Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_283081375

How to improve existing oak railing?

2 years ago

Like so many homes, mine came with oak railings that have a slight orange tone.

I have plenty of it, including in a loft overlooking the living room. I am reluctant to replace with new ones.

I am trying to to see what paint options might work. I know black railing is a trend. But I do not like it. I could do simply white, same color as my other trim. I am afraid this make it look a bit cheap. Cream color? Grey? Or a mix?

Appreciate any input!



Comments (12)

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    The oak seems pretty prevalent throughout. If you want less paint the spindles, newell posts, and stair kicks white

  • 2 years ago

    Oak does not paint attractively IMPO so I suggest you swap out the spindles for bought pre-painted white ones and leave the rest.

  • 2 years ago

    you could try changing out the spindles to the square. it updates it and you can prime and give one coat prior to changing



    or, choose a nice white and do something like these (you could lightly sand the handrail and do a darker stain if you like



    you can also change out the newel post



  • PRO
    2 years ago

    Too bad you don't like black, even though it's a trend it is a great look.

    What about a neutral brown, and then paint the balusters and risers white? You could also add a stair runner to cover some of the oak treads.

    After doing a search on Houzz for "white staircase railing" this is the ONLY one I came up with in the almost hundreds that I searched. Do you like it?


    REX · More Info


  • 2 years ago

    I actually kind of like it in the contest of your room, but you could tone it down a bit by painting the spindles and lower part of the newel post white to match your other trim like the second last of one of Beth's befores.

    The afters look good, too, I am not saying they don't, but the rest of the house that you can see in those photos looks different or updated, too. So many pictures in the age of Instagram and Pinterest are shown completely without context. They look great in and of themselves, but who knows how it plays with everything else about the house.

  • 2 years ago

    thank you all. Changing out the whole railing would be the way to go. But there is a ton of it. Even replacing the newell would require at least 7

    My thinking was not to have the railing as it is dated. That is why I kind of dismissed the light grey paint idea.

    With white everything would start to blend. Maybe keep the rail in oak and paint the spindles?


    For context: my walls are Atrium white, so there is a slight reddish tone depending on light. The trim is a shiny white. I feel that the trim white would make the railing look cheap.

    I also feel like I should not have too many colors.


    What white would you use?



  • 2 years ago

    The white should be the same as the trim. White spindles don't look cheap ... they look white!

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    it won't look cheap.


    use the same white as this baseboard, in a semi gloss finish. make sure to get a good trim paint like BM Advance


    I think the black looks sharp.




    consider doing a runner of some sort





    this is a large project to do yourself. all those spindles must be sanded (i'd use a 120-150 and remove all gloss. you can also use a de-glosser, but I'd still fine sand first) , wipe w/mineral spirits, primed (I'd use a spray primer since it's easier and lighter coverage, but you will have to tape/plastic off the surrounding area!)


    after that dries, the primer coat must be fine sanded w/a 220-320 grit. vacuum, wipe w/damp rag. Now you can paint. it's easier to spray (but again, you'll have to plastic sheet off the surrounding area) lay down a light coat, 2nd coat the next day.

    it's a ton of work. I've done it.

    if you want to redo the handrails, fine sand to remove all gloss/top coat, mineral spirits, and get a wipe on gel stain. one coat. apply poly when dry.

    here's some tutorials:

    https://heatherosteenphotography.com/diy-how-to-stain-and-paint-oak-stair/


    http://www.twopointsforhonesty.com/2015/02/refinishing-oak-stair-railings.html


    https://theladydiy.com/how-to-gel-stain-an-oak-banister/


  • 2 years ago

    White spindles with a stained handrail, white risers with stained steps are classic looks. I lived in several houses built in the 1830s and that's what they had from day one as built.

  • 2 years ago

    Sanding all the spindles scare me a bit :-). I tend to be a perfectionist, but sanding all of them with the contoured shape is going to be involved.


    How about the "base plate" - where the spindles are held? White as well?




    (p.s. this is a view from a floor up where we have carpet on stairs)

    that gray wall will be white shortly. Not sure what I was thinking....


  • 2 years ago

    No. That band at the bottom of the spindles is "Floor".

  • 2 years ago

    You have beautiful and timeless railing and floors. Keep them and add some color to your walls.