Not really sure why you hate it. It is never going to "blend in". Landscaping will certainly help. Clearing out the junk in the porch will make it look less like a storage spot. Maybe add some flower boxes or widen the stairs so you can put pots on them.

Wood Screen Doors Lowe's

Paint the porch to match the house and it should blend in nicely.

I actually like it. Maybe paint the lowest section white and paint the stairs. I would suggest some nice flower beds with taller bushes or tall flowering plants or even do some long window boxes screwed onto the front. I tried to make a picture:

If you want to spend some money, I would look into changing the lower section to something different:

Good luck!

IMO its the style of the porch I would not have done a screened in porch at the front of that house now paint it the same as the house and concentrate on fabulous landscaping.

Paint it the same color as the house and plant some flowering shrubs along the foundation. Power wash the stairs. It will look pretty good. You don't want window boxes.

Looks to be a typical "four square" from back in the day. Often in search of more private livable space, the porches got enclosed. Check city records; there may be photos of how it or some other similar home looked back then.

FourSquare Home · More Info

Traditional Exterior · More Info

Four Square · More Info

Historic Four Square · More Info

I’d paint it the house or trim color. The white is very stark.

I think Foursquares with enclosed porches look better painted cohesively.

Paint steps and railings white and the lower section same as house or white. When landscaping, use different heights with evergreen bushes next to house and bottom section will be hidden eventually. https://www.urbanorganicyield.com/best-evergreen-shrubs-for-front-of-house/

A screen door in a soft color would feel welcoming and cute. Link below has lots of options, just to give you ideas.

https://www.vintagedoors.com/product.php?id=209

Paint the lower part to match the house, and get a nicer door, painted a soft, pretty aqua blue.

Yes, definitely paint it to match the house!