Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_27711313

Which color rose would grow?

2 years ago

Originally i hoped to plant a pale purplish shrub rose in my yard, how the ones I found did not seem to do that well in heat and all day sun with no shade. I thought poseidon would work, but I read it would wilt on heat, and love so g isn't in my zone(6b/NY). I found some other purples and pinkish purples that might work.
Purples:Blue Skies; Blue Moon, Lavender Veranda, Violets Pride, Ebb Tide, and celestial Night.
Pinkish-Purples:Angel Face, Perfume Factory, vineyard Song, Sister Emnanuelle, Kendyl Marie, Paris de Yves St Laurent, Deja Blue, Sweet Madeemoiselle, and Pretty Lady.
Will a multicolor like the pinkish purples grow in the sin and heat more than the purples(or just pale purple)? Has anybody grown these and prefers one over another? I need sun/heat tolerant and doesn't need wintertime protection.

Comments (19)

  • 2 years ago

    I was going to suggest a rose which is plum perfect for your stated cultural requirements but may not meet your vision of purple - so I won’t mention its name.


    Poseidon here doesn’t get full sun before 11:15A or after 4:15P. It will ball with rain, but does not wilt with 0% cloud cover.


    I see, from your list, that you are fortunate to live in the blackspot-free part of NY.

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    I would not call Kendyl Marie anything other than pink or hot pink but it is an exeptional rose. Your area probably has a strong blackspot pressure and many of the ones mentioned like Angel face are huge blackspotters. Unless you are experienced at growing roses and spray I would do more research regarding disease resistance of the varieties on your list.

    Plum perfect like rifis mentioned is a more purplish rose and worth a try. Quick Silver is another worth looking into.

    I love Kendyl Marie. She is small here after heavy prunning but she can be a 4 1/2 or 5 feet tall plant if you let her grow.

    Kendyl Marie blooming here in mid April



    Kendyl Marie blooming at the end of may with temps in the 90s (no spray perfect foliage)

    The light pink is the fairy




    Plum Perfect and Kendyl Marie together.


    if you have space for a large rose try Flamenco Rosita she will not disappoint in the sun. She is hot pink that fades purplish.

    Here showing a proliferation but it doesnt do that a lot. She is a rockstar, solid health and strong rebloom. If I had to choose a flaw it would be her very mild almost no scent.


  • 2 years ago

    Those roses are spectacular.


  • 2 years ago

    I do not know how blackspots are in my zone, i have only planted one rose so im looking for more. i thought i would ask if anybody has tried any of the roses on my list, and let me know how they grow and their tolerance/resistance.

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    From your list the only ones I have grown are lavender veranda, Kendyl and angel face. Both lavender veranda and angel face get a lot of black spot here. I can tell you that in your area black spot is a huge concern. I hope others with black spot pressure can comment on the other roses on your list.

    If someone says a rose performs great but they are in a dry area without black spot their comment does not apply to you at all. If they are in a humid area like me with lots of black spot their info is more relevant but still not something you can bet on. There are different strains of black spot and many other things affect how the rose performs. Ideally you want to find someone close enough to your area and buy stuff they have tried. We have lots of people from the north east here so I hope they can offer some help soon.

  • 2 years ago

    I think i am leaning towards celestial night, violets pride, or loesong(i think poseidon gets too tall nless i couls keep it at 3 or 4ft). how do these roses do with blackspots? Aside from lovesong, how do these roses do in all day sun heat with no tree?

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    In central FL last week the temps were 95 to 100 . Violets Pride bloomed a lot of crispy & burned roses . Celestial Night usually stops blooming in heat . If it blooms then the color will be fuchsia not purple . Sweet Mademoiselle is orange and a stringy bloomer in all seasons for me .

    HU-27711313 thanked Pink Rose(9b, FL )
  • HU-27711313 thanked rifis (zone 6b-7a NJ)
  • 2 years ago

    Blue for You is a fabulous florabunda



  • 2 years ago

    Neptune is by far my favorite. Second is Perfume Factory. I like Neptune's color best, but PF has downy resistance unlike any mauve I've seen prior. Many mauves are prone. The REAL Shocking Blue (the real one has HT form and holly-like foliage) is also a favorite. Sweetness has amazing color and fragrance, but kinda top heavy.


    If you want true purple, go Ebb Tide, Diamond Eyes, or Twilight Zone.

  • 2 years ago

    This is my Neptune stored on HMF. Ive had it for at least 15 years.




    They're 8" in spring, 5-6" in summer here.

  • 2 years ago

    Such a nice rose, i love it. i like the size of neptune, but does it grow like hybride(singularly one rose on a stem)? How does neptune perform in wintertime and summeryine sun and heat?


  • 2 years ago

    Neptune is a wide, fat HT. About belly button high. Usually 3-5 per stem. It is still an HT. It's just among the better of them.


    If youre into this tone of mauves, Dianne has a pretty picture of Love Song. She swears by it. Another Weeks mauve. I have not grown it but I trust her opinion.

  • 2 years ago

    the neptne is fabulous and i would lovesong, i just worry it cant take full sun or wintertime weather.

  • 2 years ago

    If i prne neptune down to 3 or 4ft, could it give me more of a bushy look?

  • 2 years ago

    Jadae

    14 hours ago

    Neptune is a wide, fat HT. About belly button high. Usually 3-5 per stem. It is still an HT. It's just among the better of them.


    HU-27711313Original Author

    5 minutes ago

    If i prne neptune down to 3 or 4ft, could it give me more of a bushy look?



    HU: May I ask how tall you are?



  • 2 years ago

    do center for ebb tide rose and lovesong rose look the same?

  • 2 years ago

    No, Ebb Tide has very full + informal form, and Love Song has full + semi-formal form.

    HU-27711313 thanked User