Software
Houzz Logo Print
caryn_andrews

What to do with these pine walls?

4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago

Hi,

We are knee deep into our kitchen remodel. we have opened up half a wall and now will have a dining area in our former tv room. The walls are somid wood, tongue and groove, pine paneled. The wood is staying because the walls are in bad shape and we dont have extra money to sheetrock and plaster.

The house is 100 years old. Would you paint the pine, sand and white wash, or do an antique white poly stain? i know you will have great words of wisdom.

Thanks!









Kitchen counters are soapstone and leaning towards honed marble subway for backsplash

Comments (17)

  • 4 years ago

    Just FYI, pine bleeds a lot when painted, particularly the knots. Paint it but just make sure the wood is properly sealed and primed.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    You're doing a complete remodel but don't have another hundred or two for some drywall??

    Not even enough for one or two of the walls? Drywall is cheap.

    You can afford to cover this wall, no? I mean, give up something else!


    This paneling doesn't even go to the ceiling! It's going to look odd if you leave it like this and redo everything else.

    You could carefully take down those pine panels and replace w/drywall, tape it and mud it yourselves. In fact, if you want to paint those panels, you're going to have spend at least $100-200 for paint,primer, brushes and sanding paper. So what's the diff if you spend it on drywall?

    Based on your pic, it's hard to tell what's what or what would even look best.

    Why not just leave it for now until everything else is installed? There's no rush to do anything with it right now, is there?

    With the right wall colors and decor, pine can look great.




    If you do decide to paint, give the wood a light sanding (220) and wipe it clean w/mineral spirits. You'll have to prime it w/an oil base primer that is a stain blocker. pine knots will bleed. (the grooves will need to be done carefully w/a brush)

    After priming, a light sanding again. Wipe clean/vaccuum. Now you can paint. Use a good paint that's meant for wood trim. (Advance, Pro-Classic are two)




    https://www.houzz.com/magazine/knotty-to-nice-painted-wood-paneling-lightens-a-room-s-look-stsetivw-vs~15039759

  • 4 years ago

    @Beth H. :i agree drywall is not expensive but Even my contractor feels like it is a can of worms not worrh opening. I stretched the budget with more expensive countertops and appliances. The panels don’t go up the wall because there is a shelf that goes around the top of panels that we use for display.


    I actually really like first picture. It might work out to keep the wood but paint the trim a soft, antique white.


    Thank you all so much.



  • 4 years ago

    Paint it- if you’re aesthetic is rustic, a “sloppy” whitewash is easy to do. If you’re going for a more sleek look, you’ll have to prime the knots with Binz, and then prime the whole thing again.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    IMO do not take the pannelling down jus do the drywall over it . Painting pine is a hyge job it needs to have 2 coats min. of shellac primer then 2 coats of apint . I usully also sand it down since often those wall were oiled to keep them looking shiny . I definately think the pine needs to be apinted if thegrays and whites you show are what is going to be in the space

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    I'm a big fan of pickling walls such as these. This changes the color but also allows some of the wood grain to show thru. As Paticia Colwell said - it's not an easy job. The walls should be stripped and sanded down in order to prepare them for any sort of other treatment. If you are a diyer it would certainly save you money and give you a very good arm workout, LOL! Good luck!

  • 4 years ago

    Beth H: I do like your optimism!😉 True, drywall itself is not expensive, the cutting and installation of it not too difficult; when it comes to sanding and mudding, however, that is an art! A good “drywaller” is worth the money but won’t come cheap, it’s several trips, they’re hard to get nowadays, esp. for smaller jobs…..we’ve been through this recently. Hubby and I have done it ourselves in a few areas, but it is not our forte and I’m never pleased with the results. It looks ok at first, but once you get the first coat of paint on it you can see all the places where you messed up…..Kudos to you for doing your own, but it is not something every homeowner can do (or do well) on his/her own.

  • 4 years ago

    coray, oh I completely agree. my husband is a GC and built additions to our home all by himself. he can literally do everything. except drywall! He's done a few walls and they are uneven and lumpy! the man has no finesse. He does the rough stuff and I do all the finish work. we make a good team.

    So yes, hanging drywall isn't tough, taping, mudding and sanding is an art. I just thought if they took it slow and did only the one or two walls, they could power through.

  • 4 years ago

    What's the overall look for your house? It sounds like this is a separate dining space (a former tv room) - is it separate from the kitchen? If it's a 100 year old house, and the pine was originally stained and on full display, my first instinct would be to keep it and tailor the rest of the space around it (especially once it's trimmed out with the shelf). I love a warm and inviting dining space - and wood really brings that feeling more than any shade of paint.

  • 4 years ago

    @JP L


    The overall look of our house is cozy, comfy , traditional americana. The house is only 1400 square feet.


    Here are some daytime photos. Don’t mind construction clutter.




    View into kitchen



    Outside view

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Oh wow @Caryn A - lovely! I love the wood, especially with the upper trim/shelf in place. I'd leave it as is, replace the trim/shelf and paint the trim and ceiling a warm white perhaps - and add a simple rug in the space (a natural fiber or something that is dining room friendly for clean-up). In your kitchen, I'm not sold on the marble backsplash - it's a bit cold with the black/white counter/cabinet combo. Wondering if there's another option that is more in line with the warm/cozy feel of the rest of the house? Or possibly warm the kitchen up via accessories or other features? I was thinking a tile that mimics beadboard (Ivy Hill tile makes one) - to give that cozy/Americana look of beadboard but with a ceramic surface that is easier to clean.

  • 4 years ago

    Beth H: yes, sounds a lot like our drywall work here!🤣 Hubs does a lot, I do ”design” and paint work, but drywall finishing ain’t for novices!😱

  • 4 years ago

    @JP L


    We have not purchased tile yet so I appreciate your suggestions. Stay tuned everyone. Walls are getting plastered this week.

  • 4 years ago

    Paint it, but keep the wood trim around the windows. I love wood paneling, but I feel like you need a really funky decor style to pull it off. Paired with "americana" furniture, it will just look like grandma's outdated home. This pine wall doesn't really seem precious enough to preserve. White paint will brighten that room. Do heed Beth's advice, re: prepwork and primer.

  • 4 years ago

    Another option - Leave the knotty pine walls “as is”, paint the adjacent room and upper kitchen walls soft green to complement all the brown, paint the window trim white, paint the ceilings same color as the walls to make rooms seem taller, sand and refinish all the wood floors in a blonde/light stain (ash, aspen, white oak). BTW, I think the proposed black/white kitchen color scheme is too contemporary and cold for an updated cozy, traditional Americana cabin in the woods.

  • 4 years ago

    Years ago, in Arch Digest, Armani renovated his farmhouse which was magnificent. He painted the wood paneling white, leaving and adding some wood. So beautiful.

    Leave the wood framing around the window and paint all the rest white.