Maybe not what you’re wanting to hear, but I like it the way it is.

The most glaring thing, IMO, is the bright white garage door. I'd paint it to match the siding. I like the gables, as they are. If you wanted to bring some color into your house, like painting the gables and shutters a warm green, that might work, but just painting them without a goal doesn't make sense to me.

Congrats on your new home. It looks well tended to.

The gables are very attractive. Remove the shutters. They are not the correct side for the windows anyway and don't add to the look of the home. Paint the garage door the same color as the siding. Paint the top of the light post fixture black.

I like the ideas to blend the garage and the exterior walls plus the gables a cream with the shutters removed, then paint all the trim slightly darker. Paint the lamp black & add path lighting