Software
Houzz Logo Print
lucillle

Fitness Trackers

3 years ago

I no longer have my Fitbit from years ago but would like to start taking longer walks now that Clementine is older, and would like to start keeping track of my distance as a way to,well, keep me on track. There are so many fitness trackers on the market and there are apps so one can use one's phone as a tracker also. What tracker do you use if you have one?

Comments (54)

  • 3 years ago

    I use several. I wear a Fitbit on my bra. My phone uses Samsung Health to track the steps i take when the phone is on me. And I sometimes use Map my Walk when I remember, because I get amused at the pictures I draw with my progress.

    lucillle thanked amylou321
  • 3 years ago

    Amy I just signed up for Samsung Health. Starting a few months back I started keeping my phone with me all the time when I am awake in case I fall or something, so it might be a great app for me, thank you!

  • 3 years ago

    I have Sportstracker on my phone as an app.

    lucillle thanked User
  • 3 years ago

    I have a Zururu, which was recommended on another forum, and I bought it because it is supposed to be able to check blood pressure. However, that function does not work accurately and is worthless. However, it will keep track of steps and amounts of sleep, but if you sit very quietly for a period of time, it will think you are asleep.

    If all you want to do is track you steps/distance, then it is a good very inexpensive option. It also keeps time, in sync with your phone.

    I would love to have a watch that could check my blood pressure, but I do not think that there is one.

    lucillle thanked Lars
  • 3 years ago

    I agree to just use your phone.

    lucillle thanked eld6161
  • 3 years ago

    I use a fitbit Versa 3. I love it. I use it for work as I have to keep track of the time during tours. It offers large numbers and sleep options. You can use it like an iphone and get texts, etc, but I never do. I found the iphone tracker to always undercount the distance.

    lucillle thanked jojoco
  • 3 years ago

    I just got the updated Fitbit Sense 2. I most recently had the Sense for a few years, but I cracked my screen doing IDK what. I do use a lot of the step tracking, sleep, and mindfulness features. It also integrates with the LoseIt app I use to track my food. But your phone will count steps, too. I’d recommend Fitbit or else the Apple Watch.

    lucillle thanked gsciencechick
  • 3 years ago

    I use map my walk app on my phone. its free and has gps so it will tell you the number of steps and will keep track weekly and monthly.

    i also use it as a mini journal, there is a box to write how your walk was and i’ll add the weather, sometimes i even take a picture to member the location or day

    lucillle thanked theresafic
  • 3 years ago

    I use the Wooftrax app on my phone. It’s free. Just by walking I earn money for the animal charity of my choice with no cost to me. I chose my county animal shelter. It measures distance and time and shows my route. My iphone records the step count. .

    lucillle thanked lisa_fla
  • 3 years ago

    I had a fitbit that could clip on, but I often just tucked it in a pocket…and it went through the washing machine in a pocket one too many times. A rice-bath-dry-out only works so many times.

    I use Map My Walk on my phone, like theresa. Free, and it has never gone in the washing machine.

    lucillle thanked bpath
  • 3 years ago

    I love my Apple watch for my 3.5 daily hikes on the trail. Records and announces the time at each mile and all kinds of statistics.

    lucillle thanked lily316
  • 3 years ago

    I love the apple watch too, but only if you have an iphone.

    lucillle thanked sleeperblues
  • 3 years ago

    Following as the crystal on my fitbit is cracked so it will need to be replaced.

    I do like getting texts on it, I use it to keep track of my steps all day, but I find the time hard to see outside when it's bright, and I'd like to have a second hand or an easier-to-use timer for when I'm grilling, or planking. I've seen that ring thing that you wear on your finger but it looks to me to be awkward as it's fairly thick. I'd also like the feature that the apple watch has that it knows when you've fallen.

    lucillle thanked Annie Deighnaugh
  • 3 years ago

    I just use the free version of Strava on my phone for distance, route, elevation gain and speed. It does walking, running, cycling, etc. If you have earbuds it will keep you informed of distance and pace. No need to read it. You can add comments and images. You can also follow other people. My son and I follow each other. At the end of the session you will get a map, stats and pbs etc. If you pay there are even more features like training records, etc. I don't have a Fitbit or similar gizmo. If you just want to record steps there are a lot of simple free apps.

