I like the top one.

I like the third one down. It doesnt give the bluish tint to it, on my screen, that the top two and bottom two, do.

I think the top one, bottom one are both nice. (I tend to like the darker bottom one better) 2nd one also works

You need wider shutters for them to look appropriate on your windows

Or, have you thought about removing them completely and just paint the trim around the windows black?

for your garage doors, I'd look into something a bit diff, maybe w/windows, and for sure some iron carriage hardware. that would look better w/the colonial vibe

or something like this:

They’re all nice. Both top and bottom read blue-ish on my screen.

Agree with Beth regarding wider shutters.

What she said^^^. I had exactly the same thoughts as chloebud.

It seems you want a gray house. They all look blue except for the 2nd one. The 3rd is a teal blue.

According to your description that leaves #2.

I agree that number 2 is closest to the color you say that you want. I know you didn’t ask, but I think if you have the budget you should really replace the tiny shutters with wider ones that “fit” the windows. They would give the front of the house so much more pesesence

This is SW Smokey Blue

I also like this darker greenish gray color for your home

You may be considering this already but changing the landscaping will help refresh the home too. This is just an AI pic so it’s not accurate but just gives you an idea of things to consider before painting your home.

The Sherwin Williams Web Blue would be a beautiful choice too.

Thanks Emily for doing all these mocks! What color is the one you called dark greenish grey? we are leaning away from green tint but curious what you used.

Recommend you paint the garage doors, banding boards, and downspouts in the body color. And paint the screen door in the front door color.

All those gray samples you show are just blah. I like some of Emily’s deeper, stronger tones.

I’m glad you’re getting more sophisticated, wider shutters.

I prefer the bottom blue color! https://www.buildersservicecompany.com/how-to-choose-a-siding-color 

Hey Bridgett, it’s pretty close to SherwinWilliams Night Owl. It’s done through AI so always paint an actual sample on your house, like you’ve done with the other samples, to make sure what it looks like on the actual house.