Software
Houzz Logo Print
designassassin

Which exterior light fixture looks better?

20 days ago

I'm trying to decide which option is better. For context, this is the back view of the house. The siding is Photoshopped to look like what will ultimately be installed (board and batten on lower half and horizontal on upper.) The issues complicating the decision:


Option 1: would love the symmetrical look but the right sconce looks off because there's not much space to work with on that side.


Option 2: I picture this sconce as being more at eye level. Seems out of place way up there. Worth mentioning, I have this exact sconce next to all the doors of the house (front, side, garage.)


Option 3: Hue flood light. It probably won't be able to split the siding so I'm not even sure I could use this one.


The rest of the exterior is transitional/modern. I thought about a gooseneck light at the gable but that's too traditional looking. Please chime in and vote in the poll.

Two Hinkley Manhattan sconces flanking window
One Hinkley Manhattan sconce at gable
One Hue flood light at gable

Comments (9)

  • 19 days ago

    Lights are used to light your way to the front door and I do not feel they should flank a window. Can we see pictures of where the front door or porch is as that is where the lights should be.

    designassassin thanked Lorraine Leroux
  • PRO
    19 days ago

    I agree we need to see the whole front of the house where lighting is most important and honestly if symmetry is something you crave wahy was the window placed there ?In my back yard I like lighting for purpose like the seating area and the dining area and maybe some nice accent for a tree or shrub. Also one above the back door and the shed or garage.. I guess I need more context

    designassassin thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • 19 days ago

    No sconces are needed by the windows or gable.

    designassassin thanked apple_pie_order
  • 19 days ago

    To be clear, this is the back of the house (facing the backyard.) I didn't build the house from scratch so I didn't have any control over where the window was placed.


    The photo below show more of the area. This has been heavily Photoshopped to look like the end result. The Hinkley Manhattan light will go by the door leading into the garage, this I know.


    As for the window area, I'm trying to balance form with function... a flood light at the gable (where an old-school flood light is currently located as shown in photo below) would probably give me the amount of light I want, but those don't really look that good. 🫤


    Since I'm getting new siding and they'll be removing the existing flood light during that process I decided to see if I could find something to replace it with that looked better.



  • 19 days ago

    No sconces by the window.

    What do you need to light up?

    They sell smaller flood lights that can go under your soffit/fascia. Pick a color for the flood light (white, brown or black) that best matches your soffit/fascia paint color.

    designassassin thanked chispa
  • 18 days ago

    AW So it is the back of the house. I would do a similar flood light like the one you have and place it on the peak and the light to go outwards. It needs to not look stylish as it serves a purpose which is a flood light that has a motion sensor for protection. I would then put a nice pair or even a single next to your door. They could also be motion.

    designassassin thanked Lorraine Leroux
  • PRO
    18 days ago

    Will suggest that you use landscape lighting placed at ground level to uplight your house instead of mounting the fixtures directly on the house.

    designassassin thanked Norwood Architects
  • 16 days ago

    Thanks everyone for the perspective!