This is a pic I was just playing with. I thought I would like a clay siding but I'm not sure !!! I think the white siding is too much white for me .

I'd do the siding in a warm brown. I would put cream gutters on, you don't want bright white with that warm brick.

^^ Agree, you don't want white gutters or trim. Cream would be by far better than white, but even better than that would be dark brown gutters that mirror the color of the dark bricks you have. Look how beautiful the color of the dark brown shutters in your mock-ups look against your brick -- same concept with the gutters.

Pick a color from the brick, and I agree with the others, white isnt quite right for your house with the warmer colors of the brick. Cream would look much nicer on your house. You also mentioned stone. No, to that. It would make the house look way too busy.

A soft sage green is good with brick. Do you have to replace the siding or can it be painted? Use the opportunity to remove the shutters. It’s a great house!

What color would you call this brick. Home built in 1979