NIRP roses I tried have been great. I have Broceliande, Sweet Delight, Parfum Royale.

    Sweet Delight



  • 4 years ago

    Oursteelers - your Black Caviar is ridiculously beautiful! :) :) How is it growing for you...the canes seem strong, does it get really tall? Any other thoughts on this rose's growth? I think I need to get it. I almost got it last year. Thanks!



  • 4 years ago

    For me Ascot is not the color of Knockout. It can vary a bit in color but is usually a fairly deep red. I think in person it's a deeper color than this picture but at least you can see the shape. I wonder if soil chemistry affects the color.




  • 4 years ago

    Carol so far it is tall and narrow with strong canes. One branch did break off this spring but it was being crushed by a giant mock orange so not its fault

  • 4 years ago

    Erasmus - oh my!!! You grow Ascot to perfection!!


    Oursteelers...I like roses like that. :) I need to get one this fall...if I can. :) :) Thanks!

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    `Erasmus, I think your summers are probably 5-10 degrees cooler than mine were in Dallas, and that’s probably making a difference. Many of the newer roses blind shoot or sit dormant when the summer is hot all day and night In Texas (Ascot, Summer Romance, Mme Anisette, Savannah). I think your climate would be similar to Biltmore where Savannah Sunbelt won its award, and I bet no one would give it any accolades in a Dallas summer where it’s bloomless. The sunbelt name I find especially amusing. I have to say all the old popular HTs never have this problem…a Fragrant Cloud, Chrysler Imperial or Miss AAB is able to set decent buds in the hottest part of summer, always. And I’d much rather deal with the older HT’s fungal issues than these new roses inability to bloom.

  • 4 years ago

    I was tempted to look into getting 'Black Caviar', but when I saw that Tantau had opted not to disclose the pedigree, I changed my mind. I know its irrelevant to most people, but I don't care to support breeding houses that intentionally hide the pedigree of their product. Tantau hides the pedigree of all their newer roses. So, no thanks.

  • 4 years ago

    Black Caviar is not that new, and was originally named Astrid Grafin von Hardenberg, as I mentioned above. The hybridizer of this rose has been dead for a number of years. Diane

  • 4 years ago

    @Diane Brakefield Anything less than 25 years old is "newer" in my perception. I didn't say "new", I said newer. I'm not sure what point you're making.

  • 4 years ago

    BenT, our climate is cooler than Dallas but not as cool as where the Biltmore garden is. The Biltmore house and garden are in Asheville which is in the mountains. They're usually about ten degrees cooler than the foothills where we are. STill, it's possible the difference in color between our Ascots is due to temperature. Could also be something in the soil maybe. I find that many roses can show a range of shades. My Nur Mahal has been a cherry red for the past 15 or 20 years but this year it's bright pink, or fuchsia.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    @oursteelers 8B PNW I'm about to order one from Palatine.

    Its shape is tall and narrow?

    I'm still not sure if I killed some of the reds I have (Ingrid Bergman, Falstaff, Oklahoma, Firefighter, Dark Desire, Gypsy Soul) but it's going to end up in that bed.

    Tall and narrow would actually be better.

    How is the foliage?

  • 3 years ago

    Still tall and narrow, most of the pics I took were of blooms because I was so mesmerized by them. The foliage was nothing special but at least it was healthy

  • 3 years ago

    Wow I don't think you need anything besides that Black Caviar lol. 🖤🥀💔