refinishing pine floors

3 months ago

Our 20 year old home has wide plank, high gloss pine floors throughout all 3 stories. Due to a kitchen remodel, floors
on 1st floor were refinished but look significantly different than original flooring and we are super disappointed. Contractor used 1 coat Bona Amber and 2 coats of Bona traffic. End result is a much more pale floor without the shine of original. Looking for advice on how to potentially fix this? I suspect we need to sand and start over. Would an oil based polyurethane give us a result similar to original floors or should we add a stain as well? Super disappointed.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

millworkman
3 months ago
The exact process of how he "Refinished" the floor would help. All steps taken? All products used?
katesamhenry
Original Author
3 months ago
Fully sanded. Applied 1 coat Bona Amber seal followed by 2 coats of Bona traffic (water-based polyurethane)
Related Professionals
Trenton Flooring Contractors · Manhattan Flooring Contractors · Ashland Tile and Stone Contractors · Salisbury Tile and Stone Contractors · Beaumont Tile and Stone Contractors · Virginia Beach Tile and Stone Contractors · Syracuse Tile and Stone Contractors · Santa Fe Tile and Stone Contractors · Mount Vernon Kitchen Remodelers · Springfield Kitchen Remodelers · Emporia Kitchen Remodelers · Gulfport Kitchen Remodelers · Lynchburg Kitchen Remodelers · Martinsburg Kitchen Remodelers · Glenwood Springs Kitchen Remodelers
dan1888
3 months ago
last modified: 3 months ago
Too bad. That new finished floor tone is currently the most popular for new construction. To get what you prefer sample treatments on small areas are the norm. You pick one or ask for more. General Finish has warm tone oil based poly. Glossy is available.
katesamhenry
Original Author
3 months ago
Thanks - pretty surprised they didn’t do samples. We will be refinishing and will definitely sample before proceeding. It’s just such a mismatch from the old which carries through the rest of the house
dan1888
3 months ago
If you redid the rest to match, it would be a very strong positive at resale. Those extra wude planks modern tone with matte finish are like gold, mo.
katesamhenry
Original Author
3 months ago
Appreciate that feedback - wish we liked it more. Also learning how challenging it is to live in the house with work being done. Not sure we could handle doing floors in rest of the house. Guess the shiny orange floors have grown on us.