Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_901848027

HELP: 200 gallon tree planted without removing burlap sack or wires

3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago

Hi all,

I bought a ~200 gallon Chinese Pistachio tree (15-17 foot talk, 6 inch thick) from a big local tree farm (been in business almost 40 years) and the workers planted the tree for me yesterday.

I noticed that they did not remove the burlap sack or any of the wiring from the tree rootball before filling in the hole. I asked if that was OK and they assured me that this was the way they planted - that the burlap and wire are required to prevent the rootball from splitting apart. They said the burlap would rot and the tree roots spreading would not be affected.

The tree has already been planted and I have been looking into this and finding a lot of info stating that both the burlap and wires should be completely removed before planting.

What is the consensus on what to do here? Is it OK to leave burlap+wires on or should they be completely or partially removed to help with the success of the tree?

If they need to be removed, what are my options here? Do I need to excavate the tree to have the burlap / wires removed? How can this be done, since it's such a big tree?

I'm also a bit concerned that the tree is buried too deep, but the top was covered with the burlap bag, so the root flare wasn't completely exposed.

Really appreciate your help!!

Comments (14)

  • 3 years ago

    If it were me I'd communicate directly with the business owner. And hopefully the tree and its installation are warrantied for a reasonable of time. Yes?

  • 3 years ago

    1 year warranty for the tree. I'm worried about problems down the line, many years.

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Here is a link to the Kinsey Family Farm in North Georgia about their balled and burlaped trees.


    https://www.kinseyfamilyfarm.com/nursery-plants/ball-burlap-tree/



    HU-901848027 thanked debvanatl
  • 3 years ago

    Make sure the burlap is not still tied to the trunk and remove any burlap that may be visible as it will wick moisture away from the rootball.

    tj

    HU-901848027 thanked tsugajunkie z5 SE WI ♱
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    But while the trees didn’t survive, the burlap, wire basket, and webbing were all still there almost 30 years later.

    Give me your huddled root masses yearning to breathe free – The Garden Professors™

    HU-901848027 thanked Embothrium
  • 3 years ago

    It's a good policy to cut away the burlap and wire from the top third of the root ball AFTER seating it in the final position in the hole. Definitely remove the straps.


    Two things I disagree with: fertilizer isn't typically recommended at planting and certainly not in the bottom of the hole. You cannot entice feeder roots to grow down in search of fertilizer. They will always develop in the top ten or so inches if soil where oxygen and moisture is most available.


    Also, it is not recommended that you mix organic matter of any kind with the native soil when refilling the hole. Simply use the soil that was dug out of the hole in the first place. Tamp it in gently so as not to destroy healthy porosity. Then apply the four inches of good mulch in as wide a circumference around the root ball as possible, even further than the drip line of the tree.


    HU-901848027 thanked rhizo_1 (North AL) zone 7
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Speaking of other aspects of tree planting besides baskets and burlap etc. here is another one from the same source:

    Problems with Planting Trees – The Garden Professors™

    HU-901848027 thanked Embothrium
  • 3 years ago

    Excellent info!

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    I doubt the wires will "disintegrate". I've found old wires, nails and steel pieces while digging in an area where plank-sawing was done (and finished) near 100 yrs ago.

    HU-901848027 thanked bengz6westmd
  • 3 years ago

    i dont understand why you dealt with a very old established tree farm.. and then turn around within hours and imply they dont have a clue what they are doing ... pshaw ...


    if they were hacks.. they would NOT have been in business for the last 40 years ...


    there are 2 types of burlap.. and the nursery kind is supposed to disintegrate rather quickly.. i presume your seller knows what kind to use ..


    agree.. you can remove any burlap you see on the surface ...


    forget about the wire cage ... we arent talking chicken wire here ... there should be no impact on the roots from the cage ...


    all you have to do it water is properly.. deeply and infrequently.. and most likely.. whatever they told you to do.. and you should be all set ...


    i presume you are freaking out due to the investment you made in this rather huge tree ... i avoided all this by buying small.. and planting stuff myself... and i found out.. smaller transplants often establish sooner get over all the stresses.. and can usually outgrow the larger transplants.. plus.. if you lose it.. the cost is smaller ..


    anyway.. just water it properly.. and you should be all set ..


    any chance they offered you a water gator for it?? wonder if they would recommend one??


    ken

    HU-901848027 thanked ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
  • 3 years ago

    I am laughing that someone thinks wire cages will disintegrate quickly.

  • 3 years ago

    I think the general advice to remove burlap, wires and/or strings before planting is correct for plants sized for an average homeowner.

    This isn't that.

    I'd take pictures of your tree, and go talk to the nursery expert* directly. I'd want to be sure it's planted at the correct depth for the root flare, not mulched too heavily, burlap should be completely underground, how often to water it and how to know when you've given it enough, etc.

    *not everyone who works at a nursery is a plant expert; I learned that the hard way!

    HU-901848027 thanked User
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    This one has pictures of what can happen. I got it and many other relevant hits searching the web for "trees planted in wire cages".

    Planting Trees - Remove String, Burlap and Wire Basket - Garden Fundamentals