Software
Houzz Logo Print
pudgeder

Maybe I was rude.....

last year

My beloved brother in law passed away unexpectedly a few days ago. He was my husbands only brother. He was more than just my BIL, I considered him my brother, and he always referred to me as his sister. I loved him as such and all of us are devastated.


He was in his early 60's and as it was unexpected, it wasn't a surprise. He did have some underlying medical issues.


We've put the word out regarding memorial arrangements, some word of mouth & some via social media. I've been fielding phone calls & texts galore. Typical... I'm not complaining.


Here's where I think I may have been rude.


An old friend, whom I've not heard squat from in years sent me a text saying "what happened to brother-in-law?"

(For the record old friend was not friends w/BIL.)

No-- "Hello"

No -- " I'm so sorry"

No -- "How are you?"

Just "WHAT HAPPENED."


I didn't reply for about 30 mins. I was hoping for another follow up along the above. But no... it didn't come.


I simply replied "I'm coping. Thank you for asking."


Haven't received any reply.



Comments (45)

  • last year
    last modified: last year

    My sympathies on your loss. What @mtnrdredux_gw said, plus some people (your acquaintance) behave awkwardly in the face of death.

    pudgeder thanked Fun2BHere
  • last year

    Thank you both. I appreciate the sentiments.


  • last year

    You werent rude, your old friend was. Im sorry for your loss.

    pudgeder thanked Sheeshie
  • last year

    Agree with all above. You were not rude at all. Your 'friend' was and I think you handled it well.

    pudgeder thanked jane__ny
  • last year

    Sorry for the jolting news and that you lost someone who was truly a brother to you.


    Even nice people behave poorly around death. People are awkward, stupid, and this one a gossip queen. It sounds like you were hurt by her cold hearted text and you replied with a passive aggressive one. I think that is ok. Nobody in the midst of grief should be expected to go out of their way to express to someone why they were rude. Your reply conveyed a lot with few words and was more kind than "Shut the F-up." Way to go! Hang in there.

    pudgeder thanked Kendrah
  • last year

    Agree with all of the above. My condolences on the loss of your BIL.

    pudgeder thanked Allison0704
  • last year

    Agree with all sentiments and opinions expressed above. I’m so sorry about your BIL.

    pudgeder thanked Kswl
  • last year

    I am so sorry. 💜


    My father in law committed suicide, after some very troubling decisions he made came to light. (This was decades ago now, so this is not a raw memory now....)


    Some of the things people said, or asked, in the aftermath were stunning. I don't think most people mean to be hurtful, they just don't think how their questions may be felt by people who are reeling in loss and grief. I got asked what happened all the time, every day, for weeks. He blew his brains out felt like a rude reply, but honestly I didn't even know what else to say. However if I told people he killed himself, you can imagine the questions thereafter.


    My heart goes out to you.

    pudgeder thanked Ally De
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    I'm so sorry to hear about your brother in law. I think what you said was perfectly fine. Since it was a person you rarely interact with, I'd chalk it up to drama vampire syndrome. Some people are drama vampires, they swoop in to get a dose when they see an opportunity.

    As someone who runs away from drama, I don't understand it but I've seen it happen enough times to know that some people really thrive on it.

    pudgeder thanked deegw
  • last year

    The rude was on the other foot, not yours. Your reply was perfect, polite and squarely lets the 'friend' know what was missing.

    I'm sorry for your loss.

    pudgeder thanked DLM2000-GW
  • last year

    I'm so sorry for your loss. Such a difficult time made more challenging by a careless friend. I think your reply was totally appropriate and I hope your friend realizes how thoughtless she was and responds with more care and kindness.

    pudgeder thanked rubyclaire
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    I am so sorry for your loss. May your happier memories provide you a few smiles during this very sad time.

    You were not rude. I think so many ask how someone died thinking the answer might provide some false sense of protection that it wont happen to them or their loved one. The curiosity is driven by their own fear of mortality. Ignoring the question was the proper response.

    pudgeder thanked roarah
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    In situations like yours....of course, I always wonder what happened, and I think it is normal to wonder-but would never ask!

    pudgeder thanked OllieJane
  • last year

    I’m so sorry for your loss❤️ (and no, not rude )

    pudgeder thanked jojoco
  • last year

    That is insightful Roarah, I am glad you shared that.

    pudgeder thanked Ally De
  • last year

    So sorry for the lossof your BIL. So sad.

