Software
Houzz Logo Print
gtdj519

Pro tile help PLEASE!!

4 years ago

Installer put in Vihara glass mosaic tiles from Sonoma Tilemakers. They are paper front tiles, so you cannot see the tiles until sfter the thinset is dey and the paper is removed for grouting. he frouted the Niche today and smack in the midlde is ONE tile that has an odd black mark/ squiggle line through it. out of all the hundreds of tiles that are on the walls , this is the only one like it and it ended up right in the middle of the niche!! can this one tile be removed and replaced with a better one from the extra leftover tile that we have, even though he already grouted it? it is driving me nuts and it is all I see when I walk into the new bathroom we are remodeling.

i did call him and left a message to ask, but havent heard back. I wanted to see if any pros could answer me as I anticipate what the response may be . thank you !




Comments (42)

  • 4 years ago

    You picked a tile with a lot of variation. Just accept it as normal variation. it is possible to remove a tile and reset carefully with schluter waterproofing, but do you want to take that chance?

    gtdj519 thanked upstatem
  • 4 years ago

    I too thight of both things you did , but i was hoping a pro tile imstaller would be able to answer about if it can realistically be done safely or if my concerns about the actual ability ro do so, waterpreof issie etc , are real issues ro xonsider

  • 4 years ago

    No matter how diligent, things happen. And I’m often surprised as the workers we hire are very skilled.

    My husband was so careful laying out and choosing the tiles so that similar tiles were spread apart.

    Well, front and center, two tiles with squiggles are next to each other. Then, out of all the tiles for the floor, they put one that looks like a dust bunny near the door. . Now though I I just laugh when I look at these tiles.

    Things happen. Your master bathroom is not a public area. Personally, I might nit have noticed it, if you didn‘t point it out.

    gtdj519 thanked eld6161
  • 4 years ago

    It’s really fine. If it were the only dark one, I could understand being upset. But there’s another dark one to the left. Once it’s all done you won’t even see it.

    gtdj519 thanked Gerry
  • 4 years ago

    The light almost white one to the left shows up more than the black one. The tile looks fine as it is a busy pattern with lots of variation.

    gtdj519 thanked cpartist
  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    They did an amazing job on the tile work - and that tile is not noticeable to anybody but you. I agree that the white and grey tiles on the left are more prominent than the one in the middle that you are obsessing about. The tile flows with the design. It does not look out of place. And it would in no way be noticeable to anyone here if you did not have a microscopic lens on it. No wonder they are not calling you back.

    This is a tiny tile in a shower niche. Unbelievable.

  • 4 years ago

    The tiles photograph horribly for some reason. believe it or not , they are actually light blue/ light grey / white mix- not a silver grey as pictured.

    The wierd tile is a transulscent one, so it looks like there is a black worm or piece of yarn , or something stuck under the tile. I wish it looked as docile as it does in the pic; as it wouldnt bother me.

    there is a white tile next to it, but there are quite a few white tiles blended in throughout the bigger accent wall, so it doesnt seem odd to me. here is a pic of the wall to see the variariations- although hard to see, as its photographing like a silver/ grey 🤦🏼‍♀️

    its our guest bathroom , so it does/ will get used often.


  • 4 years ago

    No one in a million years is going to notice this. much less a guest using the shower once! i’d see worrying about in your bathroom but this really is only going to drive you mad.

    gtdj519 thanked lharpie
  • 4 years ago

    I take offense to your rude comment freddomplace1. i never stated their workmanship was poor or that I was dIssatisfied with the job. Nor did I ask members if they saw anything wrong with it. I posted to inquire about of a single tile could be removed after grouting; with the hope that perhaps a peofessional tile installer could let me know if its posisble or not. If you are a pro installer , an answer to the posed question would have been helpful. If youre not a pro installer, then a less assumptive response would have been kinder , or perhaps no comment at all would have been better.

    I have a good relationship with my contractor for years, , and not hearing back from him on a weekend is not a matter of avoidance or something unusal, as it is a weekend.

    Thank you to those who posted opinions,personal experience and kind advice.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Your bath is lovely. I am not a professional, but I did finish a whole house remodel a year ago and I vividly recall being upset by what I perceived as flaws in tile work, flooring, and other items. Now, a year later, I never notice any of them.

    gtdj519 thanked HU-401846177
  • 4 years ago

    Thanks HU. congrats on the remodel- a whole house must be a huge undertaking

    Thats a lot at once!

  • 4 years ago

    As others have said, no one will notice this. I would let this one go.  It seems to match with some of the other rules.   Treat it as a feature,  not a bug.  But to answer your question, it is possible to replace.  Whether the waterproofing could be messed up is unknown and a risk.  They will probably tell you they can add some waterproof coating after removing that tile,  but it's unknown whether issues will crop up years later.  However,  since it's in a niche,  it hopefully won't see too much water and probably be fine.  Despite that,  I would leave it as it's also possible the grout won't bond to itself as well after you replace one tile.

    gtdj519 thanked T T
  • 4 years ago

    gtdj519 My original intention for the remodel of my 1979 ranch, a rental property I bought thirty years ago and moved into in 2020, was to do a kitchen and guest bathroom remodel. That gradually morphed into a complete remodel of the interior of my 1330 sqft house. A daunting project indeed. But, it was all worth it as I am, for the first time in my 67 years, living in my own house. Be kind to yourself and trust that it will all work out, the imperfections will fade away, and it will be just fine.

  • 4 years ago

    We JUST finished a double bathroom remodel and while I’m not a tile professional I know the feeling you’re experiencing and wanted to give you some words of comfort. Right now the bathroom is only tile, so you’re seeing and noticing every little tiny imperfection and it looks HUGE and HORRIBLE because your eye is drawn to it immediately. However! Once everything else goes in - mirrors, faucets, counters, vanities, doors etc etc etc all these things stop sticking out so much and I promise you it will stop seeming like the end of the world. Had this been a chipped/cracked tile I probably would have gone with the risk of replacing, but given that the issue is a cosmetic one I’d say to trust the process and leave it as is.

    gtdj519 thanked recordaras
  • PRO
    4 years ago

    No guest, in one million years, will notice or care.

    What guests care about? A clean and uncluttered place to sleep, great mattress, varied sleeping pillows.

    Coverings on the bed that allow for hot and cold sleepers, great bed side lighting, A closet to hang clothes, not jammed up with owner forgotten junk, a basket of "may have been left behind" toiletries....and medical such as Tylenol, Advil. or any achy painful thing in the middle of the night. Rest inducing temperature, not freezing, and not the airless over heated stuffy room.......and an IMMACULATE well stocked bath with good lighting and same thoughtful, necessary items : )

    Did I say "tile free of any tiny imperfection"?..........nope.

  • 4 years ago

    Since no one will answer your question, yes it can be done. Break the offending tile up, use a carbide grout remover to remove mortar and grout, and mortar in a new tile.

    gtdj519 thanked Seabornman
  • 4 years ago

    Thank you Seaborman. i appreicate getting an answer abour if it can be done or if it cannot. at leasr im a bit more informed abour the process when i speak with my contracror tomorow. Thank you very much for the info

  • 4 years ago

    I know you wanted a professional opinion and Seabornman has stepped up. But, truly, I would not change it - for all the reasons stated here. I have a beautiful vintage marble top table which has a very odd splotch on one corner. Completely different look than the rest of the marble. Everyone tries to “wipe up the spill.” It’s a great conversation piece now. However - your niche will not even be noticed by anyone but you. I personally would not risk damage to other things.

    gtdj519 thanked NagyMama
  • PRO
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    It's worth damaging the whole wall in the attempt? Really? If you were my client? I might scream at the installer first, but you'd be next : )

    You're going into this bath to CLEAN it. Unless you are running a B and B. Absolute Perfection is highly over rated. The mostly elusive search CAN make you crazy.

    gtdj519 thanked JAN MOYER
  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Even B&Bs are never perfect . As for freedomplace 1 how was that comment even close to rude , the truth is not rude just the truth. When you post here you need to be aware that when you ask a question sometimes you do not just get an answer that satisfies you and often pros give advice from experience

  • 4 years ago

    Thank you coneneticutt . of course if my contractor says it will pose a risk or be too difficult to do, i will leave as is

    my quesrion was IF it can be done, as i had no idea if it could or couldnt. I like to have some knowledge about a topic before a conversarion about something like this, which is why i turned to houzz to see if any pro could advise.

    that is funmy about your marble.

    If the tile i have here looked as inmocent of a mark as it does in the pic, I wouldnt quesrion it at all variarions are to be expected; i get that I truly wish it did look like the pic!! ithe mosaic is a blend of translucent ones and colored ones this is a translucent tile, so when photographed, I guess the tile blurs in the pic, making it look as if is a colored tile with a litte dark mark. that wouldnt be a concern to me at all; so i could see how peope are saying it doesnt look like an issue . id probably say the same rhing if someone else posted it

    .it looks very odd and out of place in person. ill try to get better pic, but they photograph very different from what they look like in person. tough to get a true depiction of these in pics.

    thank you for sharing your experience; and reassurance; much appreciated


  • 4 years ago

    patriciiais…

    Im not looking for an answer just to satisfy me. I was lookong for an answer about tile work and what can or cannot be done. if people want to go off road and give answers or opinons that werent asked of them; thats fine. That doesnt bother me and sometimes those things are indeed helpful. what is not fine is being rude.


    “And it would in no way be noticeable to anyone here if you did not have a microscopic lens on it. No wonder they are not calling you back.”


    yes; that last comment was not very close to rude; it was flat out rude, and no, not the truth. either either.


    asking a question about the technicalities of how tile work can or cant be done shoudln‘t be such an agregious thing to inquire about. Geez ….. sorry i asked

  • 4 years ago

    and jan… why would you scream ar the installer? its not his fault . the tiles are paper fronted ; he didnt know what it would look like either .

    and then scream at me ( your client?? ) for asking if it is possible that the one tile could be removed and replced without an issue ???

    that doesnt sound very professional .

  • PRO
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Read the comment in entirety. I think it is, in this moment...and for you , because it is so recently brand new? A thing to PERHAPS get overly upset about. The purpose of a niche IS in fact to hold shampoo . Buy a very tall decorative bottle ( plastic and decant )

    1. "It's worth damaging the whole wall in the attempt? Really? If you were my client? I might scream at the installer first, but you'd be next : )

    You're going into this bath to CLEAN it. Unless you are running a B and B. Absolute Perfection is highly over rated. The mostly elusive search CAN make you crazy. "

    Would I risk , or let a client risk it? No. Mostly because of Murphys Law.

  • 4 years ago

    The person to ask your question of is the actual installer. Why would you trust some random strangers on the internet that you know nothing of, over the widsom of your installer? The installer that you say you have a good relationship with and are happy with their work, going back years.

    I have to disagree with all the people that say no one would notice that tile. I would notice it, and would think what a wonderful, unique tile it is. There are layers of color in the glass, and that's why you think it looks like something is behind it. But it is beautiful.

    gtdj519 thanked catbuilder
  • 4 years ago

    Thank you catbuilder. yes , i am going to speak with my contractor/ installer. . i posted here to see if it was something that could be done . I was curious and anxious about what the answer from my contractor may be.I did call him and left a message that Inhad a quesrion, but i did not want to keep bothering my workers on a weekend,, as i will see them on Monday I thought perhaps a pro tile installer on houzz could give me an answer about if a tile can be changed safely or not; if it was even an option at all. Just trying to gage what the response from my workers may be and educate myself a bit about tile install before posing the quesrion to them.

    And thank you for the kind compliment; i appreocate that we too think it looks very pretty and are happy with how it is coming together overall.

