Whatever color you pick for the body of the house, I would paint that triangle up high on the front the same color. It looks silly up there now. It needs to be the same color as the house. I would also paint both garage doors the body color of the house, so they dont stand out so much. It will balance out the house once its all one color except for the trim. Most here, will tell you to remove the shutters, however, since you have to remove them to paint, use that time, to see if you like the house better with shutters, or without. Personally, I would pick a cream over white for the paint. I am not fond of white houses, so that is a personal preference.

I'd do a crisp navy for the shutters. It's classic, but interesting, unlike gray.

Some visual with Blue-Green shutters and door