Software
Houzz Logo Print
mnmamax3

Primary bath tile selection: porcelain panels or large format tile?

9 months ago

Making the hubs crazy - please help!!


Remodeling entire bathroom:

- All new tile, fixtures, lighting - grout will be closely color matched to blend.

- Removing jetted tub and adding freestanding tub

- Replacing shower wall between tub and shower with glass

- new shower will be roughly 48" square (maybe 47")

- Adding 6" ledge just under the window that will carry right into the shower to hold shampoo, etc

- The tub fixtures will come out of the ledge wall

- Vanity and linen storage (maple) may be restained, enameled or replaced - top will be replaced

- After much discussion about changing the overall layout - we are not changing the layout.





I am obsessed with the large porcelian ceramic panels for hardly any grout and crisp clean corners. Prefer a cement look with warmer tones as our trim is all BM-Feather Down. Just not finding the exact look I want. The corner is northwest facing and will be brighter with new lighting and the glass wall but we are wary of too-blue grey tones.


What we have tried:

Mirage Pietra Grey - too blue-toned


What might work:

Mirage Nyuma Torching - the dye lot on the full panel pieces in stock are too grey and don't have the definition of the tile version. Tile version is nice and I am checking to see the tone of the 24x48 tiles.

Adessi 15x30 Tiles (Floor and Decor) in Sundance II and Sundance Night. Both have matching hex tiles that will be used on the curbless shower floor.




This is Sundance night and Nyuma Torching at the store.



These are the two Adessi tiles in my bathroom with natural lighting. I would say adessi light tile is lighter than Torching. SW- Skyline steel is a paint color we have used in other areas of our home that goes with the lighter Adessi tile.


What would you recommend for this project? And what for the vanity counter/paint?

Light floor, dark shower and ledge?

Dark floor, light shower and ledge?

Does it look stupid to have two tiles exactly the same design but different colors (see our existing brown bathroom).


Is there a perfect cement look porcelain panel I am overlooking? Should I just get over it and go with the tile? Our tile guy can miter smaller tiles as well but still would have grout between new pieces of tile. Thanks so much for the help!

Comments (7)

  • 9 months ago
    last modified: 9 months ago

    In the last 25 years we have remodeled and/or built new 5 homes. Every home has some design of the time tile/grout bathroom. It is hard not to get into the vibe. My daughter just did a huge reno on her house. My advice? Don't do tile in the shower and ceiling. It is a nightmare to keep the tile and the grout clean.

    Because it is a remodel, look at the Kohler Sterling Accord seated shower, it is a four piece install. Then put your tile 24" x 48" tiles on the bathroom floor (easier to clean the grout) and consider wallpaper to make the space fabulous.

    https://www.lowes.com/pd/Sterling-Accord-White-5-Piece-Alcove-Shower-Kit-Common-36-in-x-60-in-Actual-36-in-x-60-in/1000618737?store=&cm_mmc=shp--c--prd--bth--ggl--CRP_SHP_PLA_BTH_Online_Mid_Priority(E+Band)--1000618737--online--0-_-0amp;gclsrc=aw.ds&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=21048204880&gclid=Cj0KCQiA0KrJBhCOARIsAGIy9wCQHz5bVMi2uGEEVKvId1DHMB1zuYbNOIsutNqZdOJxGVfNLZw86sEaAjqCEALw_wcB


    Transitional Bathroom · More Info


    mnmamax3 thanked User
  • 9 months ago
    last modified: 9 months ago

    Thanks Judy! Wallpaper is something I had not considered. My style skews more modern/industrial but that could provide some interesting texture. Thank you!

  • 9 months ago

    I would not have a solid wall between the tub and shower, at least glass on the top half to let more natural light into the shower.

    I would use the same color/tile throughout, continuity makes a small space feel more lux.

    :ight tiles on the walls and a medium color on the floor, too dark and it looks like a hole.

    especially north facing. keep the shower light and keep the painted surfaces the same color/hue. At least three light sources, ceiling, wall sconces, and mood lighting. Soft fabric roman blinds for the windows, light wood finishes to add warmth to the room.

    Will you really use the free standing tub? If you have one in another bathroom in the house, eliminate it and make the shower larger.

    no bench in the shower, get a teak stool. How much ledge do you need? do a recess to hide the shampoo bottles, it's not a retail display.


    mnmamax3 thanked Lyn Nielson
  • PRO
    9 months ago

    IMO always keep tile schoices to a min. in a bathroom You do not have space for aFS tub IMO since they look best in huge open spaces and tyou need a min . if 12" all around the tub to actully clen around it and even then you almpst have to stand on your head to get behind on the long wall If you do not use the tub why have one if somehwere in the home there is another tub? I like 12 24 porcelain tile for both bathroom floors and shower walls the same tile only smaller for shower floor. Use a tile you like I prefer a solid color in a tone that works with my bedrom decor if this is a master bath The fewer finishes the less likely you will want change down the road . The bigger the tile the better your tile setter needs to be . I also like a stacked pattern and matching grout .Since this appears to be arenovation my advice is deal with the closet entry not from the bathroom but propably too late now

  • 9 months ago

    Good advice already - just another vote for a sleek alcove tub, the free standing models look best floating in a large space imo

  • 9 months ago

    Thanks Patricia and la_la Girl. We had considered a bunch of options for entry into the bathroom (placing the entry where the toilet is and could go either way but ultimately it really lost storage and minimized options for toilet placement.

    I get what you mean about keeping things simple. Not planning on accent tiles. The hex is only for the floor and will match whatever color our floor tile is. Just looking for a base to build on with decor, lighting etc.

    Would the dark grey floor tile work with the light tile on the walls?

    Our neighbor has the same floor plan (their ceiling is vaulted - ours is not). Does this look too crowded?

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert