Software
Houzz Logo Print
llitm

Hard or soft sided luggage?

4 years ago

I'm in the market for new luggage and for many reasons am newly committed to carry-on only. I've only used soft-sided luggage in the past but am now considering hard-sided. I've read many pro's and con's to each. Do you have a preference and why?

Comments (18)

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    We have these Briggs & Riley "soft-sided" carry-ons. I find they are more forgiving and with the "expandable" feature, they work best for us. Three of us, one in each color. I haven't looked but B&R probably has a hard-sided one with the "expandable" feature also. I just like the soft-sided for some reason-lots of pockets on the outside too. This one has the perfect handy pocket for your passport, etc. Probably depends on the brand you buy. My husband has a less expensive, hard-sided one he takes on car trips for work-they take more of a beating IMO. Since we never check luggage-the soft-sided ones are treated with more care than if they were checked and thrown around.

    https://www.briggs-riley.com/collections/carry-on-luggage/products/essential-carry-on-spinner?variant=39999346638890

  • 4 years ago

    Definitely soft, especially if it's going to be a carry-on rather than checked. You can fit more in, since they have some give. I'm a big fan of TravelPro.

  • 4 years ago

    I prefer hard sided. I’ve had trips where my clothes in my soft sided suitcase were damp from rain. Plus, my soft sided case just looked dirty

  • 4 years ago

    I really wanted to like hard sided luggage because if the looks, but I am happier with soft. We have Briggs and Riley, as well as Victorinox and are happy with them.

    I love the look of Brics hard sided luggage.

  • 4 years ago

    I have never had hard-sided luggage. I love my Eagle soft-sided. It expands, and it can squish a little when it needs to.

    I got DH a B&R expandable computer bag for Christmas and he loves it. We are both impressed with the quality and the warranty. If/when he travels to clients again, he can add a change of clothes and his overnight gear in it.

  • 4 years ago

    We try to carry on our luggage for most plane trips and soft seems to be a bit more forgiving. I have picked up wet checked bags from the luggage carousel. It's not fun. For my daughter's wedding, we checked bags so I stuck my dresses in clean white trash bags and then put them in the luggage. I was worried about rain and a possible cosmetics explosion.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I needed a last-minute carry-on last year, and I found a Filson brand Dryden carry-on at my local Sierra Trading Post. I believe this model is discontinued, but as a brand, I like Filson.

    eta, sorry, it is soft-sided, which I prefer for carry ons.

  • 4 years ago

    I have all types and choose the suitcase depending on the type and length of the trip and also to coordinate with my wardrobe. I have several soft sided French Lipaut suitcases, a full range of soft Victorinox, and a couple of hard sided cases— my favorite being the newest carryon from Vera Bradley:



    I got more compliments on this suitcase from complete strangers than i have ever received for any luggage except my boiled wool German suitcase. It’s really cute and i carried it with this canvas Coach purse


  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    How does the weight of the hardsided ones compare to the soft? I like to be able to easily hoist and take my own luggage down.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Mine is about 7 1/2 pounds, its a 22” case. It is actually not

    as heavy as my similarly sized soft sided suitcases because I stuff them with more clothing.


    ***i edited this becaiuse i typed the wrong weight inadvertently! No hard side suitcase could be 2.5 lbs, sorry sorry!

  • 4 years ago

    IMO, hard ones are more difficult to shove into those overhead bins, if you're doing carryon only. I'd appreciate hard sided for luggage that gets thrown around by the handlers - have you ever watched them at work?

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Whichever carry-on you get, you have to get this, or another brand like it:


    Tumi Voyageur Tote

    https://www.tumi.com/p/just-in-case-tote-01100421041/

    It is a lifesaver and I don't know how I ever did without it. Look at the 4th pic in link. Had it for about four years now, and it doesn't move around or fall down around your luggage like other totes with big handles do. I see people in airports carrying the huge, heavy totes on their shoulders and I feel bad for them. It holds a lot and I put makeup bag, prescriptions and my purse inside-to save room in my carry-on-and a few other things. I use it as my one bag I can stuff under the seat of the plane.

  • 4 years ago

    I have an older style Tumi Voyageur tote that goes on every plane ride with me. I've had it since 2010 and it still looks new. It's very roomy but still fits under the seat. They make excellent, if pricey, luggage.

  • 4 years ago

    I love my Lipault luggage; I have both a soft carry on and hard shell checked suitcases. I also have a Lipault tote bag that can slide onto the handle of the carry on, so I don’t have to carry it on my shoulder.
    I really like Lipault for its light weight, durability, and style.

  • 4 years ago

    The Rydir band secures any size tote or purse to a luggage handle. Maire Cate posted this link several weeks ago and we bought a couple. They are a genius idea:


    https://www.rydir.com

  • 4 years ago

    Hard sided for checked bags. We've had checked luggage delayed sitting in the rain and wet clothes when returned to us. Soft sided for carry-on. I'm a devotee of Baggalini.

  • 4 years ago

    Yes, it depends. I just bought new Monos hard sided luggage, a large and a carry on size. I’ve been a Travelpro fan for years and wore out two 22” softside pieces during my work years. I have several smaller softside bags that are getting worn out and I may eventually buy another Travelpro softside. I believe the Travelpro Maxlite hardside 22“ is getting very good reviews right now.

    OJ, I also have that Tumi tote and wouldnt go without it especially if I’m planning to buy souvenirs.

  • 4 years ago

    Thank you all for your thoughts.


    I really like DH's Travelpro and had narrowed it down to the Maxlite, either the hardside or softside. The soft-sided is a pound less but the h/s is still only 6.3 lbs. I don't use outside pockets on my soft sided luggage so that won't be missed. I appreciate the division of space in the Travelpro hard-sided so think I'll give it a try.


    As for the personal item...


    I'm going to try a backpack. I know. Neither cute or fashion forward but I appreciate the advantages of them. We spent a few weeks in Switzerland last summer doing only trains which we want to do again in the Fall and my luggage would have been much easier to handle had I had a backpack. DH loves his and the one I'm looking at is fun, colorful and will coordinate nicely with the luggage. ;)


    Oh, and as for the Tumi tote I have one that is very similar and like it a lot!


    Thanks, again!!