Not my favorite. Seems harsh.

Not my favorite. Seems harsh I do like your other ceiling fixtures.

Thank you. Appreciate the feedback!

Agree with first two statements. Seriously, do creators or interior designers give any thought to cleaning and maintaining some of these light fixtures?

What a dusting nightmare.

wouldn’t be my first choice. You might want to try to coordinate the lighting . Choose a fixture that would work with what you already have in both rooms

Options for fixtures

The barrel shade came back with avengence a decade or more ago. It's not my choice ever. Dusting with a feather duster would be a quick job. I see the black tie-in with your other hardware but I think over all you can do better.

agree with the others - wouldn’t be my choice but it’s personal, I’d love an oversized lantern there but that’s a me thing

Hmmm. The black kinda echoes the door pulls in the background. I can sense an airiness. There is a sparkle. Is this what they call serendipity?

I agree with your thought that it’s too modern for table. Seeing 3 different styles of hanging lights from one vantage point would not please me in my home. It’s hard to tell the different sizes from the pictures but would this light over table work in your room with sofa & fireplace? It’s an interesting light & might add a nice feature to that sitting room. I’d want related or same lights over the island & the table. Those lights over the island look like they’d work over the table.

I do think the chandelier feels a little too heavy and visually dominant for this room. With the round wooden table and the softer look of the space, I’d choose something lighter and more sculptural, perhaps with a rounded shape.

I recently looked at 8 very different moon-inspired lights, including several pendant designs that might give you some ideas for a lighter and more interesting alternative:

https://youtu.be/g-R98L8EdII