I need pics please . Post here in a comment do not start another post .IMO the sink should if at all possible be centerd on the window so I need to see where you are talking about. Usually only pot lights where unblance is in the space no pendant to bring attention to the off part.

Pics would help for sure - are you open to recessed lighting over the sink as well?

We are in mid tear out so don't mind the mess. We will be doing an undermount single sink in the same area. With this being an older home we are pretty tight for space. The sink location will not change, nor will the cabinet size it sits in. As you can see we tore the bulk head out above. As we have recessed lighting in the rest of the kitchen we were hoping for something different over sink.

I have three windows over my sink in my kitchen which was remodeled 15 years ago. The sink is NOT centered on the middle one. We recessed all the lights above that counter. You might try to arrange the recessed lights so that at least one is located right above your sink. I would not draw any more attention to the asymmetry of your sink location by installing a pendant over the sink. (I had to go and look at where the recessed lights were located above my sink and they appear to be located on either side of the double sink.)

We did recessed lighting over our sink. Many of the pendants over the sink i’ve seen, tend to look dated after a while. Plus, the pendants…whether semi-flush or not, tend to get grimy.

Appreciate your input - is there any other options than recessed lighting? (not my personal preference as I have light sensitive eyes, the recessed lighting in the rest of the kitchen had to be adjusted down to 3000k and on a dimmer).