Siding: BM Nantucket Gray

Trim: BM Moonlight White

What would you do for the peaks/beadboard?

Another option from SW. Just thinking it could look nice with your roof color.

I would google “Victorian exterior paint palette” and then scroll through the images to find a combo that appeals to you.

This weird app wont let me post links so you will have to type out or search for

oldhouseguy dot com / projects / exterior-paint-color-portfolio Note there are 34 more pages, link at bottom. There's a lot! He takes a more colorful authentic approach - which in its own way can have a freshness and appeal different from the overdone gray + white.

oldhouseguy.com/projects/exterior-paint-color-portfolio

Was going to say also that I actually kinda like the colors as they are now! The grays/ golds have a nice faded aged look to them, even though the materials are new!

Thanks Debbie - it looks so much better than the original cedar siding that was falling apart. The peaks & beadboard at the top are dark green. I also like the shades of unpainted hardie board colors so could find paint similar to that but need something for the peaks & beadboard. My sister-in-law recommended SW pearly white, which I like. Not sure for the whole house with other color for trim and peaks, or the the trim. I only want to do this one time and have been looking so much I'm getting overwhelmed and way over thinking!

Thanks Lisdv - that looks really pretty. The image you chose is actually not the front of the house but what you've provided it lovely. Its is hard to tell - are the peak and beadboard at the top the same as the body of the house? The neighbors right across the street used very close to these colors and I love their home. Thanks again for you response and time working on the image.

I thought the 1st photo was the front so here is another visual of the front with the 2 bay windows. Same idea though, I suggest you build a roof above the porch area (see inspiration photo). The shingle gables are the same colour as the siding.