Software
Houzz Logo Print
rnmomof2

Mismatched appliances?

3 years ago

I am ready to give up on our F&P dish drawers. I never thought I would say that but the bottom one isn't working currently. It has an error code which is fine because we never used it. That may have contributed to the issue.

Anyway, I'm tired of it not cleaning well, the arm getting blocked by something falling down thru the grid, dirty silverware, etc. We have had them for probably 15 years plus so they have lived a good life.

We just replaced our frig with an LG and the DW is close to it. Further down the kitchen is a Samsung range and microwave.

Do you think the average buyer cares if appliances match or coordinate? The handles are of the same style on both brands. I am looking at an LG dw with an exterior handle that would match the frig.

Our house would be a "move up" versus a starter home for someone if that matters.


Comments (36)

  • 3 years ago

    It's personal. I know I like mine to match, but if I had to replace and couldn't get the same, I would at least want the finishes to match.

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked eld6161
  • 3 years ago

    Yes, I would want the finishes to match, but LG Stainless Fridge, Bosch Stainless DW, it's all good to me.

    I know I have read about 'different handle designs' but it is really about performance with appliances. IMO

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked localeater
  • 3 years ago

    I like the finishes to match or at least look intentional. Brands and different handle styles....no so much.

    This house had all white appliances when we bought it, stove white with a stainless panel across the front and stainless oven door handle. When I replaced my dishwasher in January, the model I wanted did not come in white. I bought stainless and I didn't even notice it after about day #2. (no handle, must have a finger cubby or it would block an adjacent utensil door). Cabinets are all white with brushed silver hardware leaving me feeling free to add more of the silver color. When the built i microwave has lived out its lifespan, I could do either white or stainless I think.

    I wouldn't add black to the mix. Or, I'm of an age when colors were available in appliances. At one time I had an avocado refrigerator and stove ;) Those replaced copper in that small kitchen!

    Go for function please - you'll be much happier if all are performing flawlessly ;)

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked morz8 - Washington Coast
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Also, appliances all seem to fail in a relatively few years these days. Buy what fits you now, not what someone down the line might or might not like. I simply do not understand tweaking my beautiful home for what a future buyer might want. Buyers I’ve known fix their new homes to suit themselves, regardless of the tweaks the sellers have made, at all price points.

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked sheesh
  • 3 years ago

    I bought each appliance for my needs so none are the same brand or handles but all are the same finish. Function before form is important to me.

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked roarah
  • 3 years ago

    If resale is the concern, I would try to make them match, not necessarily the same brand.

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked arkansas girl
  • 3 years ago

    In a high end home....I'd expect some high end name brands and a LOT of them. In a move up home....nothing has to match. They just need standard features like a counter depth frig....or low sones(quiet & a 3rd rack) on the dishwasher. JMO

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked User
  • 3 years ago

    The dish drawers are the last black appliance. All the others are stainless so now they will all match. Our house would sell for probably $500 k ( in the Midwest) and I am guessing none of my neighbors have matching appliances.

  • 3 years ago

    I purchased 2 dishwashers last year. I put one in a rental...one in my home. I've never used the WIFI feature....but I really like the low decibels & water bottle jets. Link You might look for these features if you want an LG. I paid $899 each for open boxes. Looks like they're selling a little higher right now...

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked User
  • 3 years ago

    For me, color is more important than brand. In my kitchen I have a jenn-air, a GE, an Electrolux and a Viking... 2 are black, 2 are covered with cabinet doors. I don't think anyone has noticed the brands at all.

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked Annie Deighnaugh
  • 3 years ago

    Not important to me at all. Just put in matching finish on the best quality appliances that fit your budget.

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked jojoco
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Brand and handles don’t matter but the color should be the same. I have black appliances except for the range which is stainless. It has a lot of black so coordinates nicely. Had the same thing in another house because there are very few ranges in black. There are ever fewer black appliances and I don’t love stainless and black stainless is a passing thing in my opinion.

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked 3katz4me
  • 3 years ago

    Matching? As in all the same brand? That would be insane.


    That said, both my washer and dryer are Speed Queen, but that's because they're the best for what I need. My DW is Bosch, stove is Wolf, and fridge is KitchenAid.

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked Judi
  • 3 years ago

    Nope! I like to choose appliances based on what I need as well as quality and reliability. Electrolux induction range stainless and white washer, white Samsung dryer, stainless Bosch DW, and Big Chill/Whirpool fridge in Beach Blue.