    That persons text sounded very abrupt. However, thats the problem with texts and emails. There is no voice inflection so messages are open to interpretation. This one does sound pretty rude, I agree. Your response was fine.

    pudgeder thanked dedtired
  • last year

    So sorry about your BIL. Your response was so inspired. No, you were not rude. Texting is fine for somethings, but it is not good for conversations

    pudgeder thanked Sherry8aNorthAL
  • last year

    I am so sorry for the loss of your dear BIL.

    You were not rude in your response to your thoughtless ”friend”.

    pudgeder thanked Irish2
  • last year

    I'm sorry for your loss and the uncomfortable things that come with it. I wonder if any death occurs that doesn't have at least one. I had a woman get very upset -- start crying over the news my father was being cremated. I don't know if it was cultural differences at work or the fact that she didn't get to see him to say goodbye. All I could do was assure her that it was what he wanted and it was okay -- he was gone and his spirit was free.

    I don't see your reply as rude or passive aggressive. More passive/indirect. You could have simply said "He died" and stated the obvious and left it. Simple, direct -- maybe direct to the point that would be seen as rude. Is it possible the BIL's conditions were not known to others and he was truly surprised while you were not? That doesn't excuse being rude, but might explain it.

    pudgeder thanked lascatx
  • last year

    Pudgeder, my heart goes out to you. I think your response could not have been better. Definitely not rude. I hope you can find comfort from friends who ask nothing of you, but do offer you what you need at this time.

    pudgeder thanked cyn427 (z. 7, N. VA)
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    I am so sorry for your loss. My heart goes out to you and to your BIL's family.

    You were not rude.

    For what it's worth - if I hear that someone has died and I know a person connected I send my condolences but I would never ever ever ask "what happened".

    pudgeder thanked blfenton
  • last year

    You were not in the least bit rude. I hope at some point your friend tries to redeem her oversight - there was no other way you could have responded and been true to your own feelings.

    I had something similar happen years ago and never received that apology and while we remained friends, I saw a selfish side to mine I hadn't known was there. My own grief was not acknowledged and I was grieving deeply at the time.

    I'm so sorry for your loss and the pain you are experiencing, Not all family is acquired by birth - there are also those who earn our love and trust and become part of our lives.

    pudgeder thanked morz8 - Washington Coast
  • last year

    Not rude at all and your response was very good. I'm sorry for your loss and wish you and your family find comfort in your many memories.

    pudgeder thanked orchidrain
  • last year

    I’m very sorry for your loss, pudgeder. So many people don’t know what to say in these situations, or what to write in a text. Your response was perfect. If your friend never acknowledges your feelings, you will know where you stand.

    pudgeder thanked OutsidePlaying
  • last year

    I might have been so taken aback that I would say, "He died". I am so very sorry for your loss.

    pudgeder thanked Springroz
  • last year

    I don't think you were rude; I think your response was brilliant. Sorry to hear of your brother in law's death and the loss that means to you.

    pudgeder thanked Olychick
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    So sorry to learn of this. Wishing you and your family solace.

    Skipped down to comment - I didn't read all the replies yet, but I do wonder if this person actually did not know what had happened and was awkwardly trying to verify what occurred? Some folks are not great at communicating by text - especially older people.

    It seems that, judging by the myriad stories from people dealing with bereavement, that they face many insensitive, awkward, uncomfortable comments from presumably well-meaning, but clueless people.

    And grieving people deserve an extra measure of grace, so I would not trouble myself over whether or not your reply came off as rude, which I don't think it did.

    pudgeder thanked carolb_w_fl_coastal_9/10
  • last year

    I'm so sorry for your loss. I hope your doing well. It sounds so sudden, that would be hard to cope with. He was young.


    "What happened"....is blunt. Sort of a "I'm in shock statement".

    pudgeder thanked nicole
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    I am one who deals awkwardly with death. I so badly want to say something consoling but everything I can think of seems so trite. I do draw the line at asking what happened. It just seems ghoulish. However, when DD died semi-suddenly, I let his friends and acquaintances know what had happened so they would not have to ask me.

    pudeger, I’m so sorry for your loss. I think that losing a sibling is very difficult. I think your response was appropriate.

    pudgeder thanked bbstx
  • last year

    I am sorry for your loss. I am also sorry that many of us do not know how to be eloquent around a sudden death and our texted responses, in particular, sound “off” (immature, too curious, nosy, you name it).

    My sister’s very close friend died recently. My sister’s initial text was well written - it clearly stated her friend was found dead, no information was provided or gotten as of that day, and she would keep us posted. She also asked us not to call her because she was deeply upset. We spoke yesterday, she called me, after the funeral. I know all the facts now but more importantly, how my sibling is doing around this profound and sudden loss.

    We are not great at this. Death is shocking sometimes, horrible many times and sad always. Give people some grace. If they say or text something that strikes you as rude, inconsiderate, nosy, immature - whatever - just ignore it. It’s hard to do, but I have found that our culture doesn’t do much to teach us how to handle sudden death.

    pudgeder thanked RedRyder
  • last year

    Thank you all for the kind words.


    I totally understand where you are coming from, Red. I do appreciate your comments.


    I may have taken it less harshly(?) if he actually knew my BIL or ever made contact with me more than once in a blue moon.

  • last year

    Pudgeder, I'm so sorry for your loss. Sending you thoughts of strength and comfort, peace and solace. Such a hard thing to go through.


    I get that some people don't know what to say. Too bad. Learn. It ain't hard. Go with the trite if you don't know any better. But it's better than being rude. Which she was.

    Actually Pudgeder, I think your response was certainly not rude and more than appropriate given the situation. I would not have been so considerate and would've responded with something far more sarcastic and harsh to someone so insensitive ... especially when I'm suffering, my patience wears thin.


    It is those in grief who are suffering who should be given grace and cut some slack.

    pudgeder thanked Annie Deighnaugh
  • last year

    Ally De, I agree. Suicide adds an extra layer of grief and pain. I try to explain to people that the worst things they can ask is how did he do it and why did he do it. It is so hard to talk about especially when the wound is fresh. But especially people don't realize the pain of asking why. If I knew why, then it implies I should've known and done something to stop it. Because it happened, I clearly didn't stop it, so it makes me complicit. It's not true, but when you're already reeling in grief and guilt, it just adds to the pain. No one asks you why someone died of cancer or heart disease. It's an unfair burden solely for survivors of suicide to bear.

    pudgeder thanked Annie Deighnaugh
  • last year

    That is it exactly Annie. People hear tone and judgement - whether it is there or not intended to be there. Emotions are in hyperdrive following the loss of a loved one. Death - and weddings! - are emotional landmines. Hard stuff.

    pudgeder thanked Ally De
  • last year

    Sending condolences and love your way.

    As I get older, one of things I no longer due is help Other People process My Grief. Do not spend another minute on this person until if, and when, you’re ready.

    pudgeder thanked 1929Spanish-GW
  • last year

    When people send unwanted probes it's perfectly acceptable to just hit delete and move on.

    pudgeder thanked arcy_gw
  • last year

    I am so very sorry for your loss. Wonderful in-laws can truly be a part of your family that you love and cherish and not everyone is lucky enough to have that. I am so sorry that you are going through this pain and grief and that your "friend" was rude. You were not rude. This person is lucky you responded at all.


    While it's not quite the same, we lost my mother-in-law about a year and a half ago. She passed very suddenly and the details of her death were not clear to us immediately and then even when we did understand the medical details it still left those of us close to her with so many unanswered questions. Similarly I had people asking me (thankfully me and not my husband) probing questions about her cause of death. Repeatedly and persistently. It was so rude and unkind. I really do not understand why people do this, except to satisfy their own curiosity. I never gave any of them a clear answer because, honestly, it's none of their business. Those close enough to her to know, know.

    pudgeder thanked pricklypearcactus
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    IMO, we humans are naturally curious creatures, however, too many of us do not often (or ever?) stop to think things through before opening our yaps...

    pudgeder thanked carolb_w_fl_coastal_9/10
  • last year

    I'm so sorry for the sudden loss of your BIL -it sounds like this is a big loss for you and your DH. You weren't rude at all -the texter was exceedingly rude. I wouldn't waste another second on it.

    pudgeder thanked Bestyears
  • last year

    I do believe, as others have alluded to, that we are constantly assessing our mortality. Hearing of sudden deaths is not the same for most of us as learning of the death of a cancer patient or a 97 year old. I think we all have some sense of the dangers surrounding us with different levels of worry about different things, or no worry at all about anything. So if we accept the potential risk of auto travel and air travel, we might not have bridge collpse on our radar. Or a sudden allergy to Macadamia nuts, or whatever. So, I don't wonder if the rude curiosity isn't just someone's natural desire to learn if there is something new to add to their possible worries/danger. And not really in a neurotic way, but in a somewhat natural survival way?

    pudgeder thanked Olychick
  • last year

    I think you're on to something Olychick.


    I am sure at several points in my too many decades on this earth, I asked "what happened" after someone passed away. Until I personally felt the pain and uncertainty "what happened" can cause....I was - sadly - oblivious to why such an innocent question can cause such hurt.


    Like so many things about our own personal evolution as humans, what we experience along the way shapes us all. "Oh my gosh, what happened?" can feel like it's coming from a place of surprise and honesty and showing an interest...or it can be a dagger into someone's heart.

    pudgeder thanked Ally De
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    Reading some more comments like Olychick's and carolb's, I do agree with the assessment that curiosity and attempting to understand death as it relates to our own mortality is probably part of why people ask. I imagine in most cases there isn't any intended malice. At the same time, I think the rudeness stems from disregard of the grief pudgeder (or other family) might be feeling and the insensitivity of the inquiry. Focusing on their own desire for information over the emotional needs of the person they are asking.

    I also think I fall into the awkward in the face of death camp as well. Mostly I am just uncertain how much space to give someone vs trying to reach out. I feel guilty to this day that I didn't reach out more to a few people when they lost someone, but I also didn't know how or when it was appropriate. In hindsight, I think I should have reached out more just to let them know I was thinking of them. I guess over time we learn to do better.

    pudgeder thanked pricklypearcactus
  • last year
    last modified: last year

    I agree Prickly Pear. My father died suddenly when I was 9 and in those days (or in my family/circle) people didn't really know how to help a child deal with that kind of loss/grief. So death was a big trigger/button for me that I avoided for many years, refusing to go to funerals and probably not offering condolences like I should have. In a bizarre coincidence, my husband died at the same age my dad had, of the same thing. I had no choice but to deal with the situation and my grief. (probably my compounded grief). We had a very large circle of wonderful friends and the outpouring of love and concern was unbelievable. And I learned that you gotta show up for others. It meant so much to me, especially the people who talked to me about why they loved my husband, or those who wrote about him in their cards. I had a difficult time with people who knew us well, who would say "Sorry for your loss," instead of something like, "I am so sorry about Tom." I know now people were just doing their best but the impersonal nature of those "loss" comments really hurt.

    It was a harsh lesson in why it's important to show up, to offer what you can, love, help, kind words, food, etc. I go to memorial services now for people I didn't even know if I have some kind of relationship with their spouse or child, etc.

    I had a convo with a cousin in her early 50's whose best friend's dad had just died. She was conflicted about the memorial service because she already had other plans. I really encouraged her to go to the service, for her friend. And to think about how it would feel if her friends don't show up when her mom dies. Trying to pass on a life lesson I learned.

    pudgeder thanked Olychick
  • PRO
    last year

    Very sorry your brother died.

    • People often just don't know what to say, especially if they've never experienced the same type of loss.
    • Even if they have experienced loss, they may still be so traumatized they haven't figured out how to be supportive.
    • How people deal with death can be very different.

    pudgeder thanked mdln