SW Shell White

BM Navajo White pulls a whisper of peach in my house.

You can always take a color you like a dilute it with more white. That said, the color will change with the light. My study is BM Marry Me diluted to 50% strength. Somedays, my study reads as pink, other days as a pinkish neutral. It is warm. We got it painted in winter and kept thinking that we'd left the lights on, since it looked so warm. It was just so much warmer than our other rooms (mostly far more saturated colors).

You mentioned a neutral, orange undertone.

These are BM colors and suggest speaking to a paint consultant or just look in the appropriate section to compare/find intensity you are looking for.

BM Pale Almond is very slightly peach. Palace White is more peachy. I have used both of these in the past.

https://www.matchmypaintcolor.com/farrow-ball/setting-plaster-231/#google_vignette

Another source for matches

https://encycolorpedia.com/edd8c3

So get he F&B becuse no one coppies it well .I find alot of their colors have an effect of changing at dirfferent times of the day and IMO if you love a color from F&B pay the price and get it .I am not a lover of peach but I could do that one that touch of brown just takes it to anoter level of depth which I why I love F&B paint. None of the ones posted match IMO

Perhaps Benjamin Moore Soft Whte. To me Setting Plaster has a pinkish cast.

https://www.colorxs.com/color/soft-white-2170-70

My suggestions arearen’t meant as matches to FB Setting Plaster. 🙂

These are light near neutrals from the same Yellow-Red Hue Family neighbourhood.

ItIt’s possible to compare and contrast them in detail, via their measurable colour attributes.

Hue Family / value / chroma / LRV

No need to guess at this anymore!

see them all on the color dna table @thelandofcolor.com

Don't go looking for "peach". Look for a off white with red undertones. Take a look at B.M.

White Opulence OC-69. It will be a perfect back drop for orange accents.

Rather than jumping right in with orange, consider a stronger peach color with orange undertones.

Then add a peach based orange.

I have been using this as a neutral for years. Three rooms in my present house and I will probably use it with a darker coral peach in my kitchen. It is a barely there warm color and looks fantastic with deep oranges to pink and even warm purples.

Thank you all so much for these suggestions! You really gave me a range of options to consider, from barely there to full on saturated color but still muted.

FB Settling Plaster is a great color.

I tried to go with a BM match and it never looked as good. If you can get this in FB go for it. You won't regret it. Something about this color makes a space feel warmer, calmer, cleaner.. Truly a great color I loved this. Here are some options by BM but you may not find the same feel as the FB colors. Post some images when you finish so we can see the lovely color.