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked gsciencechick
  • 3 years ago

    No matching here either. We have GE, Kitchen Aid and Electrolux. The appliances that are side by side are the same brand and handles, so maybe they give the impression everything matches. Stovetop, wall oven and microwave are all GE (original to the house), all in close proximity. DW and ice machine are side by side, both KA and new. Electrolux Fridge also new but on a wall by itself.


    If we ever gut this kitchen i am either having all built in fronts matching the csbinets or all off white appliances (biscuit, not almond, lol).

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked Kswl
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    I think the washer and dryer should look like a pair, but if the laundry is in a separate room altogether, that is less of an issue. Mine are both LG, but I bought the dryer earlier, and it has a white door, whereas I picked a SS door for the washer when I bought it later, thinking I could buy a replacement door for the dryer, but the SS doors had been discontinued by then. The washer and dryer match in size, and I think that is what is important, and they are in the back part of the kitchen, behind the peninsula and so are not prominent.

    I asked a coworker (who is an interior architect) about this, and she told me that it was okay to have non-matching doors, especially since the appliances otherwise matched.

    For the main part of my kitchen, I have SS refrigerator, MW, and DW, but I have a red Bertazzoni range, which I was told is very popular with flippers in my area.


    In Cathedral City, I have SS DW and stove, but the refrigerator is matte black, and I kept it because it is opposite a bay window overlooking the pool, and there would be serious glare on the fridge if it were stainless steel.


    The microwave is also black, and I chose to keep that. Black is part of the color scheme. Here's a before photo:


    The recessed lighting had brown trim rings, and I replaced all of those fixtures with new LED recessed lighting with white trim rings, to match the ceiling color.

    I would not mix black with white appliances, but I will mix black with stainless steel - the stove itself has already done that. I much prefer black to white, but I do have whitish countertops in CC, whereas I have black countertops in L.A.

    I did not choose colors for my CC kitchen for resale value, as we plan to stay in that house longer than in the L.A. house. My real estate agent told me that the renovation I did increased the value of the house, but that is partly because we replaced decrepit cabinets. The colors I chose are popular in Palm Springs, and buyers who are priced out of the market in Palm Springs tend to buy in Cathedral City, as we did, since we get so much more for our money there, and PS is less than 10 minutes away.

    The washer and dryer in CC are in a separate laundry room, off a hall that connects the bedrooms and the garage to a hall that leads to the living room. Therefore, laundry is close to the bedrooms and very far from the kitchen.

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked Lars
  • 3 years ago

    Consumers prefer if all appliances in a kitchen have the same finish. After that it's a crap shoot as to which buyers are so picky/observant they would notice if the appliances are a matched set or acquired over time so not all the same brand. To assume a company makes the best for the money range and fridge seems to be a leap. I would hope buyers appreciate the quality of the appliance over if the handles all matchy match.

  • 3 years ago

    If the finish is the same and the handles are the same or similar, no one is likely to have an issue with them. For a DW, you can always do an integrated handle as well -- some folks prefer nothing sticking out while others prefer a handle that can be used as bar for drying dish towels. But honestly, if you are preparing to sell you house, what most potential buyers will care about is brand new dishwasher. Period.


    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked lascatx
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    In a high end home....I'd expect some high end name brands and a LOT of them. In a move up home....nothing has to match.

    I see it differently. In a high end home, the best in each category is usually a different brand, and things like fridges and d/w are usually custom paneled as well. La Cornue doesn't make a d/w, and Subzero doesn't make a stove, etc etc.

    I think, if they are not paneled, the should be harmonious but still does not need to be the same brand.

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • 3 years ago

    @mtnrdredux_gw...I'm not the one asking the question. Please address the op.

  • 3 years ago

    I'm another who doesn't care if they match, but I want the finishes to be the same or at least to coordinate.


    When we bought our house three years ago, all of the appliances were white. We prefer stainless with black accents and have so far replaced the white stove with a stainless/black Miele, installed a stainless hood and the white microwave with a stainless model. The fridge will be next and eventually we will replace the white dishwasher, although it is a very nice Bosh that works perfectly, so we're not in a big hurry to do that. We will also replace the kitchen sink with stainless which I much prefer to white.

    Meanwhile, we're living with a mix of white and stainless/black which doesn't bother me.

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked Rosie
  • 3 years ago

    Dear RNmomof2 zone 5,


    In re @User's comment "In a high end home....I'd expect some high end name brands and a LOT of them. In a move up home....nothing has to match:"


    I see it differently. In a high end home, the best in each category is usually a different brand, and things like fridges and d/w are usually custom panelled as well. La Cornue doesn't make a d/w, and Subzero doesn't make a stove, etc etc.


    I think, if they are not paneled, the should be harmonious but still does not need to be the same brand.



