Definitely the smaller one.

The smaller one placed along the sink looks natural and balanced. The big one looks like a trip hazard. Cute kitchen, but the EAT sign is a lot, lol!

It depends on why you want the rug. If you want a rug by the sink for comfort while standing, and to protect the floor from water, then the smaller one. If you want a runner, then the larger.

I voted small on your other post. I love your wall color! If I may, I think your wall décor detracts from its beauty, though.

Connecticut Yankeeeee suggestions??

Could you answer my question?

Diana Bier I just thought the larger rug added more color and visual interest

One more vote for the smaller one.

Kim, your answer has nothing to do with the purpose of the rug. Of course a larger rug will be more dominant in a space, especially one with a pattern. The question remains, What do YOU want the rug for? If it's for looks, then go with the larger one. If it's to cushion your feet/legs/back and provide absorption of water while doing dishes, then go with the smaller one.

The rug, whatever size, does not work with the wall decor. Keep the ethnic style rug and get rid of farmhouse stuff on the wall.

I took the wall decorations down but they definately need somehing as you can see in the pictures

Well, the larger one isn’t good because it’s too wide for a pathway” runner” and puts your footing on 2 levels in your work zones, opening fridge.

Hi Kim - yes, now I can see the beautiful color! I can’t quite get your layout based on your pix, but from what I see, I would not add anything to those walls. You’ve got plenty of interest with the bead board and your lovely wood floors. It’s very nice as is, imo.

Way better without the visual noise of the wall art.

I like the clean walls and the two smaller rugs. Your wall color is fabulous.

Way way better without the wall decor clutter! Your light pendants, nice cabinetry, lovely paint color are interesting and are enough.

Thanks for your comments the plain walls look so bare. It will take me a while to get used to it. I just feel like it needs something.

The point of the rug is to protect the floor so near the sink is where it should be if you must have one > Think they are tripping hazards unless they are antifatigue ones that sit tighter to the floor .

The bright white trim around the door and baseboard…is distracting ..perhaps match the other whites in the kitchen..so it is no so dominany

dominant..🤷🏻‍♀️

Tell us about your fridge. Did you paint it?

No, it is a refigerator skin i ordered