What does YOUR house look like? Pictures? Description (home style, colors, natural light, artificial light, life style, pets, kids, etc., etc.)? Help us help you.

At least these are similar in pattern and grain. Looks like the difference is in color. So, the main question for you is do you want a lighter or slightly darker floor.

Shaw is a well known flooring manufacturer ... can't you got to any local flooring store and see if they carry these colors?

For me, one looks too gray and the other too pink, so I wouldn't want either of them.

Where is the house?

Personally I'd never take the lighter one. Too light and trendy.

Can you choose any of the colours shown in your link? I would choose a more medium colour myself but you may be wanting a light colour.

What about Prestique Pine that is shown in the link?