Software
Houzz Logo Print
sjgranholm

Which kitchen layout seems more functional?

4 years ago

Hi there - looking for some feedback on our kitchen layout. We are redoing our main floor and want to see if a peninsula is a better option that the kitchen island. The concern with the island is whether there is enough clearance around the island so the walkway doesn't feel too cramped. Any advice would be greatly appreciated. Layout with measurements are included.








Comments (16)

  • 4 years ago

    Show us both plans in 2D.

    Sahar Granholm thanked cpartist
  • 4 years ago


    Sorry, I thought I updated both. Here you go.

  • 4 years ago

    I like the peninsula better. I think the entry to the kitchen from the front door is less awkward, there is more room to open the refrigerator, and the bar stools are better positioned to serve as overflow seating for the table.

    Sahar Granholm thanked Julie B.
  • 4 years ago

    I can’t read the numbers on how much clearance there is for the island on either side? also how many cooks in the kitchen. for multiple cooks i would prefer the penninsula, but i really can’t tell how far away everything is. i would want to have a drop zone for the ovens, so would probably pull these over to the end of the range wall.

    Sahar Granholm thanked lharpie
  • 4 years ago

    The clearnace for the island is 41.5 on the side with seating and range and 48 on the side with the fridge. Typically I do most of the cooking but my husband does help every so often. Drop zone is a good idea, I didn't even think of that.

  • 4 years ago

    Can you even open the right fridge door fully in #1? I think #2 works better, though I'd probably shift the fridge to the right to be closer to the sink.


    Why are you closing of the window on the left? With the pantry, it doesn't seem like you need the storage and good light makes for a great kitchen.

  • 4 years ago

    No matter which one you choose, you should consider swapping the bottom doors for drawers.

  • 4 years ago

    Not enough room for the island. You need a minimum of 42" from counter to counter, not cabinet to cabinet. And that's for a 1 cook kitchen.

    Your photos are too small for me to see. Especially the measurements.


  • 4 years ago

    It might work to minimize aisles in a small one person kitchen, but it seems strange in a kitchen sized to cook for a crowd. why have a 48” cooktop if you aren’t going to have space for multiple cooks? i am also not sure where all the doorways go, but it is going to be hard to get by those chairs if anyone is sitting in them. i definiely agree with the pp that said keep the additional window. that will make it a much happier kitchen no matter what you do!

    Sahar Granholm thanked lharpie
  • PRO
    4 years ago

    With a 48" range, you need about 48" in front of that to open the ovens. The peninsula is nice, but not with the main sink right in the center of it. I would move the cooktop to either the right or the left and get the sink on the outside wall.

    Good luck!

    Sahar Granholm thanked Debbi Washburn
  • 4 years ago

    I see the bay window has flexibility, so I am not sure how much the scope of the remodel covers. But before you finalize and choose between only 2 variables, it is best to review all options for the entire floor together with evaluating an island vs peninsula.

    For instance, the Powder Room would be better next to the Pantry with a more hidden door, and you could improve the layout of the Office(?) a bit. In Option#1 the area in front of the sliding door is unassigned, so maybe a separate Mudroom, or moving the Pantry to the back area might help in circulation and maximizing the space you have. There could be ways that improves opportunities for your island vs peninsula.

    Sahar Granholm thanked 3onthetree
  • 4 years ago

    Personally, I would find the island more functional, but I also hate prepping facing a wall. As always, I agree with all of @mama goose_gw zn6OH's points

    Sahar Granholm thanked Elizabeth
  • 4 years ago

    I’m troubled by what appears to be wasted space. There’s a foyer space inside the front door. Then There’s another foyer-ish space outside the office and powder room. And there’s this empty space between the kitchen and banquette. The peninsula plan fills this last space best, but I think a change with the pantry/powder/office space planning may be Key to creating your best layout.

    Sahar Granholm thanked rainyseason
  • 4 years ago

    Thanks everyone! I do still have reservations on this layout and need to continue editing it with the designer.

  • 4 years ago

    I prefer the island version--everything feels closer together for cooking and the overall look is more open.

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert