Software
Houzz Logo Print
mtnrdredux_gw

"Rain"coat review

last year

So the criteria for my coat quest is:

  1. Knee length
  2. Tan or olive
  3. Warm
  4. Repellant
  5. Belted or fitted


"Jojo's coat," the Eddie Bauer, has not yet arrived but it does not meet criteria #5 so I will have to see if it redeems itself on other criteria. I ordered one from Bogner and I love it but it also does not meet criteria #5.


Meanwhile I got one from Nordstrom, below and it meets a criterion I did not know I had, call it #6... it has an integrated hood that is removable, fits close and warm, and does not make me look 8yo or like a conehead.


It meets all of the other criteria, pretty much. There are a ton of reviews on the mfrs site. Some say it is warm some say it is not; so I will need to see that for myself. The mfr site calls it "water repellant" and some say it is great in the rain others not. DH points out "if it is really cold or really rainy, you are heading back to the ship, no?" Probably.


Here is the coat and my review. For the price, I will keep it and if nothing else have it at the condo as a back up.


I like it a lot. It seems quite warm to me, love the hood as I said. The sleeves are adjustable and have thumbstraps for extra warmth. You can remove the "vest" and hood. The pockets zip shut, which I like. It is very flattering, esp for a puffer coat. It is most certainly fitted; to a fault in some reviews. The sides have these stretchy panels that make it form fitting. Some people complain that they dont lay flat, I did not find that. It might depend, physique, and what you have on underneath or maybe if they had sized up? But I like it because it really envelops you, which helps keep you warm. Some agree and some say the panels are cold.


For travel, I can see using this as a blanket or even a pillow. Several reviews say that the inside has straps that allow you to fold it up and wear it as a backpack?! The site does not mention that.



Comments (14)

  • last year

    Bonus: it looks like it has a vest under!


    Seriously though, I like it, and like that the quilting looks nicer than a lot of coats (looking at you, northface). So of course I had to look because I had never heard of this brand, and now I want this Bernardo Suede Shirt Jacket | Nordstrom ... too bad they don't have petites.


    I was having zipper issues with my go-to rain jacket in Austin, so I have been looking at the famous Jojo model. I am just not in love with the colors available in my size.

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked Sueb20
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    The "vest" is removable but I think it adds to the warmth.

    Easier to see in this color:



    The jacket is cute and a great color for you. I love the Nordstrom "models;" always helpful info

  • last year

    Mtn that coat looks very warm! I have an irrational bias against chevron baffles (I think they make me look like a turtle or armadillo) but I do have a heavy jacket that has a removable zip-in puffer liner that can be worn by itself as a light jacket--- so handy for changeable weather or a wide range of temperatures.There's no downside to keeping something from Nordstrom's for as long as it takes for you to decide.


    I wish the Eddie Bauer GirlontheGo coat still came in a brick red or a light tan because I would buy it just on the strength of the many recommendations from GWers, but in a tall size because I like a longer coat.

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked Kswl
  • last year

    Ok, I tried the GirlontheGo coat and it was a no-go on me.


    The GirlontheGo coat is very plain cotton-like material without much detailing and the green color it came in was more Pine than Olive. Overall on me, with my linebacker shoulders, DD2 said it gave her "assistant coach vibes." It is prob better in blue or black.


    I also would need to size up in that one (heaven forbid!) to accommodate say, a thick sweater.


    Growing every fonder of this "Transformer" coat with its accordion sides. Still cannot figure out how to wear it as a backpack!? They must've poached the guy who writes "instructions" for Ikea furniture.



  • last year

    I also ordered the jojo coat in size medium. I am a medium in almost everything unless I want something oversized (sweatshirts). I love the coat. However, it's too small in the bust area. I would say I am very mid size in the bust - B cup. It fit perfectly everywhere else. Sleeves may be a little long but that doesn't bother me, and I actually prefer longer vs shorter.

    I've reordered it in large because I do really like it. It should arrive tomorrow. Hoping it works because I do like it and I think it fits what I need.

    Looking forward to your review to see if you have the same issue.

    I do like the one you got. It does look very warm, and very stylish.

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked jsk
  • last year

    LOL; my reviwe is above. What color did you get?

  • last year

    Mtn, if you are currenlty having wet weather, ideally wet & windy weather, please go out side in the Nordstrom coat and check how the coat withstands water, particularly the sides. I like the look and idea of that cost but some reviews mentioned it not being very water resistent. Thanks.

  • last year

    LOL, the snow is done. Plus I worried if i get it wet, can i take it back? When do you need it?

  • last year

    I can wait until you wear it on your river cruise (?). I just thought ”we” could strike while the iron was hot, or the skies were wet as it were. I don’t need another coat, but it did catch my eye.

    mtnrdredux_gw thanked hhireno
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    You know actually I forgot I decide to keep it either way. I shall let you know when it is UL tested

  • last year

    ha, I read your review and didn't realize it was THAT EB coat.

    I got black.

    So it wasn't tight in the chest area for you? This is weird because I am not an odd size. I mean, I do not have clothing not fit my chest area when it fits everywhere else.

    I think my size L arrives today.

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    I bought my EB coat about 8 years ago and as I described in Jojo's original post it has become my go-to winter coat replacing my LL Bean down coat. Fortunately I was able to try it on in the store and see the different colors. It was a toss between black and really dark navy but since I have a closet full of black coats I went with the dark navy. Mtn mentioned that it was a 'very plain cotton-like material.' I don't see that on my coat but it is most noticeable on the photo of the grey heather coat. I also went up one size to allow extra room for bulkier sweaters.


  • last year

    My girls on the go coat definitely gives off varsity vibes. I just prefer to think of myself as a player vs a coach. Most important feature is that it is waterproof which is why it is so warm. The wind cannot penetrate it at all.