I can look into that. Would the silver sage be horrible?

Personally, I don't care for the silver sage with your trim color.

Nothing wrong too with keeping it all Saybrook.

For me, I feel the chair rail with two different colors is dated. But, that's not to say you shouldn't do it if to your eye it looks nice.

I like the silver sage myself. i am working on my 2 color bathroom options now too. pretty sure my trim is dated to the 1920s, soooooo…. not gonna complain about it being dated.

@lharpie. Our place was built in 1987 I believe. We just moved here a year ago and choosing paint colours has been stressful. 😅

It looks to me like you have a very unusual/unique bathroom… color selection should be chosen with a fuller picture of the room… it may make more sense to not add a new color.. choose one that blends with what is there… to allow the unusual woodwork to stand out more… not have to compete with another color

If you have white fixtures I would consider white walls.. for the same reasons

White that matches the fixtures

Here are some more photos of the bathroom.

This is ballet white to the left and white dove to the right. I think would dove would be a little too stark.

I agree according to the way it looks in the pic… and thanx for the broader view… the unique woodwork and cabinetry will be featured better with white and when you can the flooring … using a smaller tile with a patterned layout using all the colors would be very striking…

Due to the woodsy feel a shower curtain in white with leaves.. trees…greenery … a pattern ….would add a softer edge..to all the wood

The metal tray and greenery are a nice touch in that theme

I love the idea of greenery with wood.  Hence why I was love the Saybrook sage. Does anyone have suggestions for BM white? White dove looks too stark in my opinion. Thoughts on ballet white? I still want some warmth, not too white/stark.

Why not start with a white primer coat..

I agree with priming first. Personally, I would paint top, bottom and chair rail all one color.

We are having a professional painter do the work.

We are planning to leave the trim as is. There is wooden trim throughout most of the house so I don't want to paint it. Just trying to work with it lol.