Wayyyyy too big.

@k8cd What should approximate size be for one mirror if we went that route? Vanity is 55” wide.

I think it’s your bathroom not your contractors & your opinion is the only one that matters. If you had a single mirror that covered the 55” width would that be considered too big? I doubt it. If your mirrors were this same 24” x 38” size but had a much larger frame & less mirror, that might look too heavy with all the frame width around the mirrors. But, your mirrors have very narrow frames & are mostly mirror so not an issue. The mirrors don’t exceed the width of the vanity which I think would be too big. BTW - are the users of this bath on the tall side height wise & maybe the taller mirrors provide a needed function for you? Looks like you have a nice rain shower head & in the same color as the mirror frames - nice! Because your mirrors are wall hung / removeable, you can always do a mockup with a smaller size to see what you think but again, your opinion is the one that counts.

They look too big to me. I would get one large one or two smaller ones. I prefer sconces on either side of the mirror. I think they light up your face better.

I agree they look too big and in fact that vanity it too small for 2 sinks too. One simple mirror 55" wide would be my choice but honestly only one sink and if that was centered you could have done one of those mirrors.

I would probably do one big square mirror. Take the oval ones off the wall and mark out the space with blue tape. You can have large custom sized mirrors made by local glass/shower/frame stores.

The mirror should be at least as wide as the outer edges of the sink on either side. But I wouldn't get any taller than 32".

I think that you could even get one that is the length of the vanity. I linked one that is 55” x 30”. It’s a little shorter so it takes up a little less visual room (and because there would only be 1 not 2) and then lights would be at a more appropriate height.

This happened to a friend who was remodeling- putting the mirrors over the sinks looked too close together and the proportions were just off. She put in a single large mirror and it looks great!

Tape it out on the wall and see what looks good. Or large piece of cardboard as a mock up.

One long mirror over both sinks would be better. And that would reflect more sunlight and tile!

Yes, they're out of proportion. You'd be better off with one large mirror (framed) to top the small vanity.

and in fact that vanity it too small for 2 sinks too.

True. This vanity would've worked well with a single sink + a bank of drawers. Lack of drawers at the vanity is not a good choice.

Tape it out on the wall and see what looks good. Or large piece of cardboard as a mock up.

Seeing is believing! Creating a mock-up is always a good choice.

I am assuming it might be too late for this, but any chance you could return that vanity and get a 72”? Looks like there would be room for it (depending on the door swing) and with 6 people using the bathroom I think storage is probably pretty important.

Knowing there are 6 people, have you thought about an inset medicine cabinet? I can’t find a 55”. But am linking a 59” and 48” below.

I like the 2 lights over the sinks (and still would if you went with the medicine cabinet). The clear glass will be a pain for upkeep but you might be more into cleaning than I am.

Mirrors on each side would be really far apart and only light one side of your face (but if you decide to go that route, a taller mirror would be nice).

https://www.westelm.com/products/frameless-seamless-triple-medicine-cabinet-b4298/?catalogId=71&sku=493154&cm_ven=PLA&cm_cat=Google&cm_pla=Bath > Medicine Cabinets & Mirrors&region_id=780420&cm_ite=493154_20632409400&gad_source=1&gclid=Cj0KCQiAj_CrBhD-ARIsAIiMxT_iAhcU0Dmb4Fk6gObUQ6D2dY7hOkzhxLTQXRzqLcK748xRiL-7R5caAn9ZEALw_wcB

https://www.homedepot.com/pep/Glass-Warehouse-Calla-48-in-W-x-32-in-H-x-5-in-D-Black-Recessed-Medicine-Cabinet-with-Mirror-SC3-SQ-48X32-B/321724439

For sure a larger vanity with more space on the countertop would have been nice.

If you opt for the one mirror - ensure that it does not look like a builder grade.

Good Luck!

No disguising the fact that they make your vanity look too small.

Unfortunately there is for sure not enough space for anything larger or I definitely would have gone that route. This is max size. Door is angled and there’s a toilet on the other side of the door opening. It would be way too narrow/obstructive with a larger vanity. I had originally ordered the 60” but after mocking it up reduced to the 55”.

You could have gone over to the right, it did not need to be centered on the wall. I think the real point is you are making your vanity look too small with the out of proportion mirrors.

The Original Poster has explained that 55 inches is the size that will work. I think that the mirror K8cd shared from Lowe's would look very nice.