Software
Houzz Logo Print
dedtired

Jeni’s ice cream

last year

A couple of Jeni’s Ice Cream stores have opened near me. There was a lot of chat about their flavors, which are mostly unique. CBS Sunday Morning did a piece on her and her success. Today I went to Whole Foods and noticed the pints were on sale so I bought Sweet Cream Biscuit and Peach Jam flavor.

I was so disappointed. It wasnt very sweet, did not taste much of peaches and the biscuit was tasteless crumbs. Maybe I should have tried the mint chip, my go-to flavor. There were other odd flavors like Lavender and blueberry.

At least I satidfied my curiosity.

Comments (36)

  • last year

    Is it just me? Or are food "vendors" (restaurants, bakeries and other venues) going a tad overboard with trying out new flavor combinations that may be delightful to some folk but leave others at a loss? IMNSHO, if they want to go crazy, fine, but at least offer less contrived combos for the rest of us unenlightened fuddy-duddies!

  • last year

    But wouldnt you think peach and biscuits would be a good combo? How can you ruin that but she managed to do it.

    Heres a link to her flavors. The only one that sounds totally weird to me is goat cheese and raspberries. Sometimes I think people imagine themselves as sophisticated by being weird.

    Jeni’s flavors

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    I'm not a big fan of ice cream and I usually order some version of dark chocolate. I threw caution to the wind the other day and ordered this and inhaled it.

    (The shop has regular flavors too.)

    Couch Potato: a burned sugar ice cream with house-made chocolate-covered potato chips, brownie bites, and chocolate freckles

  • last year

    I'm gluten intolerant so I've really appreciated that Jeni's has a few clearly marked gluten free options. I can't always find options at the store, but my favorite is the Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks. I have been longly looking at the Peach and Biscuits but can't eat it, so honestly that's kind of nice for me to hear that I'm not really missing out.

  • last year

    Dee, who makes that? I do like a sweet and salty combo.

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    Me too! I don't think it's sold in stores. It's a place near a friend's house in NC.

    https://andiasicecream.com/

    You can order it through Gold Belly but it is pricey.

    I'm going to try the date night flavor next. Another sweet and salty flavor.

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    Oh, I want to try that Couch Potato ice scream, dee! Love the name!


    Good chips covered in great chocolate are addictive. I first discovered them many decades ago when I worked at a florist -- neighboring barber's wife made these infrequently, and they were inhaled rapidly by all of us!


    Now I am craving them.... (resist, resist making any, she admonished herself)

    dedtired thanked roxanna
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    My momma was born in 1917. When she was in grade school in a tiny town in Ohio the elderly lady next door would make homemade potato chips fresh fried just for her and her friend when they walked past after school. Years later in the early ’60’s my Momma would eat Charles Chips , delivered to the house in a big can, and she dipped them in chocolate ice cream as a snack eaten in bed while reading a book . Only when Daddy was out of town! I sure miss her.




  • last year

    Aw, Still Trailing, my mom was born in 1917, too. She lived to be 105. One of her specialties was homemade ice cream, which she made every July 4th. Wed take turns churning.

    Was Charles Chips regional? I remember them being delivered in big metal cans, which are now collectible..

  • last year

    We had moved to New Orleans by then 1963. They returned the cans when another was delivered.


    My Dad was raised on a farm in Central Ohio. When he was a boy , he was born in 1910 , his Mom and Dad cut ice from a pond in the area and stored it in the big barn ( my little brother and I loved playing in that barn) they piled hay bales around the ice blocks. Come July 4th they used the last of the ice to churn ice cream. During the Depression my Grandmother made ice cream with the yolks and Angel Food cake with the whites on almost a daily basis because there were so many eggs . There were many families that walked by on the road looking for work. My Dad and Grandfather hired the men for $1 a day , excellent pay at that time, and the women helped my Grandmother cook. My Grandfather raised prize winning hogs and in November they butchered them . They had a huge cauldron of rendered fat and deep fried the tenderloins and ate them standing around by the firelight.


    Wish I had recorded all the stories.

    dedtired thanked Still trailing
  • last year

    ded, mint chip is my fave too. But it must be green.

    dedtired thanked Bunny
  • last year

    Bunny, agreed.


    ST, I love your family stories. My grandparents lived close to a dairy farm. We spent so much time in that barn. The farmer was a patient man! Mostly we climbed in the hayloft and patted the cows. I wohld bring chicks and bunnies home where we admired them for a while and then had to take them back to the barn. My grandmother made stretch taffy and homemade root beer. Id pay a thousand dollars for a bottle of her root beer now.

