For me, the white shaker cabinet doesn't give the industrial moody vibe you describe. You don't show any of your decor except for the end of a kitchen cabinet but here's another idea...

Hard to know what “industrial moody vibe” means. Show pics of things you consider industrial moody and it will be easier for people to come up with ideas for this space.

Would need to see the rest of the room - however, based upon the comment by lisedv, I like her mock up with the black cabinet instead of the photo white shaker one.

The mirror is al wrong do some coffee stuff and shelves for cups and that coffee stuff . IMO the cabinet really does not go with the rest of the cabinets so draw your eye to the wall but not a mirror that reflects nothing worth seeing twice . I do agree a dark color for that cabinet is a must .The kitchen as I see it is not IMO moody at all maybe a new all shiny industrial type coffeee maker could be a good start . I see nothing industrial so maybe lets us see the whole kitchen

No. Nothing about it relates to the adjacent kitchen.!!

Buy something completely different, Paint the wall behind it....add art, a lamp. Ditch the mirror

Crate and barrel.......

Currently you have country kitchen next to city loft. What attracted you to the white cabinet? It has to go to meet your stated design goals.

Forgive me? It is not "being swallowed" It is sticking out like a sore thumb!

Painting it will not help. It is a style issue, a material issue, if your style bent is "moody /industrial.

It's return what you bought, start over, and save your $$$$ until you can do it right.

Failing that?

Relocate the coffee pot, do some fabulous black floating shelves and wait for something else.

What do you think of coffee posters or art that might be able to blend the browns and whites and off-whites / softer browns and cream/ecru colors?

https://www.wayfair.com/Great-Big-Canvas--Hello-Coffee-by-Jennifer-Pugh-Vintage-Textual-Art-2399794_1-L1318-K~GBCN7112.html?refid=GX148683917886-GBCN7112_24956555_26544548&device=m&ptid=325425753764&network=g&targetid=pla-325425753764&channel=GooglePLA&ireid=30343322&fdid=1817&PiID%5B%5D=24956555&PiID%5B%5D=26544548&gad_source=1&gbraid=0AAAAAD9ISC7dEaDwKrAe9r8F2oQOSn1EE&gclid=Cj0KCQiAz6q-BhCfARIsAOezPxlMwvH6PlxMRcdVQCb0RPZ34iIZlVeABnQJfi3T2PuMFqXWgtZtE1oaAo5LEALw_wcB

https://tailoredcanvases.com/products/personalized-coffee-bar-sign-v?variant=41831861846105&tw_source=google&tw_adid=736662541608&tw_campaign=21863025260&gad_source=1&gbraid=0AAAAABmUFZF4XeIzYm8lsoFe9rY-F_4cG&gclid=Cj0KCQiAz6q-BhCfARIsAOezPxng7xQCS2uaidhTnRZo8zBrMoLJEmmsZ3jqyglPQWM2h03KRl0RMGYaApGkEALw_wcB

Brand MWzZUPQ https://www.amazon.com/MWZUPQ-Espresso-Minimalist-Terracotta-Aesthetic/dp/B0DN9PXTC5/ref=pd_aw_subss_hxwPER_sspa_mw_detail_m_sccl_5/133-1934687-5971326?pd_rd_r=20f6d1fc-662c-493e-afd9-eb2cece8b1dd&pd_rd_wg=8U6AZ&pd_rd_w=uqwWv&pd_rd_i=B0DN9PXTC5&psc=1

Brand: Nufar https://www.amazon.com/Coffee-Better-Poster-Vintage-Station/dp/B0CLXYV3TF

Wayfair https://www.wayfair.com/Great-Big-Canvas--Hello-Coffee-by-Jennifer-Pugh-Vintage-Textual-Art-2399794_1-L1318-K~GBCN7112.html?refid=GX148683917886-GBCN7112_24956555_26544548&device=m&ptid=325425753764&network=g&targetid=pla-325425753764&channel=GooglePLA&ireid=30343322&fdid=1817&PiID%5B%5D=24956555&PiID%5B%5D=26544548&gad_source=1&gbraid=0AAAAAD9ISC7dEaDwKrAe9r8F2oQOSn1EE&gclid=Cj0KCQiAz6q-BhCfARIsAOezPxlMwvH6PlxMRcdVQCb0RPZ34iIZlVeABnQJfi3T2PuMFqXWgtZtE1oaAo5LEALw_wcB

What kind of industrial moody are you looking for? Grays in steel, pewter, concrete, warmer in brass, copper... Deeper tones of green or blue, or even rusts or safety teals. I personally would skip the black- it's moody, but I'm not sure you need to go that dark with the lighting you currently have.

The current cabinet is underwhelming for that nook. I love the mirror but... maybe look for a steel bakers rack that can fill that space. There's a lot of variety in bakers racks, you can likely find one you like. Or a beefier natural wood cabinet with a stainless top. If you want to go a bit more hardcore, iron pipe frame with wire baskets and either a wood top/shelves or a steel one. Look to the tones in your existing hardware to choose your cabinet/rack metal.

If you want to add in some workshop-ish vibe, you can add in a backboard to hang things on. Your coffee cups, tools or accoutrements of a beverage station.

If you can, try to get a light in there. If you can't hardwire, there are options for a plug-in that you can then suspend as a pendant. There is a plethora of industrial vibe lighting out there.

I agree, the white cabinet, does not go well in your kitchen. There are pictures of some above that look considerably better. I also agree that mirror has to go. Put up some shelving with some of your coffee stuff on the shelves. I also think, the white cabinet is not deep enough, it looks lost back against the wall. Find one that is closer to your cabinet color and is deeper. The one you have is barely deep enough for a coffee pot. My coffee bar is 24 inches deep, and it works perfectly.

Cabinet (color and door style), top and mirror are the entire issue. They go with nothing.

Advisors so far are entirely correct.
The current cabinet and mirror are a total disconnect and need to be removed.
Find a cabinet that is at least the same depth as the adjacent brown structure.
Try a steel plain bakers rack if you want an "industrial " effect,or use a more hefty lower cabinet and add several shelves to the upper wall that fill the horizontal space.
Happy updating!

Looks like a cottagecore vanity wandered into the kitchen. Ditch the mirror entirely. Paint the cabinet black. Stain the top to match the other cabinets. Then do some iron shelf brackets on the wall and match the cabinet wood for the shelves. Add actual coffee stuff, visible.

Can you purchase additional cabinets that match what you have?

Absolutely no reason for a mirror. Look at other coffee stations.

Beverly: "Can you purchase additional cabinets that match what you have?"

Yup. That's the best solution.