Software
Houzz Logo Print
forno_chris

De-Leafing my Black Tulip Magnolia?

4 years ago

I love my Black Tulip Magnolia! It has been in the ground 3 years now and has for the first time this summer really started expanding its branches. But ... I never saw a picture before I bought it showing how it looks AFTER it drops its blooms and leafs out. Although still very attractive, the dark green and super thick canopy of leaves looks very HEAVY to me.


So I'm wondering if I can remove some of the leaves in the middle of the tree to open it up a bit and show off its branches? I'd like to do it early summer after it leafs out and wouldn't remove any new buds which are forming.


What are your thoughts on this? Will doing this decrease the number of FLOWERS the following spring? I don't want to do that !!!


Also, wondering if I'll need to keep doing the leaf removal every year to maintain the same look or if in future years, the tree will automatically stop growing LEAVES where they have been removed.


Thank you!


The Greengoblin

Comments (8)

  • 4 years ago

    Hello sir.


    Is the Liriodendron tulipifera https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a878 that we are talking about?


    If so I say prune it shortly after it flowers for best flower production the next year though there may be other species specific health concerns I do not know about.


    You'll be able to raise its canopy at will. Selective thinning will eventually require climbing. I like their natural look so maybe an every several year thing will do.


    Far as it eliminating its shaded or lower branches, sort of. In a forest they absolutely do. In an opem yard they'll probably still thin themselves out but you'll have some branches that reach to the ground. They'll make mowing difficult but put them beautiful flowers at eye level. I'd try to go for a balance with mowing and flower visibility.

  • 4 years ago

    Magnolia soulangeana "Black Tulip" may be the OP's tree. It would be good to clarify that before we give pruning advice LOL.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    “Black Tulip” is a hybrid Magnolia, not a cultivar of M. soulangiana:

    ”sometimes listed as a selection of Magnolia x soulangiana, but its background is more complex than that. It is the result of a cross, made by Mark Jury, of 'Vulcan' as the seed parent and possibly 'Iolanthe' as the pollen parent (Gardiner, 2000). The background of these parents includes a number of Magnolia species.”

    https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/magnolia-black-tulip

  • 4 years ago

    Thanks Toronado! Here's the tree: https://www.monrovia.com/black-tulip-magnolia.html


    And here's a pic of what I'm talking about after it loses it's flowers:

    https://www.pinterest.com/pin/569423946619045411/


    It's located against a fence in a garden so no mowing required. ;)


    I'm not necessarily looking to raise the canopy but rather remove leaves so that it doesn't just look like a wall of green. Would like to see the branches which will make it more interesting. Just want to make sure that when I remove the leaves in summer, that I'm not limiting the blooms next year.


    Thanks Again!!

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    The leaves serve a purpose. You do not want to remove them if you value the long term health of the tree. And being a pretty small sized tree to begin with, the loss of any leaves during the growing season could very well have an adverse impact.

    You can see the branches in winter and when the tree is in flower before the leaves emerge. But do not remove just for aesthetics!!

  • 4 years ago

    Good to know- glad that I asked! Thanks for the info Gardengal!


  • 4 years ago

    In addition, magnolias tend to resent pruning.

  • 4 years ago

    i think you ought to go buy more plants.. and screw around with those.. and leave this poor thing alone.. lol...


    a shrub with large potential can take 2 to 4 years to settle in .. and get growing to specs.. we call that getting established ....depending on how well you planted it ..


    so your plant is not fully established ... and your only thing is.. im going to start cutting off the food making machines [leaves].. because i know better that it.. how it should grow ..


    no.. no..no.. leave it alone.. and as stated above.. go buy more plants


    and i suspect in 5 years.. you will love this plant as it is.. shrubs should be some of the most carefree plants i in the garden.. presuming you sited them properly from the gitgo ... [meaning you didnt plant then 2 feet from the foundation...lol]


    now.... all that said... after it does get fully established .. and you want to start pruning it for aesthetics.. then knock yourself out ... its your plant.. in your garden.. and i approve you doing whatever you want to your plants ...


    ken