Thanks Sigrid! I wouldn't say the garage door is a feature, no. But it's a big spot of the house so I'm just unsure. If I went with the oak plank garage door - what do you think about the front door? Black? Another color?

Cedar/wooden color goes good with navy Blue.

Thanks, Celery! If I decided to go with Cedar - what color door would you suggest? Although the cedar is a much redder wood than any of the wood tones inside. Does it matter? Yikes. Confusing.

I like the middle g door. Have you thought about a lime green for the front door?

X - No I haven't! I'll have to do a mock up. I guess I am just overwhelmed right choices! And then I start thinking about what is inside and how it fits and my mind gets blown. :)

I like the first.

What's wrong with your current garage door? If it functions, paint it to match the brick around it and you will have eliminated one of your confusing issues. Then find a funky color for the front door. Increase the size of your lantern lights, and get busy on the landscaping - that's where the bang for your buck is!

I don’t really love orange for the front door. Are you open to something else?

I prefer not to accent that door so my choice would be similar to the stone colour that is below. Of the three you posted the middle seems less distracting and I see your front door first.