    Somewhere I have my mom’s ice cream recipe but I dont have a churn.

  • last year

    Really enjoy these stories. My dad would make homemade ice cream occasionally when we were kids, usually vanilla or pistachio, his favorite. We all helped turn the crank. Periodically, I think I should try making ice cream but have not tried it yet. Maybe this summer.


    A friend was talking about Jeni Ice Cream the other day, she enjoyed the Goey Butter Cake flavor, but not as much as the ice cream at our favorite local ice cream shop. They have the best ice cream, the chocolate brownie is my go-to.

    dedtired thanked jill302
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    Love the ice cream memories.

    I am not particularly fond of ice cream. I don't like it being so cold, and I really find cones stressful. Hurry before it drips is no way to enjoy dessert, amirite?

    Growing up I liked Bassett's, the vanilla with a caramel ripple or better yet with a peanut butter ripple. I never see the latter annywhere anymore.

    I confess one of the shops here makes Goat Cheese Blackberry Chambord ice cream and I love it. It has just a bit of tang, like sour cream.


    dedtired thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    I'd try that! Sounds very rich.

    I always get a cup. And Andia's that I mentioned above sells cone chips which are the perfect topping for a cup of ice cream.

    dedtired thanked deegw
  • last year

    Have to give a shout out to the best ice cream store in my area, Handels. Unfortunately for me, its right across the road from my hairdresser, so I have to fight temptation every six or seven weeks. I have to plan ahead and bring a cooler, then drive home fast, which honestly isnt possible around here.

    C&C Creamery in Roxborough is as good if not better and they have a drive through.

    Handels

  • last year


    We just tried these....it's mint ice cream...then dipped in chocolate...then rolled in crushed chocolate cookie crumbs. Delish!

    dedtired thanked nicole
  • last year

    Dedtired, we had Charles Chips in Lakeland, FL when I was a kid in the 60s.

    Donna

    dedtired thanked msmeow
  • last year

    Funny, I always thought Charles Chips was local. Live and learn.

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    We didn't get Charles Chips, but I babysat for a family down the street that did. Pretzels too. I thought they were so fancy to come in a big can.

    I find peaches in ice cream and a number of baked goods to often be disappointing. My mom loved Blue Bell's peaches and cream ice cream, so when I saw it a couple years ago, I thought of her and bought some. It didn't have that much peach flavor -- I blamed the peach season, but I've had a bounty of good peaches and made things like muffins, coffee cake or cookie bars that lacked much flavor. Peach pie with the same peaches was great. Peach jam -- awesome. I wonder why peaches shine in some things and get lost in others.

    My son just came back from a trip that included a Ben & Jerry's stop. He found out they still make Chocolate Therapy ice cream and a berry sorbet that hasn't been seen in stores for years. Now I want some.

    Mtn, we agree on so many things, but not ice cream. I don't get ice cream out very often, but when I do, it will almost always - maybe always, be in a waffle cone if they have them or a sugar cone if they don't. But you can't eat it standing in the sun. Maybe that's why my dad would take us out for ice cream at night when we were young. But he would "help us" with a drippy cone and it felt like we got half of it back. Fun memories.

    dedtired thanked lascatx
  • last year

    The few times I’ve had Jeni’s Ice Cream, I’ve been underwhelmed.


    I wonder why peaches shine in some things and get lost in others.


    I believe I’ve read that the freezing mutes the flavor. I made peach ice cream once with terrifically ripe peaches and it was fantastic. I made it a couple more times and it was very bland. I quit making it. My maternal grandmother made peach ice cream and I hated it. The peaches were always little hard rocks of ice. I’ve read that macerating the fruit in liqueur or liquor keeps the fruit from freezing. I made blackberry ice cream for the cookbook club. Macerated the berries in something (probably vodka) and they were still little chunks of ice!


    @Still trailing, I remember hog butchering time in November, too!

    dedtired thanked bbstx
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    Thanks Nicole! Now I want one of those FatBoy Mint Cookie sandwich pops, but the "where to buy" is not working on their website. My closest supermarket (big chain) only has the basic FatBoy vanilla sandwiches.

    Edit - just checked the Walmart website and they have it at my local Walmart, which I rarely go to, but might need to make an exception!

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    My son would love those Fat Boys.

