I think it looks too cottagey and a little too chunky compared to the rest of what you have.

Thank you i agree

Agreed.

What about something more Scandinavian.
I’m thinking oval.

I don’t think those chairs “ want “ a coffee table. Not that part of the room really, with the piano there.
I would try a small ( not tiny) , round or square table between them, with chairs kind of angled conversationally. The table beside a chair is often more comfortable for placing a drink or snack.

I think something with thinner legs, less chunky, would fit the bill. Who sits in these chairs, when, and what do they do? In your current configuration, that coffee table seems more inviting to sit at, on the sag rug, and eat dinner or play a game.

Thanks everyone! I had that coffee table down in the basement leftover from a previous incarnation of the room. I knew it was too big and too chunky and too cottagy, but I'm glad to hear others saw that as well. So, I'm hauling it back down to the basement and replaced it with two small (too small lol) round tables (also from the basement.) Size and shape matter for sure! I'll link updated pictures later. Thanks again!

The chairs look more like dining chairs so either get a sofa to work with the coff table or IMO use a table between the 2 chairs with a lamp

Norwood Architects, can you tell me more, please .