    lucillle thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
  • 3 years ago

    Garmin Vivoactive watch. I do have to take it off at night, as it lights up every time I move.

    lucillle thanked Joan Soles
  • 3 years ago

    I got a FItbit Luxe to replace my Fitbit HD that was at least 7 years old. I like it...but it's hard to read in bright light. Then the little numbers for steps...almost impossible to read. I need a magnifying glass to read the heart rate. It needs recharging every 4 days. I have a cheapie one from China that does blood pressure too...but it no longer links to my computer....I can't change the time or date....useless!

    lucillle thanked User
  • 3 years ago

    I've used trackers in the past, but found them ineffective because they didn't count my spinning workouts. For some reason, the peddling motion wasn't picked up, and it would pick up other motions, etc. They seem overall inaccurate to me, but perhaps they've been improved.

    I didn't know my iphone could do so much before reading this thread!

    lucillle thanked Feathers11
  • 3 years ago

    I currently have the Fitbit Inspire 2. It does the basics well: step count, heart rate & sleep. It has a great battery life; 10 days between charging. I’ve had more expensive ones but this has been a favorite so far.

    lucillle thanked jrb451
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Apple Watch. It keeps me walking every day, no days off. Distance, time, speed, HR, calories, etc. Plus it's so much more. I wouldn't be without it. My AW reminds me when I'm slacking.

    lucillle thanked Bunny
  • 3 years ago




    Here are some screenshots from my MApMYWalk app. Just for fun

    lucillle thanked amylou321
  • 3 years ago

    Lol! My dh likes to go biking when he has time. The thing to do here is to plan your route in the shape of Texas.

    lucillle thanked User
  • 3 years ago

    I use the free Charity Miles app on my phone. As you rack up miles, you also rack up donations to a charity of your choice (of those offered - currently I am supporting the Nature Conservancy).

    lucillle thanked raee_gw zone 5b-6a Ohio
  • 3 years ago

    I am trying to figure out how the apps measure walks. One would think that a phone app would measure true distances. I take shorter steps than I used to, so more of them in a mile. Does the app actually measure steps or distances?

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Map My Walk uses GPS, not steps. maybe it uses the cell location? So not so useful if your steps are walking around your house. And, you have to remember to turn it on. and off!

    lucillle thanked bpath
  • 3 years ago


    The iphone tracks a bunch of stuff automatically including step length

    lucillle thanked lisa_fla
  • 3 years ago

    Strava also uses GPS, so you get the true distance, not steps.

    lucillle thanked floral_uk z.8/9 SW UK
  • 3 years ago

    The reason I am asking is that my Samsung Health said I walked a little over 10,000 steps yesterday. That sounds reasonable because we went for a total of 3 walks, one a walk to a park some distance away and of course back. And, as I said, my steps are shorter than they used to be. But it also said I walked over 5 miles and I just don't see how that could be so.

  • 3 years ago


    Wooftrax would be accurate to see how far you walk by gps .. You turn it on when you start walking and turn it off when you stop. It also shows a map of your route. My FILs phone showed him walking much farther than he actually was. I don’t remember, but I’m guessing you input your height and it figures out your step length. He’s very tall but now hunches over and shuffles. I think you are probably correct about your step length being recorded incorrectly and being inaccurate on distance.

    lucillle thanked lisa_fla
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    I don't keep track of steps, it's all time and distance. I have my exercise walk of 30+ minutes each day, but the Apple Watch is paying attention to my movements beyond that, so my total miles per day exceeds my exercise (goal) total.

    Before I got an Apple Watch I was in denial over how frequently I walked each week. I said it was at least 3 times/week but maybe less. Now it's every. freaking. day. In a way it rules my life.

    lucillle thanked Bunny
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    But it also said I walked over 5 miles and I just don't see how that could be so.

    10K steps is about 5 miles for me, but I do have kind of a long stride.

