The shutters aren't the right size for your windows, so I'm sure a lot of commenters are going to tell you to remove them. I wouldn't disagree with that. Putting skinny shutters on double windows is a builder special treatment. You're on the right track making the garage door the same color as the siding. The porch railing can still be white. The front door would look better if it leaned green instead of blue. SW Urbane Bronze is a popular color that is interesting and would probably look good on your house. It's kind of green-gray-brown.

More green:

BM Boreal Forest AF-480

Another option:

Another option: Remove the shutters and beef up your white window trim

I like your first picture, and on your house, I would leave the shutters, since they do add interest. I would look for a different color than pictured for the door. Something brighter, maybe a darker color teal?

I hadn’t thought about removing shutters but that’s an option. I don’t think I have the option to add wider ones because there isn’t room in some spots to make them even in both sides.

Is that a new paint color @Glo Windows and Doors? I do like it.

Yes, something that plays up the grey roof and portions of your stone...if you choose to keep the shutters.