  • 4 years ago

    gtdj- I realize my little story of the marble is not the same as your tile disappointment. Years ago, I’d probably have had a moment, too, looking at something that didn’t come out as I imagined. However, whether it’s because I’m older, more experienced and dealing with some pretty bad/impossible choice sh$$ these days, I’m more in the camp of “let it go.” In my 30s or so, I’d have blown up at stuff that I now shrug off.

    gtdj519 thanked NagyMama
  • 4 years ago

    I understand connecticutt. your marble story is a good examole of how hou get use to things that arent ” perfect”

    and perhaps that will be the end result of my bathroom story too.

    However, i dont find anythifng wrong with wanting to ask the quesrion and find out an anwer to that question , without people jumping all over me as if i said ” i hate it alll…. rip up the entire bathroom!“

    it is a quesrion i regret asking on here. I shoukd have just waited to soeak with my contractor or researched tile information myself online. sorry for trying to educate myself a bit by asking a question. . unreal …..

    i do appreciate the sincere reassuring messages and relative responses . thank you to those that did


  • 4 years ago

    This can be a tough crowd, gtdj. I’m sorry that some people are rude. Of course you should try to research options and educate yourself. You did nothing wrong and I’m not sure why people jumped all over you. Maybe it’s because some pros here deal with this stuff all day, are tired and jaded and know the consequences of trying to fix a tile situation like yours. Maybe they know what they’re talking about. But the problem with that is they don’t say it nicely. It’s always in a condescending tone. They could just as easily say something like “wow, I’m sorry you’re disappointed. Here’s my experience…” instead of the nastiness. I’m so tired of it really.

    gtdj519 thanked NagyMama
  • 4 years ago

    100 percent agreed connecticut Yankeeeee!

    pros/ non- pros ….. some of the attitudes on this site are less to be desired. Its a shame because i think there are genuinely kind and extremely helpful members on here that are a wealth of knowledge. I have learned a lot from them and have been helped a lot over the years by them. I even enjoy seeing their projects come to life as they work through them. They are terrific !

    And then there are the others that for whatever reason, seem to enjoy being rude, demeaning , and never miss an opportunity to lace into someone simply asking a question or to tear apart and insult every aspect of a persons room/ home. I have experienced it mysef, but also have seen it repeatedly to many , many members . There are appropriate and inapproriate ways to express opinions, iseas, comments etc

    And no…. I don’t agree with the excuse of ” well …. I have a designers/ pro eye”

    You can very well have a designers/ pro eye and also have a respectful voice. To me, , that is the making of a class act professional, no matter what your trade is. I rhink the same for the non- pros as well. No harm in being nice to others .


  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Thanks HU. congrats on the remodel- a whole house must be a huge undertaking

    And I built a house that was completed 4 years ago and yes there were some of my marble tiles in my master bath that my eye went directly to. I wondered why when they had so much tile left over they didn't use a quieter tile. Guess what? 4 years later, I don't notice them at all.

    You are noticing it, because you don't have all the pieces finished just yet. I'm a fine artist who does realism. I understand your feelings because there are days I'm working on a drawing where I over focus on one area that to me looks wrong but in the overall drawing won't even be noticed. We all have a tendency to do that.

    Once everything is completed, trust me, you won't notice it either. When we're building or renovating, we tend to hyper focus on smaller issues that turn out to be nothing when seen as a whole.

    gtdj519 thanked cpartist
  • 4 years ago

    However, i dont find anythifng wrong with wanting to ask the quesrion and find out an anwer to that question , without people jumping all over me as if i said ” i hate it alll…. rip up the entire bathroom!“

    No there's nothing wrong with asking but if it were me, I definitely WOULD NOT change it out for the reason Jan mentioned; Murphy's law. Why would you want to take the chance of chipping adjacent tiles or compromising your waterproofing. Once your shower door is on, and the shampoo bottle in the niche, it will be even less noticiable.

    gtdj519 thanked cpartist
  • 4 years ago

    Thank you cpartist i can understand that. like toy, . I too am a creative , pay very close sttention to detail and am very in tune to aspects when they are in the working phase. inam glad you have made peace with your room and are happy with the end result. our himes are ohr havens, so its importnat to be sureoudned by spaces that you love . Thank you for sharing your experience it helps

  • 4 years ago

    PS: To give you an idea how much I can focus in on details (I'm very detail oriented), my students nicknamed me Eagle Eyes. So I hear you! Let the whole room take shape and I can almost guarantee you will be ok once it's finished. It's a stunning tile btw.

