Software
Houzz Logo Print
mxk3

Neighbor cut down a big tree darn it

2 months ago

There is no point to this post other than to ventilate, and maybe some of you can commiserate -- many of you probably can.


You may or may not recall that I planted quite a few trees and taller shrubs down by the road and along the property line for more privacy. I live on a dirt road, but it's a major county dirt road and we get a fair share of traffic. And, of course, road dust.


Today the next-door neighbor cut down a large paper birch tree. In fairness, it wasn't that attractive of a tree (papers usually aren't, not in the landscape anyway), but the large canopy shielded the view of my home from that angle, and helped to keep down the road dust. Nothing I can do about it. I'm not mad -- it's their tree after all, it's just that because our parcels are long and narrow the neighbor's trees and shrubs help to hide the homes from view from an angle as the cars are driving down the road, and help shield from the road dust (as mine do for my neighbors).


I can't yet see how I can plant more trees on my own property to fill that hole because of the way the overhead wires are. I'll fully assess once they're done doing whatever they're doing out there (it's a long weekend...more trees might be on the docket to be felled IDK). Maybe I can figure something out. I suppose I could just ask them if they are going to plant a replacement tree or trees, that might be in their plan. I hope so.



Comments (12)

  • 2 months ago

    I totally understand and can relate! One of our neighbors cut down a mature tree near our shared property line a few years ago. We had loved the shade and the privacy it gave on that portion of the yard. It was fully their tree, so nothing we could do, but it was definitely a bummer.

  • 2 months ago

    So sorry to hear it. It’s so good when you can share in a neighbor's landscaping. Can you plant some additional trees further in from the road?

  • 2 months ago

    Sorry to hear that. my skin crawls whenever i hear a chainsaw in my neighborhood

  • 2 months ago
    last modified: 2 months ago

    I believe my township has an ordinance to get approval before a tree is cut down. I never followed this, I just plant two trees for every one I took out..., and I only had them chopped down due to...., disease or, one, being hit by a drunk driver! Depends on where your live, in my zone, trees grow fairly rapidly. Had to remove an island of Eastern Hemlocks recently due to Wooly Adelgid. Miss them and OMG is it so much hotter in my yard now!



    All these Hemlocks had to be removed, gorgeous tree but now in serious decline!

    Also lost two Maples, Sugar and Red and replaced them Southern Magnolias.





  • 2 months ago

    ^^ Why did you lose the sugar maples?

  • 2 months ago

    Would a large shrub work?

  • 2 months ago

    OMG, you don't have to tell me twice! I'm right there with you commiserating! I'm sure you've seen me kvetching here the last two years about the local utility company, cutting down every tree on the street! Every tree around town - and neighboring towns. It's awful. Huge old oaks, maples, and many other smaller trees just gone. I used to live on a tree-lined, tree-canopied road, and instead of driving under a lovely green canopy, as one drives down the street one sees nothing but a row of telephone poles, one after another after another. Sigh...


    And it's not just utility companies. I guess I'm just not a sun worshipper or a lawn junkie, so I don't get why people cut down perfectly good trees. When we first bought this property, our neighbor (perfect lawn, sunny yard with pool etc) came over and one of the first things he said was, so, are you going to get rid of some of these trees? (our not-quite-one-acre lot had over 50 large trees). We looked at him in some confusion and said why? One of the reasons we bought the house was because we loved the lot!


    And whether it's a neighbor, or a utility company, or the municipality, yes, cutting down a tree (or planting one!) often affects more than just that property owner. A tree, especially in an area with smaller lots, affects lots of properties.


    I'm also in the same boat about replacing things and having to worry about the overhead wires. I won't get my lovely shade back, but I am trying to plant shrubs that get about 6-12 feet tall under them. There is an intersection at the corner of my property where some trees were lost and while I don't get road dust like you do, there is traffic, headlights, etc., not to mention wind, etc and of course just the need for privacy. I put in some hollies (a mix of deciduous and evergreen) some chamaecyparis, and a couple of viburnum. They are still small but I am hoping they do the trick!


    Good luck with your situation and let us know how you proceed!

    :)

    Dee



  • 2 months ago

    Oh wow, Dee -- your situation is by far worse than one tree I'm whining about, that's just awful. I remember you posting about shrubs to plant down by the road. Is it coming along?

  • 2 months ago
    last modified: 2 months ago

    Sorry to hear that. I have bad road-dust too, as the neighbor's very steep driveway causes rain to puddle on the road there, and when mixed w/dirt & then dries, causes my car (w/a dead windshield-washer) to "dust-up" quickly. I had cars in the long past that didn't even have a windshield-washer & I'm just gonna live w/it using a water bucket and rag.


    Dee, I just saw 2 rather large and well-formed sugar maples in front of a house that instead of just being cut down for no reason, were chopped down to their main trunks covered w/huge stubs. They must have thought those would sprout back from that butchering?!? Those 2 trees are "dead trees walking".

  • 2 months ago
    last modified: 2 months ago

    I am so sorry and I do indeed understand your pain. We had new neighbors move in about 15 years ago. They cut down every tree in their back yard (all very old Oak trees more than 100 years old) because, as he told me, the husband likes "the golf course look." I guess he has never noticed how many trees line a course from the start to the cup. We bought our house because of the trees, especially one huge Willow Oak that must be 200 years old. We had 9 Oaks when we moved in and now we have 14 plus numerous other native trees that we planted.

    I would chat with them and get around to asking if they are planning to put in another tree at some point in the conversation..

    ps. Our property and that of all our 7 closest neighbors backed to a 4-acre property that was the last remnant of an old Oak forest. A couple of years ago, our wonderful neighbor who owned the property died and her daughter sold to a developer who clear-cut the land, knocked down her almost 100 year old home, and built four really unattractive McMansions. No more wildlife there. Our home is the only one whose view of all that is blocked by trees both from our backyard, their backyards, and the satellite view. Yay. I hope you can regain your privacy, porkchop.

  • 2 months ago

    I hate that this happened to you @porkchop_z5b_MI. This has always been a fear of mine. It’s unavoidable and in many cases inevitable but it still hurts.

  • 2 months ago

    Could you offer to replacetve tree with a different one perhaps more to their liking? Do you know the readon they removed it?