I think I might try to match metal without matching the style of glass, especially since that mirror already has a similar/competing pattern. Many options out there! Do you need ambient light, or just down-light? That will help narrow things. (Also, I'd at least consider reducing to two pendants, as this feels like it's in danger of being a very busy space. Can't tell the length of your island...)

Here are some ideas to help you think.

Hines 1-Light Pendant, Black, Seeded Glass · More Info

Chloe Lighting Walter Industrial 1 Light Pendant, Matte Black · More Info

Watts 10.5" Glass, Metal LED Pendant, Oil Rubbed Bronze/Clear, Width: 13.25" · More Info

Kira Home Wyer 8" / Farmhouse Pendant Light, Glass Cylinder Shade, Dimmable · More Info

I skipped the lantern-style ones, because I don't think you need any more black lines, with chairs and chandelier and mirror and all the rest.

Thank you for your input!

So you can see it.

I would install one fixrure with 2 or 3 lights. This would eliminate two of the black "lines" that, I feel, chop up the visual from one area to the other. Just cap the other two to match the ceiling.

So many black lines with chairs, bar stools, and even the pet crate! I agree with one fixture with 2-3 pendants.

I would go for a similar style/look as the other light. Something like these: Lights

The first one is too small and not centered over the table and the second Is dated. I would keep looking. Make sure you get the scale right:

https://www.lightology.com/index.php?module=tools_chandelier_size

If using pendants, chrome chrome/silver w/glass to coordinate w/DR fixture.