I like the one you chose for the dining room. But the one in the entry is dated pseudo-Tuscan, so put that on your list to replace at some point. If you were to replace it you would also have more freedom in your dining room to do something else if you like something else better. But the one you're showing is great.

Your new one for the dining room looks great. But I noted your fire screen in your dining room. Perhaps you could consider new brass fixtures in your dining room and entrance hall? There are some interesting new ones being made that bridge the gap between traditional and modern. Something to freshen up your look? Just a thought….

I think my husband will kill me if I want to replace both. I wonder if I could spray paint the one in the dining room? I have the spray paint from when I painted the fireplace screen.

Whoops I meant to say paint the chandelier in the entry way. Is there no "edit" post on Houzz?

I like that Beverly. I can't afford to replace both at this time. Do you think if I spray paint the entry way chandelier in a gold/brass color it would help?

Leave it until funds permit.

Does anyone else have a different opinion or do you also think that going with a more streamlined approach is the best course of action? I would like to make a decision by the end of the weekend, so feel free to weigh in if you would like to assist me! Thank you in advance.

Wonder what the hallway light would look like without the goldish glass shades - can they be removed? It might simplify the fixture some and make it look less "Tuscan" -

For your dining room light - I like what you picked out but also really like what @BeverlyFLADeziner suggested- it has lots of sparkle but cleaner lines, which is always nice and fresh

Maybe these.........less streamline and more decorative & great pricing.

https://www.homary.com/item/gold-12light-glass-globe-led-chandelier-with-adjustable-cable-38050.html

These are very pretty!

Yup the one you want, try to paint the entryway one and when it looks mess then you can buy a new one!

You like ornate scrolls, so see if you like the chandeliers better if you the opaque amber glass on the candle arms. You like gold but I think black might do better than adding more gold - unless you want a monochromatic color scheme.

*remove the glass

Beverly or anyone else who would like to chime in... do you think either of these two would work for the dining room? For know, I am disregarding the foyer chandelier.

Get the size and proportion right so no one bumps head on chandelier…12” less than DR table width and 12” less than DR table length and bottom hangs about 30-34” above the DR table. If table is longer than 60”, definitely go with rectangle shape of a pair of small chandeliers.

This is what I ended up choosing. It's a lot of "bling" but it makes me happy. I love how it incorporates some of the gold colors from my living room. Hope you all approve!

@Renee Bergmooser, you said the four magic words: "it makes me happy". Approval by even one person here is irrelevant.

I like your choice a lot! To goes well with your design style and brings some brass into the room. Lovely! Now…enjoy!

Thank you so much!!

@Renee Bergmooser you certainly have a WOW factor with the new chandelier!

That one will be a lovely addition…enough ….even with nothing on the table…

It adds elegance to your dining room! You love it and that’s important.