How about white with a boos walnut top. Like this.

Thank you:) I meant a table top for the work table.

You can order a boos counter top in custom sizes to fit on your work table. I made my prep table years ago and cut on it and the boos walnut looks like new after a quick oiling. It was already at least ten years old when this picture was taken.

Just clear coat it. Then find a remnant of your perimeter counter for it. Or a plain pure white. Or, match the white of the counter, and put a butcherblock on top. No to 2 colors of wood. Or a different paint and another counter color. That is too many finishes and materials

From the photo, you don't have black appliances. Most would call those stainless.

I would stain the table a color similar to the darker brown in your floors. I would probably also use the same quartz you have on the perimeter.

I like the white with the butcher block top, but if you prefer stained, I would be trying to get to a color similar to the wood shelves you have (not black) and use the same material that is on your perimeter cabinets for the top.

you can do different things. the primary thing w pine is the softness....your kitchen is small...this island will be used..heavily....I would probably paint the frame and legs and do a dark stain on that bottom slatted area...then top coat the shelf w good quality semi gloss poly. Have you had pine case goods around where use is high?

here is uniform darker stain probably a satin top coat if any...

Tiburon home remodel · More Info

here is paint and w the occasional scratch / knick you can freshen up those spots....paint will toughen up the surface too as the paints are so consistently being improved.

Rosemary Woods Classic Kitchen · More Info

heres paint in a chosen color then the shelf stained and you can see the top coat for hardness and heavier wear giving protection once the use of the shelf starts.

West Chester Kitchen featuring Dura Supreme Craftsman Panel Door · More Info

there are a few ways you can go.....maybe think about it.

I think the elephant in the room is my kitchen work table is too large:( which I have to work with. Would that lend towards painting white? I love the dark painted table with white top but my chairs are black and it may be too harsh black paint with white top?? I so appreciate all these suggestions and it really has me thinking!

I would stain it with a hardwax oil. I prefer Rubio Monocoat. Unlike most stains, hardwax oils react with the wood and don’t crosslink at all. So you end up with a coating that is more durable than most stains but is easily repairable… just a light sanding with 120 grit sandpaper and reapply and it is good as new.

It is popular for flooring and tables but great for other pieces that will see moderate use. Here is a link for available colors.

https://www.rubiomonocoatusa.com/pages/oil-plus-2c-colors?species=pine

ETA: Because the coating doesn’t crosslink, it is easily one of the most DIYable coatings available. You put on just about any amount you want, work it in with a white pad, wipe off the excess.

work table is not too large but the aesthetic of your space looked really pared back before the island. the island changes things a bit. Normally I like rustic pine things but I can see white or a favorite paint color.....youll have a few baskets pots or something on the shelf I suppose so the table top will make the difference.....if you get a simple solid top or a lot of pattern etc. Just let all this sift thru your brain.......I think it'll be great when you decide.

Interesting how similar the cabinet doors and table are to yours.

The Redfield Home · More Info

I don’t think it’s too large - I think it’s just a big change. I would be tempted to take my measurements and visit some local stone yards and look at remnants, you could find something fabulous — then the stone selection would guide paint or stain for the rest of the piece

FWIW i agree that same white as cabs will feel lighter - do you need the bottom slatted area? i feel like that‘s adding a lot of the bulk - but don’t stress, it’s a beautiful piece!

kismet house did dark stain and leathered black granite. it looks like a devol dairy table.

The picture may be deceiving but I’m thinking the work table may fit better in your space if turn the other direction. Your husband did a nice job as it’s a pretty piece. I agree with others that it would be nice to keep the natural look of it by just clear coating it. Instead of black I do a white to match the other counters.

Beautiful table, thoughtful husband. Black against white cabinets is too harsh of a contrast and white against the brown floors is also too harsh of a contrast for the middle of the room. Clear coat is too rustic.

Get a wood top and stain the entire top and bottom the same honey color as your shelves. It will make the whole piece disappear more into the floor color. You will still get to enjoy the shape and craftsmanship, however, it will meld a little more into your space.

I have a custom Boos countertop and it is a dream.

"No" to white paint. I think the table only looks too large because of the camera perspective?

My suggestion is to pick up your blacks (window trim, chairs, appliance details) with Virginia Mist honed granite top. Leave beautiful wood and it’s beautifully placed grains, natural so it stands up to flooring. This piece can tie all elements together. Here are some concept photos to help you visualize. I would not use white. The eye sees white first and you have a lot of white already.

Here’s rough mock up of how it can look in your kitchen/eatting area. I am not sure you can hang a light over the work table but it would be a nice addition.

Call stone yards around you to find a piece of Virginia Mist. If you can find it honed, it mimics slate but much easier to maintain. 😊

I like flos pic w/the dark top.

as for the pine, throw away that minwax stain. it's the walmart of stains.

I've done tons of wood finishing and prefer varathane of General Finishes

to seal it, this is the best stuff to use. wipe on 2-3 coats w/a rag.

Pine is difficult to stain since it tends to be rather yellow or get blotchy. ALWAYS apply a wood conditioner first.

I have come across some weathered wood stain product that looks nice on pine, and comes in many stain colors.

Weatherwash

they have clear coat and the stain

this is on pine. The charred is nice,,

here is 'Pined"

you can also mix two of the colors.

get some leftover wood pieces and try out the diff stains to see what you like.

go to a fabricators shop or stone place and see if they have any small remnants that are going in the trash. Theyll cut and finish it for you for 100-200 bucks.

Take your photo and the measurement of the table to a stone yard and see what they have in remnants. I agree with both Flo and Beth - stain it (or just seal it) and look for something like Virginia Mist for the top. Not black.

You never know what leftover piece might look perfect in your kitchen. But a stone piece is a great idea.

And your husband is sweet to make this for you. It just needs some finishing up.