Would you consider a gray/green with soft white trim? Something like this but ignore the shutters.

This shows Benjamin Moore Saybrook Sage that’s a nice shade of sage green.

If you do not like MCM what style do you like? I happen to love MCM so I need more info. Post all dealing with this question here now in comments DO NOT start another post.

@chloebud Thank you! This is so pretty. I love the soft sage. Adding this palette to my favourites!

Your house was built mid-century but is not MCM style - roofline, overall shape etc are not MCM. I looked at your favourites and see that you like aqua for the front door. That would work with your existing house colour. Or are you planning to repaint the whole house?

@Patricia Colwell Consulting (Sorry, I couldn’t get this to tag you directly! New to this site!) I know I’m in the minority…MCM is so popular and I also know it’s probably the best option for the house! Not completely opposed, just not my ideal. I LOVE craftsman style. If I ever build my dreamhouse, thats the style. Just not sure how (if?) to incorporate it here?

@partim Thank you! I forgot I had those favourites from when I first bought my house so thanks for the reminder! I love the idea of the aqua door. The whole house does need to be repainted. It’s in poor shape. Figured this was a good opportunity for a whole facelift! :)

partim has a good point regarding an aqua door working with your current house color. A quick and easy fix for now!

This same idea but with a 2-step porch...

B.M. Newburyport Blue for siding.

B.M Central Park for front door AND storm door. I like the green with your foliage.

@lisedv I really like this! The grey is a colour I had in mind but wasn’t sure how it would look. Love the porch with railings. will definitely consider that option!

@elcieg I LOVE this blue! So many great options. It’s going to be harder to decide than I expected! lol

Here's you house in blue suggested by elcieg: