Software
Houzz Logo Print
bellarosa009

I need your opinion..

6 months ago

I ordered this rose from an online vendor. The rose doesn't appear healthy to me. The branches on the left keep flopping and the leaves are turning yellow. It's still in the pot that it came in.


When I contacted the vendor, they asked for a pic - I sent them this pic - and they said that I can monitor the rose (they thought it had good chance of surviving) and they will keep one on hold for when I place another order. In other words, they aren't going to send me a replacement. I'm not happy, especially given the price of shipping today. I have ordered from them before (over 20 years at least), but none in this condition. What are your thoughts on this?


Comments (12)

  • 6 months ago
    last modified: 6 months ago

    If it were me I would strip off all the yellow or dried out leaves. Inspect the canes for bent damage and cut them off it they are damaged. Then plant it in something bigger. It looks too big for the pot it is in. Take pictures of it periodically but to me it looks like it will survive. You did the right thing letting them know so you can get a replacement if it doesn't.

    bellarosa thanked mmmm12COzone5
  • 6 months ago

    Thanks, mmmm12COzone5. Yes, I was planning on repotting it. Honestly, I'm not happy with the way the vendor responded to my request as the rose is clearly distressed. Fingers crossed that it makes it.

  • 6 months ago

    The top growth is thin and gangly, but it has a lot of it, which is good. I'd water it really well and then asap put it in a one gallon pot with good potting soil. Hopefully when you pull it out of the band, it will have great roots. I'd wait to give it a major haircut until it gets established in its new pot... the leaves are providing the energy. And don't over-pot it... I've found that bands grow best when gradually potted up. What variety is it?

    bellarosa thanked susan9santabarbara
  • 6 months ago

    Thanks everyone for your suggestions. The rose is Cornelia.

  • 6 months ago
    last modified: 6 months ago

    They should not have sent such a scraggly specimen, but I am confident that you will have it sparkling robust in no time. At that time, send them a photo of it at it's new thriving state.

    Moses.

    bellarosa thanked Moses, Pitt PA, cold W & warm/humid S z6
  • 6 months ago

    Honestly, for a "band" that was in transit at this time of year, that does not look bad to me -- Par for the course I would say.
    If you see anything diseased or damaged you can cut it off. Might not hurt to give a little tip prone regardless. Once it is potted up, it will likely start pushing lots of new growth.

    bellarosa thanked philipatx
  • 6 months ago

    The rose is Cornelia.

    As someone who pruned four of them yesterday, that's how it grows. It is not a robustly upright rose, but a rose that drapes gracefully. Given that, your rose looks like a fine specimen.

    It also isn't the hardiest rose in the world. I keep expecting to lose one (or more) but so far they have been snowline hardy after legitimate zone 6 temperatures.

    bellarosa thanked mad_gallica (z5 Eastern NY)
  • 6 months ago
    last modified: 6 months ago

    Ohhh, Cornelia! That is one that I wanted to try. It is on the nearly thornless list and I was thinking how your picture didn't show thorns so I was wondering which rose it was. I really like the flowers on it.

    Did you get this from High Country Roses? I usually pick mine up at the green house and if they are big like that but are jammed in with other big ones they haven't yet had the opportunity to strengthen their canes by being exposed to wind so they kind of flop. Also some roses are naturally floppy as mad_gallica mentions in their post. If I had seen that one in person I absolutely would have chosen it because it has really long canes and the base shows thick older canes so the root system is likely very good. I think it will take off once planted. I always put my new roses right in the ground after the acclimation period so don't have any experience with potting them up.

    I have watched the packers who usually strip off the bad leaves so likely the yellowing happened during shipping. Sometimes in shipping they are too long in the box, get bent in the box because they are too big or get exposed to high heat or extreme cold. Any of that could have happened to this rose but if it did it should easily over come it once acclimated to the outdoors and planted. It is much more fun to get a perky fully leafed rose right out of a box but to me this one doesn't look too bad and frankly that thicker base stem and the long growth would still have lead me to chose it over others.

    bellarosa thanked mmmm12COzone5
  • 6 months ago

    I think it looks good for a band of Cornelia. I might start with a 1 gal or 2 gal pot size to let it size up. Cornelia takes a while to get really going.

    bellarosa thanked Sheila z8a Rogue Valley OR
  • 6 months ago
    last modified: 6 months ago

    I purchased the rose from Rouge Valley Roses. I'm transplating it to a slightly larger pot. I'm loving that it's nearly thornless and there's 2 small pretty flowers. Thanks again everyone for your advice. I'm hopeful now that she will rebound. Maybe the shipping was too much for her - LOL!

  • 6 months ago

    Give her time. She really will get it together in time.