Can we see your house please .

Both option colors will look baby blue outdoors in the natural light.

SW Blustery Sky is the depth you need to look for. even that is too gray and dreary.

Look at your samples in bright sunlight.

Get a large board, at least the size of a shutter and paint a sample of the color to look at outside. The big box stores sell small pieces of drywall for patching. DH got a whole piece and cut it in fourths for our samples, but you can always get a smaller piece. Ultimately it doesn't matter how a color looks on someone else's house, you have to see it in person next to your siding in order to know if it's right for you. Look at it on all sides of the house, at different times of day and under clear and cloudy skies. It will look different under different light. I have sampled Smoke for use inside and it is a nice color, so I don't think you're wrong to start with it. After you see it you can decide if you want to try something darker, or more blue, or less blue, whatever.

The front door will have a six panel window

Photo please.

Context is key......................

Shutters, you want authentic with all the hardware, professionally measured and installed. If you are going the vinyl way, where shutters are screwed to the siding of the house, don't waste your money. In that case nix the shutters.

Sorry. i was having trouble getting the picture to upload.

The sampkes are on the door as follows: top right is niebla azul, top left is smoke, and bottom left is pale smoke. This is towards the end if the day with minimal sun.

They all look very similar to what's already there. Why are you changing the color? If you don't like what you have, try something completely different, like black, or dark green or red.