    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • 3 years ago

    We are definitely NOT a high end home! I ordered the LG today that matches the fridge and now makes all of our appliances stainless.

    Now to get used to bending over to load a new dw. ugh, old age!

  • 3 years ago

    If appliances are directly adjacent, like a washer and dryer, I prefer them to match. I replaced both my washer and dryer when the washer went out. (Sold the used dryer so it didn't end up in a landfill or anything.) For kitchen appliances, I replaced the KitchenAid dishwasher that matched the set with a much better quality, but older used Bosch diswasher and I couldn't be happier. The handles don't match and no one has ever made a single comment. I do think ideally it's best to keep the same finishes or at least look like it's intentional (such as a bold colored range with stainless fridge and dishwasher). Personally I'd buy the best dishwasher in your situation rather than worrying about matching handles.

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked pricklypearcactus
  • 3 years ago

    Glad you found one you liked, Rnmom!

    I asked a similar question a few weeks ago re: washer and dryer... and thought I'd circle back on that in case it will help someone else.

    I wanted a dryer with a hamper door (only available from whirlpool) ... and a higher end washer. When I looked at them in person, not only was the height off, there was a huge difference in build quality. I opted not to mismatch!

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked Funkyart
  • 3 years ago

    @mtnrdredux_gw..😂😂😂

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked User
  • 3 years ago

    TBH, and not that I am in alot of kitchens, but I cannot think of one that does not have matching appliances color - wise. It just seems to be the way. KSWL, I love biscuit! I wanted that when we changed out appliances a few years ago, but could not find it in all the pieces. I have never liked stainless and it definitely does not work with our antique cabinet and cottage vibe. We went with white.

    RNmomof2 zone 5 thanked Tina Marie
  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    I cannot think of one that does not have matching appliances color - wise

    My Maine house has a turquoise fridge, My CT house has a jet black stove. I think Gscience has the same fridge as me. But I agree, outside of choosing "colors," they do usually match

  • 3 years ago

    In some states, appliances are considered real estate and stay with houses when they are sold, and in some states they are not. In California, refrigerator, clothes washer and dryer are not real estate. Movable stoves generally stay with the house, but that is not guaranteed. Anything built-in, like a dishwasher, is considered real estate and does stay with the house when sold.

    In Texas, I believe refrigerators are considered real estate. I don't know about other states, but we were taught about this in my interior design classes in Texas.

  • 3 years ago

    Kitchen appliances always stay, washer/dryer seem more negotiable here in MN.

  • 3 years ago

    My former home had some very expensive appliances. My range cost as much as a used car. I never even considered everything matching. I did, however, make sure everything was relatable and jived together. However, my range was like my big piece of jewelry or art for my kitchen and it was superb. Every appliance has it's own top notch variety. I felt it more important to get the best that I could from each appliance I needed. I never considered matching the brands. That is just me though.

    I say pick what you want and what works and makes you happy. If that is matching appliances then more power to you!


    I would never even think of that when buying a high end or just a small bungalo. As long as each worked well and blended nicely, I would not care.



  • 3 years ago
    last modified: 3 years ago

    Lars, in Texas, the usual is pretty much what you describe for CA. Washers and dryers as well as refrigerators typically move with the seller unless otherwise agreed -- the exception being built-in refrigerators and built in wine coolers. Those would be expected to remain with the house unless otherwise agreed. They do remain with some frequency, but realtors will usually separate them from the sale of the house with a personal property addendum.

  • 3 years ago

    When we sold our house three years ago, I was so, so, so happy to leave the side by side refrigerator behind. It was less than five years old, but I detested that thing! :)

  • 3 years ago

    Just a thought:

    Mismatched sounds unintentional, like a mistake. Unmatched could simply be appliances of different brands/styles/finishes, that are allowed to coexist together.

    Until I got a new stove in 2020, I had a stainless fridge and DW, and a white stove. At first it bothered me, but then I thought, if it's okay with me, no one else's opinion matters. My old stove was sort of sweetly unassuming and frumpy. And then its oven light went out and couldn't be removed for replacement. It was time. I was sad to see the old stove go, but now I love my new one (it matches!) mostly because it's got better burners and a better layout up top.

  • 3 years ago

    Personally, I have always had matching finishes and prefer that. I never even thought about the handle style until I saw posts about that on the forums.

    In my last house when we replaced appliances, they were all different brands but same finish; they were replaced at varying times .

    In this house when we replaced, it was in remodeling mode and all were replaced at the same time. There was a better "deal" to get all one brand and so they happen to all be the same brand (and finish) and I guess handle styles match but I really don't focus on that.