    Bbstx, interesting -- but IIRC, we had fresh peaches (white from our tree and yellow ones we bought) when I made the muffins and coffee cake and the flavor got lost. I made scones also -- marginally better. I freeze some peaches, but I don't usually use them in baked goods with a better because they get so juicy and I haven't played with keeping the juice for flavor and subbing for any other liquid -- which can be cream or buttermilk and part of the texture and flavor too. I will make a pie or cobbler with those -- or whir them up and make sorbet -- and the flavor is always great there. I blame it on the batter and it being hard to get the ratio of peaches needed and still have structure. Maybe?

    For the record - I don't think I've ever had Jeni's ice cream. I think of Austin and my years of living there when I hear the name, but that was Amy's - and Back Porch in Ft. Worth. We had several Marble Slab locations and one of another similar style shop. All but one Marble Slab closed. We are in the process of getting new shops, but they come slowly. I have one of those Cuisinart ice cream makers where you have to freeze the bowl. DS used to make a lot of sorbet, but we stopped having the bowl in the freezer and you have to plan way ahead. I'm thinking about getting a compressor unit -- for me and the grandkids I don't have.

  • last year

    My local Walmart also has the Fat Boy Ice Cream Sandwich Pops! I would never have thought to look there if it weren’t for chispa! Thanks.

  • last year

    BTW, we are going out to lunch today to celebrate our anniversary, and I am getting a small cup of Goat Cheese Blackberry Chambord after. One thing I really like about this place is they offer very small cups, like gelato places usually do. None of the American portion nonsense where 1 scoop is never ever one scoop, and the word "small" is totally abused.

    dedtired thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • last year

    Happy anniversary to Mr. and Mrs. Mtn. Enjoy your celebratory ice cream.

  • last year

    Happy Anniversary mtn!

    For anyone near Bucks County, PA -- the best ice cream I've ever had is at OWowCow. There's one in Lambertville and a couple others in the surrounding area.

    I am not the biggest ice cream fan. It's not my first choice when I want something sweet. But I make an exception for OWowCow. It's amazing and their whipped cream (whipped fresh by hand) is so good.

    As far as I am concerned, the only ice cream flavor worth eating is coffee (or espresso). DH and I get a hot fudge sundae with which ever coffee flavor they have that day and split it. Yum.

    dedtired thanked jsk
  • last year

    I grew up there, and will be there this weekend. Too bad i ”don’t like” ice cream.

  • last year

    It could change your mind!

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    In the hot summer I do like a good ice cream now and then. DH and I will sometimes take a ride in the convertible to Handel’s for their ice cream. It’s about the best around here in a shop. Of course I can buy Blue Bell or Mayfield at Publix, either of which are good. My favorite is a vanilla base with peanut butter cups and caramel, or with dark chocolate chunks, or mint chocolate chip. I don’t like any ice cream with a chocolate base.

    I haven’t heard of Jeni’s but don’t believe i’ll be trying it. A few years ago there were some new highly-touted brands that came out and I had to try them. I forgot one brand, but i think one was Talenti. Didn’t like it at all.

    As for Charlie’s Chips, we had those delivered for a while back in the late 70’s. So good.

    dedtired thanked OutsidePlaying
  • last year

    Here is my Goat Cheese Blackberry Chambord ice cream!



    The proprietor noted that my phone matched her decor, LOL. Her fridge!

    I can't tale a pic of my phone case but I cropped it out of my What to Wear selfie.




    dedtired thanked mtnrdredux_gw
  • last year

    I rate an ice cream shop based on their hot fudge! These days many shops only have that awful cold chocolate syrup. When you ask for hot fudge, chocolate syrup is not an equal substitute! I don't bother unless they have real hot fudge.


    If anyone is looking for a good store bought hot fudge, I found this one below. I usually find it at Sprouts.


  • last year

    The proprietor would fit in here very well :-)

  • last year

    Chispa - Coop's is the best!!

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    I rate an ice cream shop based on their hot fudge! These days many shops only have that awful cold chocolate syrup. When you ask for hot fudge, chocolate syrup is not an equal substitute! I don't bother unless they have real hot fudge.

    We can be friends! ;-)

    Hot fudge and fresh (not from a spray can) whipped cream are essential!

    I neglected to mention that OWowCow has spectacular hot fudge.

Sponsored
Kuhns Contracting, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Central Ohio's Trusted Home Remodeler Specializing in Kitchens & Baths