I would go black. The "close" color hinge would like more like a miss.

I had the same issue. Went with the slightly different colored gold. It doesn’t bother me. But if you know it will drive you crazy, go with black.

Black would seem jarring to me. I think I'd go with the near miss because who looks at hinges?

Looking at your photo, the gold shades work nicely together and since the hinges and door handle are for the same door unit it makes sense. The black idea seems too jarring with the aesthetic you have going on. Beautiful shower!

Mine don’t match exactly and it doesn’t bother me in the least. No one has ever commented that they don’t match.

In this case close is better than black .

I have a similar situation and went with the gold. I would not do black at all.

CR Laurence might have a better gold "match".