    Years ago I read that Fitbit has way more accurate tracking than anything else (besides maybe Garmin). And the thing is, Fitbit uses proprietary software and hardware that's not shared with anyone else, so the other companies couldn't really copy what they were doing so well. (note: I'm not sure if any of that is true these days though.) so back then I used to compare my fitbit to my iphone and found them to be off by about a mile or so -- and sometimes even more when there was a phone update. It used to drive me crazy.

    But since then, fitness trackers are getting better. they're doing things like step count plus GPS to calculate distance, and the hardware is getting better and better. One thing for sure: if you have wearable tracker, it will record things more accurately than a smartphone alone. I found that my Apple Watch was quite a bit closer to my fitbit (compared to my iphone alone).

    So my next question is: which one is the most accurate? Probably the fitbit. I decided it doesn't matter, I love the other conveniences my apple watch gives me, and the distance count is close enough for me. But I walk A LOT so a difference of 1/4 or 1/2 mile per day doesn't really bother me the way it used to.

    lucillle thanked User
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    PS: here are wirecutter's top picks for fitness trackers. I really trust their opinion. looks like Fitbit is still the top (with Garmin being a great upgrade if you're feeling fancy).

    https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/the-best-fitness-trackers/

    "Top pick: The Fitbit Charge 5 is among the most accurate for measuring steps and heart rate"

    lucillle thanked User
  • 3 years ago

    I had a Fitbit before the Apple watch. Of course, they have improved since but no comparison in my book. I know my watch is very accurate and yesterday at the trail it measured a 17:47 for the first mile, a 18:27 for the second one and 20:04 for the third mile since I stopped to talk to a friendly deer. I like it announces in a loud voice and also displays and if I take a faceplant like I did last fall ,it calls 911 and my contact.


    lucillle thanked lily316
  • 3 years ago

    Regarding the faceplant feature of the Apple Watch. Only once, thank goodness, during the time I've worn my watch (since mid-2019) have I fallen. It was a buttplant. Legs went out from under me on a slick surface. Nada, no "have you fallen?" etc. However, if I ever shout or yell or otherwise make loud noises via my mouth, it's all over me and wants to call 911.

    lucillle thanked Bunny
  • 3 years ago

    Here is the Fitbit Sense 2. I just set it up last week.

    lucillle thanked gsciencechick
  • 3 years ago

    Bunny, my watch wanted to call 911 when I swatted a mosquito on that arm.

    lucillle thanked lily316
  • 3 years ago

    Outlier here but if I think I walked an amazing amount of steps, I can always check my phone providing that I had it with me when I was walking. Otherwise, I walk til my dog and/or I get tired. I know that it is 1/2 a mile to the corner, a mile there and back. I am beyond the point of caring about how many steps it is but I do applaud you for wanting to be concious of excercising.

  • 3 years ago

    I have used map my walk on my Iphone since at least 2016. when I first got my apple watch version 3, i used both at the same time. They were within a couple of steps of each other. i consider both to be very accurate.

    lucillle thanked theresafic
  • 3 years ago

    Nekotish, a record of my walking and a suggested goal has already increased my activity. And that is good for me (and Clementine enjoys the extra added walking as well). If you don't care about the number that only means that the step record plus a goal would not promote further activity for you, as it does for me, but that is fine, we are all different .


  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    One thing I don't like is I set the fitbit app on my phone before I go for a walk so it will map the walk and tell me the length...but the stupid app doesn't realize that I've forgotten to turn the walk off when I get to my car and believes I can cover 2 miles in 4 minutes and logs it as part of my walk! Especially annoying as, when I don't set the app, the watch clearly distinguishes between walking and riding in a car.

    lucillle thanked Annie Deighnaugh
  • 3 years ago

    I also have Google FIt on my phone. It records my steps and gives me a daily update on how well it thinks I'm doing with heart health. After I became aware of that, I started watching my steps to make sure I had more than 10,000. I would play games with myself to increase them. It's not uncommon for me to get a huge number of steps a day now. It bugs me when we have to take a trip or bad weather impedes my ability to get outside because I'm addicted to the extra movement. I get restless if I have to sit around for long periods.

    lucillle thanked User
  • 3 years ago

    Yes, 1 mile = ~2,000 steps.

    lucillle thanked gsciencechick
  • 3 years ago

    Another outlier here. I am self aware enough to know if my body has worked hard enough or not. Counting steps is something I could see being helpful for those with walking issues or disabilities. All steps are not created equal. Is one walking briskly uphill or shuffling around a mall? The quality of the activity is what really counts toward good health, not how many steps. Is the activity building core strength? I think step counters can add to a sense of well being that really isn't there.


    My observation is that many people don't walk correctly these days. Everyone is shuffling along. Even young people walk like they are constipated. Few people walk with purpose these days.

    lucillle thanked wildchild2x2
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    " The quality of the activity is what really counts toward good health, not how many steps."

    Absolutely. But if the tracker and a goal gets people to walk more,(it seems to be doing that for me) that is a great start. "A journey of a thousand miles begins with a single step".


    Small beginnings can make a real difference to our physical health. Here is a post from you, 3 years ago:


    "In the last year and a half I have gone from barely being able to mount correctly to catching, grooming, tacking ,caring for and working on the ground with horses besides riding them both in and out of the arena. I get to ride great horses and I hope some endurance riding is in my future. I am both mentally stronger and physically fitter at 68 years old than I have been in years. Who would of thunk a Groupon from DH could be so life changing."

  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    My incentives for walking (with Wooftrax)

    1. Guilted into 3 walks a day. if I don’t do it, the dogs at the shelter are missing the donations.

    2. I can see the Top Walkers for my charity. I am #1 and I’m not going to let anyone pass me. Silly, but I feel competitive.

    3. There are side challenges. Right now its still the winter challenge. extra donation for every walk you take.

    The main incentive is health and fitness. I feel like Wildchild. I am improving my health as time goes by. i can see the difference in my arms, legs, and waist.

    lucillle thanked lisa_fla
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    but the stupid app doesn't realize that I've forgotten to turn the walk off when I get to my car and believes I can cover 2 miles in 4 minutes and logs it as part of my walk!

    I often forget to set or turn off a workout too. the apple watch senses that and will ask you if you want to start or stop your workout. it takes about 5 minutes. it will add the steps that you already took prior to the prompt. (of course if you do nothing, it will also count your steps all day long, but this is just in regards to timed workouts.)

    I did find that the fitbit did a better job of knowing when I took stairs or hills though.

    lucillle thanked User
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    I just got a tracker watch that syncs with my phone app. I didn't really need it, I could just look at my phone, but it is so much fun. A new toy! I got to choose the watch face, and besides my steps it shows the time, date, day, the outside temp, and there are a couple more numbers I'm not sure what they are yet. I can get it to do even more stuff but that is all I want it for, for now. The app has definitely promoted more activity as I am trying to make sure I get in the suggested amount of steps; and in the future I will raise that amount.

    Check out the picture with over 8,000 steps!! (I am not a tech whiz so I don't really know how this happened but the wristwatch is now communicating with me. I took a short nap (us seniors do that sometimes) and after I woke up my wristwatch buzzed and showed me a message that it was 'time to get moving' and when I got the leash and Clementine and I started our walk it told me 'good job!!')


  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Like bunny I no longer use a tracker, my fitbit and watch both counted me just swinging my arm as steps so eating a bowl of ice cream counted towards my total steps lol. I started walking a minimum of thirty minutes everyday after my stroke in addition to everyday tasks like mowing the lawn, golfing, biking , playing with kids, swimming and house cleaning. I no longer track steps or calories and feel healthier than ever and satiated without binging.

    lucillle thanked roarah
  • 3 years ago

    Check your cell phone! Some have step counters right in them, such as the Apple iPhone. It's all my husband uses when he goes for long walks. I use my Apple Watch. While it's old (series 2), it no longer has Apple updates, but still does everything I bought it for: fitness tracker, text messaging, missed phone calls, and whose at my front door? ;)


    lucillle thanked WittyNickNameHere ;)
  • 3 years ago

    I am using BP Smartwatch as a fitness tracker. The main reason is that it is relatively small, easy to carry, and has many functions. I have to say, with it, I have become more and more sporty.