  • 4 years ago

    We share anothe commonality, thats my nickname too!! LOL

    thank you; the mosiscs are very pretty the pics really do them no justice. i cant fiigure out how to work the camera

  • PRO
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I have a radiologist client right now. He calls himself "Waldo" , and freely admits its a curse. I told him " Seems you can find a flea on an elephants ass''.... and while that may make your vision better than anyone on planet Earth? It will, eventually, destroy your enjoyment of your own home. All this work, all the new Everything will be for naught. Nobody will see it that way, You will miss the entire overall welcoming, handsome, layered, warm , cozy etc!!! by focusing on the 16th or 32nd of an inch and perfect symmetry and God knows what else. It is unrealistic, and it will be a crying shame. Everyone else will be enjoying all of it, and your own f.a.b.u.lo.us and beautifully framed original art.. " Exact words btw: )

  • 4 years ago

    Omg Jan… i posted a quesrion!!! one stinking question about tile installation.

    how did my one question turn i nto this??

    I cant help that I noticed it , and since i did, If there was a simple way of recrifying it , without posing a risk to ruining anything , why wouldnt I then have it changed? if there is great difficulty or a potential probelm with removing one tile, then obviously, it stays as is . The point is that I HAD NO CLUE what the correct answer was, which is why I posted the question. isnt a person allowed to ask a mere quesrion without being chastised for doing so??

    With the exception of ONE member who seemed to adress the techincal question about tile installarion. Based on the answer, he/she may be an installer or perhaps had been in the same situation and has the proper info to share

    The rest were personal opinions about what should or should not be done, or the belief that it may be a risky thing to do. however- I did not get the impression that anyone who believed it may be risky is a pro tile installer. Maybe indeed it is a risk to change 1 tile , maybe it isnt a risk. I dont know either, which is why I asked in the first place

    I appreicate the reassuring kind posts greatly, and the rude assumptive ones serve me no purpose.


  • 4 years ago

    gtdj519 - I too had shower tile (tumbled marble) that had lines or blotches on several of the tiles. In particular were a couple that would be in my line of sight every time I used the shower. I don't think the tiler even really looked at the tiles when he installed them! I had the tiler change them out with no issue to the waterproffing. I also had him change out a limestone floor tile that had a bootprint on it (it was right infront of my sink). No issue to the heated flooring. I also had the tiler change out a glass tile in my kitchen that cracked - he was able to carefully pry it off with no damage to surrounding tiles or the wall.

    I would have been very very unhappy to have had to look at all of the above everyday as this is our "forever" home.

    Best of luck to you!

    gtdj519 thanked rdy2retire
  • 4 years ago

    Rdy2retir— thank you very much for your personal and relevant experience Glad to hear that your fixes were a success and without issues, and that it seems like it may be something i could possibly have done as well, as long as no potential issues.

    truly appreciste yoir response; encouraging .

  • 4 years ago

    It reminds me of show business. Remember Simon Cowell? Was he the bad guy among the rest or just brutally honest? Us creative types....oh well - just get over ourselves.

    Yes, designers are very nice on Houzz, but I'm nice and I've been lured by the animus of social media and posted things I regret.

  • 4 years ago

    "can this one tile be removed and replaced with a better one from the extra leftover tile that we have, even though he already grouted it?"


    Yes.

Sponsored
Wannemacher Interiors
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Customized Award-Winning Interior Design Solutions in Franklin Cnty OH