What type of flooring is in the adjacent room(s)?

It’s the same hardwood, which is shown in option 1

Match the hardwood.

I don't like either with that island color.

What color would you recommend ?

I'd change the island color -- it's just this big honkin' black thing admist a sea of white. (or really, really dark brown thing? I can't tell) I see you've got black window trim, but it isn't enough to visually balance it.

The island is not the issue - IMO. It's the sea of white cabinets on the left.

Match the hardwood that is elsewhere for a cohesive look to the flooring on that level of the house. But choose a medium, classic brown color or a light white oak tone-not the gray which is passé already despite it still being a favorite of flippers.

Neither of those floors. They are so dreary. The room needs natural wood tones on the floor.

How about these